Ordered on the 4th of July cause they were the only place open, absolute waste of money, the delivery drive was disgustingly rude I wouldn’t order if it was last pizza shop ever open absolute garbage would rather order pizza from a highschool then them ever
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Anne Gomes
I would give zero stars if possible. This was the WORST pizza ever. It was stale and tasteless. It seemed more like a frozen pizza than a supposedly freshly made pizza. It's as if they used a frozen pizza and threw a few toppings on it. And I do mean a few. because although we ordered toppings, there was hardly any on the pie. The pizza was ready and delivered in less than 30 minutes but needed to be reheated. Try another option in the area. This place is definitely not it.
Food: 1
Luke Plumadore
Dave ordered a 24 cut and we only got 12 that's crazy... Dave is pictured here
Alex W.
They were open on New Year’s Day, so I gave it a try. Though the restaurant is named Oscar’s (according to Google Maps) it is actually called Lemons. I ended up passing right by… and had to use GPS to find it. There is a single “Oscar’s” sign in the vestibule.The person who took my order was very nice. The price was on par with other pizza places.The toppings were above average (meat lovers) but non-traditional. It had pepperoni, ham, and some kind of meat likely used in one of their other dishes. No complaints… it wasn’t bad. The sauce seemed a bit plain and sparse, but it wasn’t bad either. It wasn’t too greasy.I’m giving it 3 stars because of the crust. I honestly think the best crust is from “I Love NY” located just down the road. This crust was only average in comparison. Granted, I Love NY is a bit greasier/soggy in comparison… but I really love their crust.I would Oscar’s/Lemon again, but likely wouldn’t have their pizza.For reference I rank their pizza was at least as good as Inferno’s (Lishakill Rd).
Matthew Collins
Horrible chicken wasn’t even cooked idk what type of chicken that was and WONT BE COMEING BACK
Jennifer Juarez
We always get the deluxe Supreme pizza and it never fails us. The garlic knots are also delicious.
Jessica Armstrong
Pretty good pizza for upstate New York!
Jose Rodriguez
Ordered ziti chicken Alfredo they gave me ziti with a pound of oregano and no Alfredo sauce. Is it really that hard to make Alfredo? Do I have to open up a restaurant and ruin everyone else's restaurant around here?
Joseph Mahar
Ordered from them last night. Guy on the phone got my house number wrong, I corrected him. Asked for my phone number, gave it. Order never showed, I had to call. They delivered my food to the wrong house number. Somehow, despite asking for my phone number, they somehow couldn't contact me. I asked them to re-deliver my food but they said they ate it instead. Hope you guys had a great meal.
steven mafrici
Had the pizza and wings there and they were terrible Plus they can't count change out
It doesn't look like this place exists anymore. I ordered a pizza, went to the address, searched around for 15 minutes and couldn't find anything called 'Oscar's Pizza'...
Chyna VanAuken
Absolutely awesome food! My very first time trying it and I was not disappointed! I ordered the wings extra hot and they came sprinkled with crushed red pepper. ? The pizza was phenomenal. I'm very happy with everything! Highly recommended!!
Crunch
This is the freaking best pizza i have had in my life i am blessed mashallah if i want to crave pizza again i would choose this place over and over i love you guys wallahi
Leona Breidhaupt
The family was hungry and it was closing time !That didn't matter, we were greeted with kindness and we loved the Pizza. Ate inside with being rushed.Thank You for fantastic customer service and food.We will definitely be back
Luis Gonzalez
Even though they messed up my order. After receiving my order I called and I’m figuring the owner or the manager brought me the correct order within minutes. That to me deserves 5 stars. Thank you for your Great Service !
Ordered on the 4th of July cause they were the only place open, absolute waste of money, the delivery drive was disgustingly rude I wouldn’t order if it was last pizza shop ever open absolute garbage would rather order pizza from a highschool then them ever
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
I would give zero stars if possible. This was the WORST pizza ever. It was stale and tasteless. It seemed more like a frozen pizza than a supposedly freshly made pizza. It's as if they used a frozen pizza and threw a few toppings on it. And I do mean a few. because although we ordered toppings, there was hardly any on the pie. The pizza was ready and delivered in less than 30 minutes but needed to be reheated. Try another option in the area. This place is definitely not it.
Food: 1
Dave ordered a 24 cut and we only got 12 that's crazy... Dave is pictured here
They were open on New Year’s Day, so I gave it a try. Though the restaurant is named Oscar’s (according to Google Maps) it is actually called Lemons. I ended up passing right by… and had to use GPS to find it. There is a single “Oscar’s” sign in the vestibule.The person who took my order was very nice. The price was on par with other pizza places.The toppings were above average (meat lovers) but non-traditional. It had pepperoni, ham, and some kind of meat likely used in one of their other dishes. No complaints… it wasn’t bad. The sauce seemed a bit plain and sparse, but it wasn’t bad either. It wasn’t too greasy.I’m giving it 3 stars because of the crust. I honestly think the best crust is from “I Love NY” located just down the road. This crust was only average in comparison. Granted, I Love NY is a bit greasier/soggy in comparison… but I really love their crust.I would Oscar’s/Lemon again, but likely wouldn’t have their pizza.For reference I rank their pizza was at least as good as Inferno’s (Lishakill Rd).
Horrible chicken wasn’t even cooked idk what type of chicken that was and WONT BE COMEING BACK
We always get the deluxe Supreme pizza and it never fails us. The garlic knots are also delicious.
Pretty good pizza for upstate New York!
Ordered ziti chicken Alfredo they gave me ziti with a pound of oregano and no Alfredo sauce. Is it really that hard to make Alfredo? Do I have to open up a restaurant and ruin everyone else's restaurant around here?
Ordered from them last night. Guy on the phone got my house number wrong, I corrected him. Asked for my phone number, gave it. Order never showed, I had to call. They delivered my food to the wrong house number. Somehow, despite asking for my phone number, they somehow couldn't contact me. I asked them to re-deliver my food but they said they ate it instead. Hope you guys had a great meal.
Had the pizza and wings there and they were terrible Plus they can't count change out
Restaurantji Recommends
It doesn't look like this place exists anymore. I ordered a pizza, went to the address, searched around for 15 minutes and couldn't find anything called 'Oscar's Pizza'...
Absolutely awesome food! My very first time trying it and I was not disappointed! I ordered the wings extra hot and they came sprinkled with crushed red pepper. ? The pizza was phenomenal. I'm very happy with everything! Highly recommended!!
This is the freaking best pizza i have had in my life i am blessed mashallah if i want to crave pizza again i would choose this place over and over i love you guys wallahi
The family was hungry and it was closing time !That didn't matter, we were greeted with kindness and we loved the Pizza. Ate inside with being rushed.Thank You for fantastic customer service and food.We will definitely be back
Even though they messed up my order. After receiving my order I called and I’m figuring the owner or the manager brought me the correct order within minutes. That to me deserves 5 stars. Thank you for your Great Service !