Love the pizza and wings. Friendly crew that works there. Always have a good laugh when they think my name is " jerry"
Michael Baker
Still the best pizza around
Joker
Best pizza in the area. Great customer service.
dan roberts
Been going here since I was a kid. Friendly atmosphere and employees. The pizza is very good!
Marie F.
I have tried this place twice for Subs an both times they have TOTALLY messed them up!! This this time we took them back. one of the snotty girls was rude. They re made one of the subs but gave me the same MESSED UP sub back!! The turkey is spoiled and I ended up not eating what I paid for. This is only my second week in New York. I have heard for years about how good New York Subs are. If this is what they are like I think I will stick with Subway. At least they can follow directions!! This is what happens when you allow children to run things. They are too busy flirting and checking their phones to take care of customers.
Brian G.
We heard about this little convenience store and their pizza. Thought we better give it a shot. Stopped by here in February or so. Don't let the store front fool ya, inside is a pretty decent slice of pizza. The customer service is working, but what do you expect at a gas station? The pizza was tasty and crispy.
Averi D.
This photograph shows all the onions that were on one singular slice of pizza. And that's all I gotta say. Under cooked and underwhelmed....
Joy Shulla
BEST PIZZA except for the pizza I got in Seattle, Wa. They made theirs' with Buffalo Cheese, can't be beat! Best in New York state. ❤️??
Reggie F.
Best hospitality and pizza around. Just like family. Very nice menu and everything is to go. It really is a to go restaurant and a small store and a gas station. What more do you need! Cheers
Michael L.
This place has THEE best pizza between Rochester and Syracuse inclusive. Delicious homemade dough with super generous toppings served by a pleasant staff in a timely fashion. I literally get off the Thruway to pick it up. My 27 year old son tuned me in to these folks. Try it..You'll like it
I gave this place a try based on the reviews. I must admit, I was pleasantly surprised. Every good thing people have said, is right on the mark. The pizza is honestly really good. They use quality ingredients and the guys that make the pizza, are beyond accommodating and polite. I asked if he would make me a medium pizza extra thin, light on the sauce and well done. It was cooked perfectly and just like I asked. The dough tastes homemade and has a crispy texture. The sauce was not overly sweet and had more of a fresh tomato taste. Plus, a little of that orange oil you get on top of the pizza from a good mozzarella that I love, was present and ran down my chin. Don't be deceived by this dive gas station because inside is some pretty good pizza. I'm giving it four stars because of the location. If the guys that make the pizza get their own place, they will definitely get five star ratings.
Phelps C.
Fabulous pizza. Surprising as it is in a gas station. Just try it and you'll be hooked!
Sam W.
Everson's has always been a great place to grab a slice of pizza or sandwich. The staff is always pleasant and welcoming. Since Covid-19 started, they have been taking the proper precautions to make sure all customers and staff are safe.
Kyle Norsen
Nice local store
Rikk F.
I heard the rumors for a couple years. I finally had enough of all the crappy pizza in our area. I gave it try. OMG! This is what use to be the considered the best pizza anywhere by many from another pizza shop. This pizza took me back to the 1990's when a local pizza chain had the best pizza in the country. They have not for years but we kept going back hoping. No more hoping! This place has nailed it! Crust, sauce, toppings and cooking it until it's done without burning it. They have the whole package. The wings are right on too. Absolutely love this place, so unassuming as an old gas station. Congratulations, you guys nailed it. Thank you!
Love the pizza and wings. Friendly crew that works there. Always have a good laugh when they think my name is " jerry"
Still the best pizza around
Best pizza in the area. Great customer service.
Been going here since I was a kid. Friendly atmosphere and employees. The pizza is very good!
I have tried this place twice for Subs an both times they have TOTALLY messed them up!! This this time we took them back. one of the snotty girls was rude. They re made one of the subs but gave me the same MESSED UP sub back!! The turkey is spoiled and I ended up not eating what I paid for. This is only my second week in New York. I have heard for years about how good New York Subs are. If this is what they are like I think I will stick with Subway. At least they can follow directions!! This is what happens when you allow children to run things. They are too busy flirting and checking their phones to take care of customers.
We heard about this little convenience store and their pizza. Thought we better give it a shot. Stopped by here in February or so. Don't let the store front fool ya, inside is a pretty decent slice of pizza. The customer service is working, but what do you expect at a gas station? The pizza was tasty and crispy.
This photograph shows all the onions that were on one singular slice of pizza. And that's all I gotta say. Under cooked and underwhelmed....
BEST PIZZA except for the pizza I got in Seattle, Wa. They made theirs' with Buffalo Cheese, can't be beat! Best in New York state. ❤️??
Best hospitality and pizza around. Just like family. Very nice menu and everything is to go. It really is a to go restaurant and a small store and a gas station. What more do you need! Cheers
This place has THEE best pizza between Rochester and Syracuse inclusive. Delicious homemade dough with super generous toppings served by a pleasant staff in a timely fashion. I literally get off the Thruway to pick it up. My 27 year old son tuned me in to these folks. Try it..You'll like it
Restaurantji Recommends
I gave this place a try based on the reviews. I must admit, I was pleasantly surprised. Every good thing people have said, is right on the mark. The pizza is honestly really good. They use quality ingredients and the guys that make the pizza, are beyond accommodating and polite. I asked if he would make me a medium pizza extra thin, light on the sauce and well done. It was cooked perfectly and just like I asked. The dough tastes homemade and has a crispy texture. The sauce was not overly sweet and had more of a fresh tomato taste. Plus, a little of that orange oil you get on top of the pizza from a good mozzarella that I love, was present and ran down my chin. Don't be deceived by this dive gas station because inside is some pretty good pizza. I'm giving it four stars because of the location. If the guys that make the pizza get their own place, they will definitely get five star ratings.
Fabulous pizza. Surprising as it is in a gas station. Just try it and you'll be hooked!
Everson's has always been a great place to grab a slice of pizza or sandwich. The staff is always pleasant and welcoming. Since Covid-19 started, they have been taking the proper precautions to make sure all customers and staff are safe.
Nice local store
I heard the rumors for a couple years. I finally had enough of all the crappy pizza in our area. I gave it try. OMG! This is what use to be the considered the best pizza anywhere by many from another pizza shop. This pizza took me back to the 1990's when a local pizza chain had the best pizza in the country. They have not for years but we kept going back hoping. No more hoping! This place has nailed it! Crust, sauce, toppings and cooking it until it's done without burning it. They have the whole package. The wings are right on too. Absolutely love this place, so unassuming as an old gas station. Congratulations, you guys nailed it. Thank you!