Our meal was terrific. The restaurant was clean and the noise level was low. we enjoyed appetizers, main meals and shared dessert. We always choose Delmonico's for special occasion dinners. We can count on having a wonderful time We make reservations and are always seated on time when we arrive.
Husband and I were disappointed. Never had a poor meal here until yesterday. Delmonico steak was tough and very rare for Med/ rare Lasagna looked like it wasn't fresh, noodles gummy. Sauce was very good and flavor good however, the apps were good. Stuffed hot peppers were good. We were disappointed and won't go back due to the entrees. Not up to par for Delmonico's whose usually very good.
RobG
First time we ate here, probably last. Food was pretty good and service was pretty good, but at end of day it is a chain. If you haven't been think of a fancy Olive Garden. Everything is average to just alright.
Food was excellent. Atmosphere good. Table for 4 was way too small and literally all our food (appetizers and mains) came out together on a table that could not hold all the items. We had to merge dishes and put things on the floor. Servers seemed to not know what to do when food came out all together. Food was excellent just would have liked to not feel rushed. I would try again because the food was great.
A+ experience. Would we like to repeat what took place at Delmonicos? You bet we would. Appetizer was first class. Steak and chicken entrees were superbly prepared. Desserts? Wow. Strawberry Cheesecake and cannoli. A perfect dinner and a very attentive server. We WILL be back.
Our server Alexa was wonderful. We told her it was our anniversary and we are not in a hurry. She gave us space and took her time. Good never disappoints. Chris Holmes hires the right people!
My family and I had a relaxing and intimate dining experience on Mother's Day that was the next best thing to having dinner together at home, without the work of preparing and cleaning up after the meal! I especially enjoyed the "Sinatra Room, " which allowed us to have a semi-private gathering place to eat and engage in conversation without having to yell over the noise of other patrons in the restaurant. There was a wide variety of meals to choose from on their menu, and everyone in our party was extremely satisfied with the quality and taste of their meal selections. The service was exceptional, as our server was very attentive, courteous and professional, and we thought the cost was reasonable. We will definitely be back!
Good service and conversation with our waitress. Loved the shrimp cocktail and the beer and wine selection were good. Delmonico ribeye steak ordered rare came out medium rare and didn't have much flavor. Cheesecake and tiramisu were excellent. 
Targa4jbn
The meal and dessert was good. I got the peach salmon special and my wife got chicken marsala. Both entrees were cooked well and tasted great. The only negative is that the service was a bit brisk, resulting in us not being able to order a side or drinks after dinner. This is very unusual for this restaurant. It was just our server.
dp3326
Service was good. 2 martinis came out wrong and we sent back. Poor tasting food. Not real Italian food. Linguine and clams super garlicky. Eggplant Parmesan too thick and too much breading. The cannoli cream didn't have any flavor. The cinnamon waffle shell doesn't belong with the cannoli. Too many other good Italian restaurants to return.
Great experience at Delmonico's steak house. Service, drinks, appetizers, and meals were excellent. Will definitely be going back when I am back in town. PS, great value for what you get.
Mama2
As usual, great food and beverages and a great value for the money. Nice atmosphere. Our waitress seemed like she didn't want to be there, oh well, she still got a decent tip (~20%) anyway.
JoelD
We've been to Delmonicos quite a few times and rarely have had any complaints. This past weekend was no exception. The food was great as usual. Our apps of mini meatballs and the Utica greens we delicious and plenty for our table of 4. The one pound lasagna was great as usual and as usual we brought half of it home. Companions 2 and 3 both enjoyed their steaks and sides. I had the veal with mushrooms and the risotto on the side was excellent. Our server -wish we got her name- was very friendly and fun with a twist of sarcasm! I felt she enjoyed our table as much as we did her service.
StephanieM
We showed up a couple minutes before our reservation and were handed a pager to wait to be seated. A party with a later reservation was seated before us and we had to wait about 20 minutes before we were seated which was the wait time given to people with no reservations at the hostess station. Both our steaks came out drastically undercooked. One was inedible it was so raw when it was supposed to be “medium”. For a first time experience for both of us, it was less than impressive.
Very good calamari. Food overall was spot on. Service could be improved. We would come back. No mention of our birthday that was noted on the reservation but that's fine guess they were short staffed.
Our meal was terrific. The restaurant was clean and the noise level was low. we enjoyed appetizers, main meals and shared dessert. We always choose Delmonico's for special occasion dinners. We can count on having a wonderful time We make reservations and are always seated on time when we arrive.
Husband and I were disappointed. Never had a poor meal here until yesterday. Delmonico steak was tough and very rare for Med/ rare Lasagna looked like it wasn't fresh, noodles gummy. Sauce was very good and flavor good however, the apps were good. Stuffed hot peppers were good. We were disappointed and won't go back due to the entrees. Not up to par for Delmonico's whose usually very good.
First time we ate here, probably last. Food was pretty good and service was pretty good, but at end of day it is a chain. If you haven't been think of a fancy Olive Garden. Everything is average to just alright.
Food was excellent. Atmosphere good. Table for 4 was way too small and literally all our food (appetizers and mains) came out together on a table that could not hold all the items. We had to merge dishes and put things on the floor. Servers seemed to not know what to do when food came out all together. Food was excellent just would have liked to not feel rushed. I would try again because the food was great.
A+ experience. Would we like to repeat what took place at Delmonicos? You bet we would. Appetizer was first class. Steak and chicken entrees were superbly prepared. Desserts? Wow. Strawberry Cheesecake and cannoli. A perfect dinner and a very attentive server. We WILL be back.
Our server Alexa was wonderful. We told her it was our anniversary and we are not in a hurry. She gave us space and took her time. Good never disappoints. Chris Holmes hires the right people!
My family and I had a relaxing and intimate dining experience on Mother's Day that was the next best thing to having dinner together at home, without the work of preparing and cleaning up after the meal! I especially enjoyed the "Sinatra Room, " which allowed us to have a semi-private gathering place to eat and engage in conversation without having to yell over the noise of other patrons in the restaurant. There was a wide variety of meals to choose from on their menu, and everyone in our party was extremely satisfied with the quality and taste of their meal selections. The service was exceptional, as our server was very attentive, courteous and professional, and we thought the cost was reasonable. We will definitely be back!
Good service and conversation with our waitress. Loved the shrimp cocktail and the beer and wine selection were good. Delmonico ribeye steak ordered rare came out medium rare and didn't have much flavor. Cheesecake and tiramisu were excellent. 
The meal and dessert was good. I got the peach salmon special and my wife got chicken marsala. Both entrees were cooked well and tasted great. The only negative is that the service was a bit brisk, resulting in us not being able to order a side or drinks after dinner. This is very unusual for this restaurant. It was just our server.
Service was good. 2 martinis came out wrong and we sent back. Poor tasting food. Not real Italian food. Linguine and clams super garlicky. Eggplant Parmesan too thick and too much breading. The cannoli cream didn't have any flavor. The cinnamon waffle shell doesn't belong with the cannoli. Too many other good Italian restaurants to return.
Restaurantji Recommends
Great experience at Delmonico's steak house. Service, drinks, appetizers, and meals were excellent. Will definitely be going back when I am back in town. PS, great value for what you get.
As usual, great food and beverages and a great value for the money. Nice atmosphere. Our waitress seemed like she didn't want to be there, oh well, she still got a decent tip (~20%) anyway.
We've been to Delmonicos quite a few times and rarely have had any complaints. This past weekend was no exception. The food was great as usual. Our apps of mini meatballs and the Utica greens we delicious and plenty for our table of 4. The one pound lasagna was great as usual and as usual we brought half of it home. Companions 2 and 3 both enjoyed their steaks and sides. I had the veal with mushrooms and the risotto on the side was excellent. Our server -wish we got her name- was very friendly and fun with a twist of sarcasm! I felt she enjoyed our table as much as we did her service.
We showed up a couple minutes before our reservation and were handed a pager to wait to be seated. A party with a later reservation was seated before us and we had to wait about 20 minutes before we were seated which was the wait time given to people with no reservations at the hostess station. Both our steaks came out drastically undercooked. One was inedible it was so raw when it was supposed to be “medium”. For a first time experience for both of us, it was less than impressive.
Very good calamari. Food overall was spot on. Service could be improved. We would come back. No mention of our birthday that was noted on the reservation but that's fine guess they were short staffed.
Loading...