Find myself coming back to Old Stone more then I care to admit, great Italian spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Mabi Scharf
Old Stone Trattoria is such a cozy and familiar place! They have one of the most delicious Gnocchi alla Romana I’ve ever had in the state — perfectly soft and super creamy. The waiter was very friendly and proactive, even offered me wine samples to help choose the best match for my dish. Great experience and I super recommend you visit this establishment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick Bogojevich
Wrong pizza delivered and arrived cold.
Michael
If you like thin pizza and live in the Chappaqua/Pleasantville area this is the place to go to. Very tasty!
Food: 5
A. L.
Food is okay - not great They charge for bread on the table
Joe Scuccimarri
This is a 5 star pizza restaurant do not be fooled by the 4.3 stars. The pizza is by far the best in the area and I wish more people in pleasantville knew about it because they would switch over immediately if they did.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jaime Olmeda
Not so friendly vibe when you come in. The waiter/waitresses give off good energy but the other staff not so much unless your a regular.The last time I was there I ordered 2 slices. The pizza tasted overheated that the cheese looked dark orange right before it burns look. I've had the pizza before and it was really good so I was disappointed. The time before that I had the chicken parm wedge. The cutlets were paper thin that when you bit into the sandwich all you tasted was a mouthful of bread. So I had to take the chicken out the 2nd half of the sandwich and place it into the 1st half I started eating to taste chicken. The very 1st time I went had the meatball parm and that I can say was good. The reason for 1 star is for consistency and non welcoming feeling when you enter the restaurant. 1st time the pizza was good then the other time its disgusting. Meatball parm good but your chicken parm is bad. How can you mess up a chicken parm? It literally just tasted like bread, cheese, and sauce.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Didi Troy
Excellent food and service. Dont skip dessert. The zeppoles and cannolis are the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stephany Amigon
The service was great. The waitress was attentive and made sure I was okay along with the bus boy. The food was really good (I had the pescatore in marinara). I ended it with dessert. I ate outside and I really enjoyed the atmosphere, it was very peaceful. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tubby Foodies
@oldstonetrattoria 425 King Street Chappaqua, New York 10514 ?
Atmosphere ? was beautifully decorated, perfect place for a weekly family dinner or a birthday party. Small cozy yet perfect size for any gathering.
Staff ??? was super friendly with a warm greeting as soon as you walked in. Once seated we were checked on multiple times to ensure we had everything we needed and wanted.
Food ? was WOW! Their brick oven pizza delicious, perfectly crispy and soft at the same time!
When you walk in they give you their in-house freshly made bread with their tomato sauce for dippping and wow how delicious! ?
We also ordered these amazing vodka Mac and cheese fritters, holy cannoli ! They were massive and so delicious! We would go back just for those ?
I place a delivery order last night, 08/03/2021, at 5:15 pm and they told me it would take 45 minutes. I called at 6:15 pm , 7:00 pm and they said they were waiting on the driver. At 7:20 pm the food came cold. They owner was to suppose to call me back to explain and reduce my bill - never called. This is not the first bad experience I have had with them in ordering for a pickup or delivery. My bad for ordering again and think it would change.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Jeff P
Red sauce Italian and pizza bistro, where the red sauce is actually excellent. Service was particularly outstanding, especially from Luis. The pasta fagioli was less impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
tony Carlo
I ordered a eggplant pizza roll with no cheese. It was so small and hardly any eggplant. It was put in a paper bag and I walked back to my car but I also felt it was light in weight like a feather. So disappointed I happened to pass Midland pizza and just out of Curiosity i ordered the same thing just to see the difference. I go to Midland a lot so I knew I would get a not only twice the size but delicious tasting. Even seems they put bits and pieces of left over eggplant in the roll. I know it’s just a pizza roll but it’s the principal of it and Disgraceful. Won’t be back
Mister Salazar
Excellent and delicious, that’s the best way i can describe this place and its food. Specially those pizza slices.
Find myself coming back to Old Stone more then I care to admit, great Italian spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Old Stone Trattoria is such a cozy and familiar place! They have one of the most delicious Gnocchi alla Romana I’ve ever had in the state — perfectly soft and super creamy. The waiter was very friendly and proactive, even offered me wine samples to help choose the best match for my dish. Great experience and I super recommend you visit this establishment.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wrong pizza delivered and arrived cold.
If you like thin pizza and live in the Chappaqua/Pleasantville area this is the place to go to. Very tasty!
Food: 5
Food is okay - not great
They charge for bread on the table
This is a 5 star pizza restaurant do not be fooled by the 4.3 stars. The pizza is by far the best in the area and I wish more people in pleasantville knew about it because they would switch over immediately if they did.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Not so friendly vibe when you come in. The waiter/waitresses give off good energy but the other staff not so much unless your a regular.The last time I was there I ordered 2 slices. The pizza tasted overheated that the cheese looked dark orange right before it burns look. I've had the pizza before and it was really good so I was disappointed. The time before that I had the chicken parm wedge. The cutlets were paper thin that when you bit into the sandwich all you tasted was a mouthful of bread. So I had to take the chicken out the 2nd half of the sandwich and place it into the 1st half I started eating to taste chicken. The very 1st time I went had the meatball parm and that I can say was good. The reason for 1 star is for consistency and non welcoming feeling when you enter the restaurant. 1st time the pizza was good then the other time its disgusting. Meatball parm good but your chicken parm is bad. How can you mess up a chicken parm? It literally just tasted like bread, cheese, and sauce.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Excellent food and service.
Dont skip dessert. The zeppoles and cannolis are the best.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The service was great. The waitress was attentive and made sure I was okay along with the bus boy. The food was really good (I had the pescatore in marinara). I ended it with dessert. I ate outside and I really enjoyed the atmosphere, it was very peaceful. Definitely recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
@oldstonetrattoria 425 King Street Chappaqua, New York 10514 ?
Atmosphere ? was beautifully decorated, perfect place for a weekly family dinner or a birthday party. Small cozy yet perfect size for any gathering.
Staff ??? was super friendly with a warm greeting as soon as you walked in. Once seated we were checked on multiple times to ensure we had everything we needed and wanted.
Food ? was WOW! Their brick oven pizza delicious, perfectly crispy and soft at the same time!
When you walk in they give you their in-house freshly made bread with their tomato sauce for dippping and wow how delicious! ?
We also ordered these amazing vodka Mac and cheese fritters, holy cannoli ! They were massive and so delicious! We would go back just for those ?
10/10 recommend you guys give this place a try✨
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
I place a delivery order last night, 08/03/2021, at 5:15 pm and they told me it would take 45 minutes. I called at 6:15 pm , 7:00 pm and they said they were waiting on the driver. At 7:20 pm the food came cold. They owner was to suppose to call me back to explain and reduce my bill - never called. This is not the first bad experience I have had with them in ordering for a pickup or delivery. My bad for ordering again and think it would change.
Food: 3
Service: 1
Red sauce Italian and pizza bistro, where the red sauce is actually excellent. Service was particularly outstanding, especially from Luis. The pasta fagioli was less impressive.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
I ordered a eggplant pizza roll with no cheese. It was so small and hardly any eggplant. It was put in a paper bag and I walked back to my car but I also felt it was light in weight like a feather. So disappointed I happened to pass Midland pizza and just out of Curiosity i ordered the same thing just to see the difference. I go to Midland a lot so I knew I would get a not only twice the size but delicious tasting. Even seems they put bits and pieces of left over eggplant in the roll. I know it’s just a pizza roll but it’s the principal of it and Disgraceful. Won’t be back
Excellent and delicious, that’s the best way i can describe this place and its food. Specially those pizza slices.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food, small neighborhood trattoria.
Parking: Enough
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chicken Marsala
Loading...