Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant

We ordered from Michael Anthony’s today. Pizza, garlic knots and shrimp & scallops Newburg. Everything was absolutely delicious.

I ordered for the first time yesterday on a recommendation and Michael Anthony’s lived up to it. Delivery was right on time. Pizza was a huge hit with the kids and delicious. I will be definitely ordering from them on a regular basis and cannot wait to try other items on their menu.

Food was fast and delicious. 15.99 parm night is well worth it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Food and service was spectacular. We came in late, we stayed late and we were still treated great! All of the food was Wonderful. Cannot wait to Come back!!!!!!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Awful service and delivered the wrong order. Would not refund or replace the order.
Just said sorry they can not do anything about it. Really ? Learn what it’s like to have service. ! Soggy wet old wilted salad and false advertising about buy one get one free
They took zero accountability! So if you want to get scammed you can go to this awful restaurant. And you know what’s truly sad is that YOU the owner was right by the phone but instead of doing the right thing you had one of your Widget workers get in the phone and dismiss us. So your feedback is also pathetic as you could care less of your customers and would not do the right thing. Is it a big deal to redo a sale correctly and honor the fake buy one get one for free as your reply is a COVER UP ! I have owned many businesses and always do the right thing. Does it cost you a nickel to have integrity and redo a mistake ? Instead you blame it on Uber really. ???
Pathetic truly And YOU the owner have your staff lie and say it did not say chicken and was not buy one get one … please pathetic.

If I could give 0 stars I would. I Ordered thru ubereats & received the wrong order. When I called the restaurant to notify them of their mistake they refused to give me the correct order or a refund.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Don’t claim you close at 9 if you’re going to be closing before even 8:30

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 3

Service: 2

Stopped there cause in the area and in a pinch for a quick slice. Place opens at 11 get there ten after. Walk in and ask for a Sicilian slice. They have non. Ask if there us anything available. NOTHING. How are you opening the doors and not a single slice of anything is available. Can't say how good or bad the pizza is but to walk in when open to absolutely nothing is enough for me to not come back.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Got the veal parm and cheese purse pasta, very good, veal nice and crispy

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Today's pizza was good. Thanks.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Ordered 2 pies that were extremely saturated with oil. Ive seen pizza grease, but this was like taking a bath in it, 3 paper towels worth of soaking up the oil. Pizza was too thick, flimsy and doughy to be considered pizza. I called to complain and got a valid answer of the cheese wasny curated enough so the oils released quicker. I said the pizza tasted horrible and i was told "well maybe its your tastebuds" ... worst customer service ever. Will never return. Disgraceful!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I honestly don't know where to begin. Everything about Michael Anthony's is top notch. The employees, the atmosphere, the quality of food, their willingness to help plan an event, etc. I usually order from them for my meetings at work and the food is always great. With that said, it was only fitting to use them when throwing a surprise retirement party with 100 attendees for one of my long time associates. Michael was great in the planning and Christine and Cathy are second to none with regards to setting up, serving, cleaning up, etc. I literally felt like I had two of my aunts there helping me. They are such wonderful hardworking women. The party was 3 weeks ago and people are still texting me daily to rave about the food. We had Veal Marsala (my #1 choice), penne a la vodka, eggplant rollantini, heroes, stuffed knots, salad, chicken parm, sausage and peppers, tortellini carbonara, Caesar salad, and cold antipasto trays. All in all everything was a solid 10/10. Again, they do everything right. From the planning and cooking to the delivery and serving. They have never let us down. In addition, I ordered some personal catering for my home last weekend. My mother has celiac and she was amazed with the taste and quality of Mike's Gluten Free options!! I got her mussels in a white wine sauce, fried calamari, and a grandma pizza. All Gluten Free and all delicious! Thank you Mike and your entire staff for truly caring about your customers. I know it's a tough business and I personally appreciate all you have done for us!Ciao, Joe D

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great place to eat. Waiters are wonderful food is great even my 8 year old loved it xoxo

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The good was excellent!Very nice dining room.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was there last night!Wonderful experience!Met Mike, the owner and Gina was our waitress. Such nice people!The food and service was excellent!Thank you both for making our dinner experience wonderful!We will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5