Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant

2425 Middle Country Rd, Centereach
(631) 285-7722

Recent Reviews

H Nemzer

The good was excellent!Very nice dining room.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jackie M.

I heard such great things about this place and the customer service. I went on their website and it kept popping up to use this app "slices" to order delivery. So I order thru the app at 4:23 a large pie a large salad and a roll. Easy. At 5:15 the delivery comes. Great. I get in the house open the bag and it's missing the roll. At this time a notification comes up from the slices app that any issues or w/e you can chat thru the app. Which was perfect because I had guest over I didn't want to talk on the phone. As you can see they said that the restaurant apologized and at 5:30 the roll was already done and ready for delivery. Well around 6:20 I still didn't receive my eggplant roll and my guest had to leave. I called the restaurant and heard all the commotion in the back saying that I canceled the order thru slices and that my Entire order was currently at the restaurant. I explained that I already received my pizza and salad and (I'm assuming the owner Mike)seemed to not believe me. I asked for a refund only for the roll but he said I couldn't get it because it was a problem with the app not them and that I had to call them in order to get my refund because he needed his money. Which look I get but jeez I'm the customer here trying to host guest. With missing items. Such a hassle and attitude (like I said I heard what was being said in the back) over an 8.99 eggplant roll. The delivery guy was super nice. Posted that pic so maybe the owner would believe me. Anyways go to caffe amici instead.

Steven Krinsky

Was there last night!Wonderful experience!Met Mike, the owner and Gina was our waitress. Such nice people!The food and service was excellent!Thank you both for making our dinner experience wonderful!We will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Curt

Beautiful dining room, amazing service and outstanding food!! Had the Veal Chop pizzaola was incredible Mike is awesome and so was his server Gina highly recommend this place!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Nicole Gresh

Amazing Gluten Free food and regular food. Can’t even tell the difference between them. The owner and staff are absolutely wonderful!! This place is my go to for all GF food. Almost their whole menu is GF, it makes you feel like a normal person being able to pick almost anything on the menu. Thank you again for amazing food!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tracy Gardell

The food is delicious and the service is great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Ray Davidson

Great food Great Staff Christmas Party

D S.

I went to a party here twice - the first time at this establishment I was very impressed with the quality of the food. It was buffet style and the food was amazing. Consistent with the quality which is key! I highly recommend the restaurant

Gabriela Ulin-Mejia

Cancelled an order randomly through DoorDash. Terrible restaurant. Would not bother.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Jonathan P

Penne a la vodka should be a creamy sauce. Not an oily sauce.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Tara K

We've been here a few times, never reviewed. This restaurant is a hidden gem with excellent food. We've never been disappointed. Tonight, Christine was our server, very friendly, quality service. A warm bread and butter basket was served. And our dinners came with a very enjoyable salad with grated mozzarella on top, that we love. We started with the baked clams, which, were so good, and had that sauce you keep dipping the Italian bread in. My husband ordered the Asiago Veal Chop. The size was insane. It was tender. It was perfectly breaded, fried, and delicious. He was very happy. I ordered the Zuppa di Pesce over linguini. One of the best ones I've had. Loaded with seafood. An overall perfect meal.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Miss Bossy

Well I ordered delivery thru Uber Eats thought the place was kind of costly figured we would splurge on ourselves. So my friend and my husband ordered chicken Parmigiana with penne. I ordered Chicken Franscese. Boy was I let down. First off I'm Italian and love my bread all the meals were suppose to include that and of course received none. Most of all my meal. Omg the pasta was over cooked and smothered in the sauce and the chicken was dry. I was looking forward to sitting down and having a good meal together. The chicken parm my husband got most definitely was a large portion. The sauce was nothing to write home about. Needless to say I won't be going there again.

Food: 2

Alissa Tocco

Best grandma slice I've ever had. The regular slices were huge and my son loved it. The owner was really cool about our kids running around also.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lee Michel

Great food with good prices. I've been here a bunch of times. They have a prix fixe Monday through Thursday, which is awesome.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala, House Salad

Lucy Barone

The BEST fried Calamari I've had!! They also make a DEELISH Pizza (vodka sauce, pesto sauce, marinara sauce)!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More

Michael Anthony's Pizzeria & Restaurant

2425 Middle Country Rd, Centereach, NY 11720
(631) 285-7722