Excellent as always!! Menu offerings so different than other traditional Italian restaurants! They have a few dishes that you can get anywhere but then offer so many creative, delicious dishes... Love them and sad that they are closing on 1/17.. Am thankful my hubby and I were in town so we could dine one more time before they close for good..
Christy730
The food, service & ambiance has always been consistent, Great! Last night, I ordered the shrimp Luciano,husband had the linguini with clams, & others had shrimp dinners which were all outstanding! Would highly recommend Andreas 25, one of the finest on Long Island
Frank Alfieri
Great food, friendly service, clean and very COVID-19 conscious with many precautions. They care about you, your family and the meals they serve. What more can you ask for?
Larryholz
We have been going to Andrea's for many years and it was always an upscale Italian restaurant with a large and excellent menu and food. They always made you feel welcome and special. Being greeted by the host and he is wearing jeans and polo shirt not even tucked in demonstrates the attitude of the restaurant and service. The food went from something to look forward to to just okay. It is unfortunate that one of our favorites is no longer providing that wonderful experience. It appears there is new leadership and it isn't what it used to be.
Caitlin C.
I visited Andreas 25 on a Saturday night at opening and sat near their beautiful glass windows. I really liked that their menu wasn't huge and overwhelming. We started with their broccoli rabe & sausage egg rolls which were so crispy and tasty!! Also their burrata was creamy & delicious with the pesto on top. For entrees we had their NY strip cooked medium & their seafood risotto. Both were EXCELLENT! Highly recommend Andreas!
Hammer T.
Second time here. First time we ate at the bar with wine food etc. service was pretty good and we enjoyed our meal. Went two weeks later on a wed night with my son Place nearly empty and staff ok when not hanging out by bar. My meal was fair but the calamari horrible and my sons chicken meal looked like soup and was chewy. Not very appealing to say the least. May or may not be back. I was generous with the three stars.
It was one of the worst meals we have ever had. The noise level was almost unbearable. We would have left the moment we arrived except for the threat to charge a $50 fee for canceling a reservation in less than 24 hours, although we had made our reservation a few minutes bef arriving. Will not return nor recommend. Sorry. I hope this helps the owners to improve their food quality and atmosphere.
HM Simon
Absolutely superb !! What a pleasant surprise !! We will be returning for sure !!
The menu online does not match their actual menu! We were very disappointed that a majority of the items were no longer available. It was no surprise when we brought it up to our waiter he just said ‘yeah, we don't have that stuff anymore'.
Perfect from start to finish. Service was attentive. Food and wine delicious. Had the avocado salad and added grilled shrimp for appetizer and chicken Christina for the entree. The salad was amazing. Creamy avocado and shrimp grilled perfectly. The chicken Christina was so good! The chicken pounded thin and grilled served with garlicky escarole and cannellini beans. It was a wonderful meal!
Our 3rd time dining at Andrea's. It never disappoints. The food is delicious and the service is impeccable. Our favorite waiter Johnathon who is ever so pleasant was our server. He is so nice and so attentive. You never have to wonder where he went as he checks back often, makes sure drinks are filled, table is clean. Miguel the busboy is also so pleasant and fills your water, brings you warm fresh bread and wraps up leftovers without even asking. Always a great experience. We love dining there. They care about their customers. You get a home style feel while dining out. A rarity for restaurants these days. We had fried calamari, baked clams, ceasar salad to start followed by penne carbonara and veal chop bone in pizzaiola linguine amatriciana. Cannoli and Tartuffo for dessert. Everything made fresh and delicious. Definitely will return. Recommend as a must try. Buon Appetito
BethG
We always enjoy Andrea's 25, and last night was no exception. The standouts about this place are the friendly, attentive service (hostess, bartender, waitress and busser were all incredibly friendly); and the wines by the glass are good. The food is always great, especially the many healthy made to order choices (particularly the salads and the chicken meatballs over zoodles!). We hope this place never changes :)
Anthony Burnette
We went after my friend's oath ceremony so the server got her a congratulatory dessert. The food was excellent and so was the service. Loved the experience!!
Steven S.
I didn't expect much, but damn I was wrong! I had one of the best, restaurant experience by far on Long Island. The space is intimate w/ dim lighting, really sets the mode. There is outdoor tent seating also, but it was to cold for that :). Marvin was out waiter from beginning to end he killed it! The service is just as important as the food! The food was excellent, everything had its own taste, nothing over powering very subtle & pleasant. Great place for a date or just to come by for a drink & appetizers.
Commack
We hadn't been there in about three years because the food was always horrible, and the service not so great. We gave it a shot once again last night. We had outdoor seating because on open table that was all that was available. When we had gotten there I believe that managers name was Matt, I had asked him if there was anyway we can be seated inside. He was very accommodating and said yes we just had a table leave. With that being said• the appetizers were all delicious, they were very attentive, never had an empty glass•• and we all enjoyed our meals too! It will be on my list to frequent again!
Excellent as always!! Menu offerings so different than other traditional Italian restaurants! They have a few dishes that you can get anywhere but then offer so many creative, delicious dishes... Love them and sad that they are closing on 1/17.. Am thankful my hubby and I were in town so we could dine one more time before they close for good..
The food, service & ambiance has always been consistent, Great! Last night, I ordered the shrimp Luciano,husband had the linguini with clams, & others had shrimp dinners which were all outstanding! Would highly recommend Andreas 25, one of the finest on Long Island
Great food, friendly service, clean and very COVID-19 conscious with many precautions. They care about you, your family and the meals they serve. What more can you ask for?
We have been going to Andrea's for many years and it was always an upscale Italian restaurant with a large and excellent menu and food. They always made you feel welcome and special. Being greeted by the host and he is wearing jeans and polo shirt not even tucked in demonstrates the attitude of the restaurant and service. The food went from something to look forward to to just okay. It is unfortunate that one of our favorites is no longer providing that wonderful experience. It appears there is new leadership and it isn't what it used to be.
I visited Andreas 25 on a Saturday night at opening and sat near their beautiful glass windows. I really liked that their menu wasn't huge and overwhelming. We started with their broccoli rabe & sausage egg rolls which were so crispy and tasty!! Also their burrata was creamy & delicious with the pesto on top. For entrees we had their NY strip cooked medium & their seafood risotto. Both were EXCELLENT! Highly recommend Andreas!
Second time here. First time we ate at the bar with wine food etc. service was pretty good and we enjoyed our meal. Went two weeks later on a wed night with my son Place nearly empty and staff ok when not hanging out by bar. My meal was fair but the calamari horrible and my sons chicken meal looked like soup and was chewy. Not very appealing to say the least. May or may not be back. I was generous with the three stars.
It was one of the worst meals we have ever had. The noise level was almost unbearable. We would have left the moment we arrived except for the threat to charge a $50 fee for canceling a reservation in less than 24 hours, although we had made our reservation a few minutes bef arriving. Will not return nor recommend. Sorry. I hope this helps the owners to improve their food quality and atmosphere.
Absolutely superb !! What a pleasant surprise !! We will be returning for sure !!
The menu online does not match their actual menu! We were very disappointed that a majority of the items were no longer available. It was no surprise when we brought it up to our waiter he just said ‘yeah, we don't have that stuff anymore'.
Perfect from start to finish. Service was attentive. Food and wine delicious. Had the avocado salad and added grilled shrimp for appetizer and chicken Christina for the entree. The salad was amazing. Creamy avocado and shrimp grilled perfectly. The chicken Christina was so good! The chicken pounded thin and grilled served with garlicky escarole and cannellini beans. It was a wonderful meal!
Restaurantji Recommends
Our 3rd time dining at Andrea's. It never disappoints. The food is delicious and the service is impeccable. Our favorite waiter Johnathon who is ever so pleasant was our server. He is so nice and so attentive. You never have to wonder where he went as he checks back often, makes sure drinks are filled, table is clean. Miguel the busboy is also so pleasant and fills your water, brings you warm fresh bread and wraps up leftovers without even asking. Always a great experience. We love dining there. They care about their customers. You get a home style feel while dining out. A rarity for restaurants these days. We had fried calamari, baked clams, ceasar salad to start followed by penne carbonara and veal chop bone in pizzaiola linguine amatriciana. Cannoli and Tartuffo for dessert. Everything made fresh and delicious. Definitely will return. Recommend as a must try. Buon Appetito
We always enjoy Andrea's 25, and last night was no exception. The standouts about this place are the friendly, attentive service (hostess, bartender, waitress and busser were all incredibly friendly); and the wines by the glass are good. The food is always great, especially the many healthy made to order choices (particularly the salads and the chicken meatballs over zoodles!). We hope this place never changes :)
We went after my friend's oath ceremony so the server got her a congratulatory dessert. The food was excellent and so was the service. Loved the experience!!
I didn't expect much, but damn I was wrong! I had one of the best, restaurant experience by far on Long Island. The space is intimate w/ dim lighting, really sets the mode. There is outdoor tent seating also, but it was to cold for that :). Marvin was out waiter from beginning to end he killed it! The service is just as important as the food! The food was excellent, everything had its own taste, nothing over powering very subtle & pleasant. Great place for a date or just to come by for a drink & appetizers.
We hadn't been there in about three years because the food was always horrible, and the service not so great. We gave it a shot once again last night. We had outdoor seating because on open table that was all that was available. When we had gotten there I believe that managers name was Matt, I had asked him if there was anyway we can be seated inside. He was very accommodating and said yes we just had a table leave. With that being said• the appetizers were all delicious, they were very attentive, never had an empty glass•• and we all enjoyed our meals too! It will be on my list to frequent again!