Anderson's Frozen Custard

What in God's name happened to the french fries they used to be fantastic. But the last three or four times I have ordered they have some kind of weird coating. There nowhere close to the quality. I have no problem with paying the high price but for quality. These new fries you have are like fries from a truck stop please bring the old ones back. I can't be the only one who notices this

I love their roast beef sandwich with sweet potato fries it always comes hot and fresh keep up the great work guys. I also love their ice cream, they make their own ice cream and custard in house and you can taste the difference it is delicious! Anderson’s is a great place to stop for a good time and an amazing meal that won’t break the bank. The interior is vey nice and clean and I love the way it is themed.

Good dessert options, dine in or use the sit out area, there's usually enough parking, it's spacious too

On a quick trip to Buffalo we discovered this local favorite. I’d never heard of it.

I kept it simple and had a Strawberry milkshake made with real Strawberry ice cream. I appreciated the simplicity. The had a few unique favors of ice cream. I would definitely visit again if I was in the area.

Always good ice cream!

You pay almost $10.00 for an x-large hot fudge and there is very little ice cream in the dish. Wish I would have taken a picture. Not worth the price.

Food is good with many options but portion size is small vs the cost.

They have a good roast beef on Kimelwic for the price.. I only wish they did a larger version.. I would pay the extra money

Food was good, normal icecream place. Got a milkshake and wondered why I couldn’t drink it well or just get any strawberry flavor. Turns out I just had full strawberries at the bottom of the cup which was making it annoying. Learn how to blend

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Frozen Custard

Should be a Zero stars. Wow has the food and quality gone down. Turkey sandwich was beyond horrible. The roast beefs where so small and the sandwiches were smashed Down in wrapper.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Recommended dishes: Carl's Choice, Kimmelweck

I normally love andersons as a treat, and this past Saturday I went and grabbed a Junior bbq beef sandwhich and a pint of pumpkin cheesecake ice cream to keep in the freezer for when I want a sweet treat. My bbq beef sandwhich was not like normal, it was very thick and not easy to eat through. I ignored it until today, 3 days later I wanted to eat my pumpkin cheesecake ice cream and took a taste and it was not pumpkin cheesecake ice cream (I just grabbed one of the premade pints they had made, which was labeled incorrectly). I’m sure it was just a bad day for andersons, but still for the price I paid to have everything wrong is very disappointing.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 2

Wheelchair accessibility: Ground levels

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Original, Mashed Potatoes

The beef was chewy & slimy. The fries were rubbery like the fryer was at the wrong temperature, or the grease needed changing. The place is nice looking, but the food was very meh & disappointing. I actually threw most of it out.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 1

Service: 5

Yummy and good people!

Kid-friendliness: Wide open space and of course the lovely distraction of ice cream 😊

Wheelchair accessibility: Wide open. Ramp entrance. I would think this is good for wheelchairs and other disabilities