Jack Mc Carthy's Pub

2582 Middle Country Rd, Centereach
(631) 467-9105

Recent Reviews

Stephen

Went a few weeks ago with a friend. Bartenders were great and responsive despite a packed crowd. Atmosphere was fun, with a great mix of ages and lifestyles represented. Place has been there forever so they must be doing something right.

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 4

Student of growth

Good food the menu prices are wrong from what they actually are besides that good-looking bartender, and they have quick

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Kelly Kaplan

It's like my Cheers, can't get any better of an atmosphere and the staff is amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Emc Sq.

They need a pool table in the empty side room. Service was great, staff was very personable.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loukia Howard

Get food amazing

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ham Sandwich with Fries, Onion Rings, Chicken Quesadilla, Turkey Salad Sandwich with Fries, Turkey Salad Sandwich, Ham Sandwich, Corn Beef Sandwich

Joshua G

Fantastic. If your going to do St. Patrick's day, do it here

Terry Parrett

Good for what it is, but I had 2 bottles of Bud, a burger and fries for lunch, and somehow my bill came to $32.

Eileen Panico

They have a great bartender who also cooks but that makes for slow service... Worth it because the foods isnt terrible. Beer and shot prices on the high some for a dive bar

Michael Cecere

By far my favorite neighborhood pub. Regulates are hysterical, family owned and owners are great people. They even have excellent bar food. Be careful very easy to get very drunk here.

Richard Robertson

Nice little bar but 750 for a Heineken really, if you're not a regular there you'll be out of money before you get drunk, tell your designated driver to stay home

Sandeep Sehgal

Nice people and good service

Pat C.

Best burgers on Long Island. Just one critique of the burger, I've been going there since the 80's, must have ordered the hamburger 100 times, had to send it back 90 times (including take out), but for some strange reason, no matter how many times you tell them no cheese, they ALWAYS put cheese on it. Haden't been there in years until this week, I told the bartender no cheese, had to send it back because the cook put cheese on it. I'm assuming the cook is on auto pilot.

Ro W

Deserves NO stars. My step mother and her best friend went in there per usual. Apparently staff and patrons thought it was ok to make anti-Semitic jokes. Apparently that’s what they do on Saturdays. And then tried to intimidate my step mother and her friend. DISGUSTING, IGNORANT AND TRASHY! Save your money and drink elsewhere!

Spencota R.

My parents have been going to this place for years and I finally go and I've had the worst experience of my life. The bartender was horribly rude, the atmosphere was awful, and I was treated like scum. I spilled a drink by accident because it was so loud in there and I am known to have shaking due to anxiety. Not only was she not understanding but she ended up charging us triple the price I will never return to this place and I warn everybody else not to waste their time or money

Debbie V

Perfect dive bar.

Load More