The Hill

133 Scott Ave, Castleton-On-Hudson
(518) 336-4010

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mike Rappazzo

The first time we have ever dined here and we're by far impressed!!! Very home like feeling! Food was amazing, as well as the staff! Can't believe this hidden gem is less then a mile from our home. Portions were bigger then expected! 5 stars! We will be eating here again!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Sppeghetti and Meatballs

Brenda Johnson

Our first (but not last!) visit to The Hill. Our waitress was top notch, as was the food!! (Husband had scallop scampi and I had the shrimp & scallop Alfredo) The warm bread brought to table was perfect while we waited for our food on a cold rainy night...our salads were good (some of the lettuce was a bit past it's prime) but the house made blue cheese dressing made up for that! Delicious! Food came quickly and was served piping hot! Portions were generous too! Anxious to go back to try other things!Only suggestion for owners would be perhaps a fresh coat of paint for the dining room....looks a bit tired...

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kelly Harrison

We just had a family dinner, group of 13 for an anniversary celebration. First time here in several years (since the last owners). Everything was great; service, food, drinks and competitive prices.

Mary Ann

We're having dinner at The Hill tonite and listening to guitarist and vocalist Eric Peter. He is wonderful. You should hear him sing "Hallelujah." Awesome. The food at The Hill is truly delicious whether you want a pizza or something fancier. Come over soon!

Vegetarian options: Yes.

Kid-friendliness: Yes.

Quinn Coffey

Amazing Dinner. Started off with the Creamy Chicken with herbed rice as an appetizer. Absolutely delicious! It came out at the perfect temperature. Not too hot where I had to blow on it for 5 minutes, but not cold at all. I could start eating the warm, creamy comforting food immediately. On the topic of taste, also very good. The broth was creamy and flavorful. A great amount of chicken too! This was a great start for our meal. For my entree, I had the Buffalo Mac and Cheese. Same thing as the appetizer, absolutely perfect. The cheese was creamy and delicious, it also surprisingly had a bit of a kick to it which I enjoyed. It also came with a nice surprise, lots of grilled chicken on top. The buffalo chicken was great, and was a great combo with the Mac and Cheese. For desert, I had their special brownie. It was also good. A very cake like consistency, but that didn't really bother me. It also came with loads of whipped cream and a scoop of ice cream which was another good surprise. The food is obviously very important, but another important thing is the price. I had an appetizer, entree, and desert while my partner had appetizer and entree. The bill came over to a little over $50 which is pretty good these days. Also, the entree and desert portions were huge. Leftovers were needed! So, the price was great for what we are getting. A random brief topic, the homey small town atmosphere was definitely apparent. Seemed like lots of consistent supporters come back often. Everybody was nice and friendly. The final aspect was service. It was great! We consistently got water refills and orders were taken at a perfect time. Food didn't take too long either. It wasn't a busy night, so sitting down to leaving took basically an hour which is also pretty good. Overall, it was a fantastic dinner and definitely plan to come back in the future.

Natalie T

Love this restaurant, always great food. Unfortunately on the most recent visit the cutlery and glasses were extremely dirty, as if the dishwasher had no soap in it. They replaced the old dirty glasses with new dirty glasses ...

Parking: Parking is on a dirt parking lot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 4

fba5

This restaurant had a homey feel. There is a dining room on one side & a bar area on the other side. The salad that came with our entrees was fine. Our waitress told us that both salad dressings we'd selected, balsamic & blue cheese, were homemade as was the hot bread that was served. I would have given this place 4 stars but the breading on my Veal Sorrento entree was borderline burnt! FYI, my entree was a large enough portion for 2 meals. My husband enjoyed his entree though. Although the menu leans toward Italian food (including pizza & calzones), you can get other entrees like salmon as well as burgers, wings, mac & cheese, etc. I did like that for folks who prefer less carbs that available sides besides pasta included choices such as potatoes, seasonal vegetables, asparagus, broccoli, etc. Note they only are open from dinner, starting at 4 pm from Wed. to Sun.

Melissa Walker

Got take out last evening. First time customer, although only live 4 miles away. Excited to finally try it since Scarnatos.Ordered Seafood alfredo, it was awesome.! Bread great, salad great. Also ordered chicken parm. When we got home we just assumed they forgot to include the pasta. I called just to let them know, and I was directed to look at their pics on Fb. I guess the chick parm does not automatically come with pasta. Who knew? When I explained to the lady on the other line it was an error on my part, she once again directed me towards the pictures. I let her know I was a1st time customer and did not know this and assumed when they asked me what side dish I wanted I just ordered French fries. Once again I was directed towards the Facebook pictures. I was honestly waiting for a simple "Hey the next time you drive by why don't you pick up a side of pasta to try it out or Hey next time you order we can throw you a side dish of pasta." To tell the truth I really didn't care to try the pasta but my principle is that at least should have been offered to me. I don't need free food nor do I want free food but if the offer was extended I would think that that is great customer service. What I experienced was not great customer service as far as I'm concerned. Now unfortunately ,since I drive by there every day for work and I only live 4 miles away I will not be going back to this establishment although I absolutely loved the seafood pasta.

Catherine Dwyer

I’ve had better pizza at domino’s ?. Don’t know what happened or if they got a new cook. However, the wings were awesome.

Lillian Cardell

Great food. Great service! The staff at The Hill were able to accommodate our fairly large group of 7 without a problem and a fairly busy night. Our server, Katie, was amazing! She kept all of our orders straight and was very quick to see when we needed something.

Parking: Plenty of parking.

Pamela Ray

I purchased wings tonight which were tough and barely chewable. i brought them back and was refunded. I was also informedper house manager that i seem to have a problem with all my orders. I have puchased food from them several times with adequate satisfaction. this stems from me questioning their infection control during height of pandemic. bar was packed and everyone in there was eating . i should have reported to DOH> but did not . this is 2nd time out of 15 purchases i had an issues. yet i was blamed. i would think you would welcome feedback. i guess not. maybe 1 out of 10 dishes does suck. dont blame me. find out why. . me or mine will never purchase from the hill and my son used to proudly work there

Donna Kent

Wonderful place. Great decor, owner and staff made you feel very welcome. Food was excellent!

Michael LaGrave

The staff were friendly and attentive.Food was large portioned and delicious.Nice area for outdoor dining.Highly recommend.

Parking: Parking lot was very close and spacious.

Brittney Cunningham

The Hill is a wonderful restaurant. They have a full bar, dining room, and patio. The staff are all friendly and the food is delicious! You can certainly tell the cook loves the job because of the creativity in specials! The pizza is delicious also! We eat here a few times a month.

Brian Gleason

Very glad to see a locally-owned business packed on a Friday night. Everyone was very friendly. The Buffalo Chicken Mac & Cheese was delicious, and a decent portion. I would definitely go there again.

Loading...