New York Style Pizza

638 Columbia St Ext, Cohoes
(518) 783-3333

Recent Reviews

Sort by
agagnon59

Zero stars. I have never been so disgusted in my life. Ordered a 24 cut and mozzarella sticks for my birthday and had a LIVE ROACH in the pizza. When i called for a refund i was told that I'd get a credit!! No, I'll never order from here again, it absolutely ruined my entire night and my kids already ate a piece of pizza. The woman who answered the phone didn't seem surprised when I told her there was a bug in my pizza. She instead asked me if it was dead or alive!?!? Disturbing how calm she was. Everything ended up in the trash.

Brianna Bunting

WILL NEVER BE ORDERING FOOD FROM HERE AGAIN!!!! My mom ordered a 24 cut and mozzarella sticks for delivery came to a total of around $60. The food gets here my mom and sister both have a slice then my sister starts screaming saying there’s a bug in the pizza box. I come out and find a cockroach in the box!!! My mom calls the store to get a refund and the guy on the phone says he doesn’t know how it got there and that he packaged it up himself. Offered a store credit for next time. DIDN’T EVEN OFFER A REFUND OR ANYTHING. Absolutely disgusting I would not order from here again if I were you!! Terrible service!!

joanne foglia

just picked up 2 pizzas a cheese n a white with tomato spinach n basil. sooooo good! friendly help too. will be ordering again!

tippy

I Left my wallet there and they found it for me and kept it safe. Thank you 😊

Jake

Disappointing at best. The Buffalo chicken sub came with nothing on it but chicken and a little bit of hot sauce. No lettuce, no bleu cheese, nothing

Josh Oliver

Review as a driver. Store marks orders as ready to pick up when they are not even started yet. Be prepared to wait upwards of 20 more minutes than expected and if you have other orders, don't accept from here. It will impact your times. Shop should get better management if it's gonna use outside delivery drivers. They way they run is extremely unfriendly to delivery drivers

Raelene Pitt

Ordered 5 /12 cuts for a party came out fresh and perfect delicious would definitely order again

Frank Cooper

Awful, awful, awful. The past three times, something has been missing from my order, only to be told 4-5 minutes. 15-20 minutes later I finally get what I order.
Tonight, one of my pizzas, the one they forgot to make, is barely cooked. I will never return.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Michele Hendrickson

Ordered three subs and pizza- food was amazing and the people were extremely nice!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Richard McIntosh

Great Brooklyn style pizza, they have a large selection of pies, for slice service, too. Their wings are cooked perfectly, probably order wings 3 times a month from here. Been going well over 10 years now.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings, Garlic Knots

Alon Melecci

Cutttte little place with super good pizza! I've tried 4 different kinds and they've all been great! Crispy but not tough and the toppings are fresh...convenient and fast too.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Danielle Fields

The staff, the food, the atmosphere. All 1000/10. The family that owns this place are all so genuinely kind and compassionate about what they do. I stop atleast twice a week, always greeted with a smile. The pizza is NYC style, amazing taste!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pat Bloomfield

Pizza was great, and the Service was Amazing highly Recommend ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Patrick Keegan

All in All it was a pretty positive experience. Sicilian was thinner than I'm used to. Delivery was very fast. I would have liked more mozzarella on my chicken parmesan wedge.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wings

Bruno Tostes

Best pizza in the area!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...