Food and coffee was overpriced. The cashier didn’t give our change back and when we questioned her she claimed she did and wasn’t too nice about it. We knew that she didn’t based on cash we had left however it wasn’t that much and we didn’t want to make a scene or hold up other people.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
S P
Been going here for like 25 years. Love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Silber
I wanted to share this for anyone buying the “low carb” bagels for health or blood sugar reasons. I wear a continuous glucose monitor and tried these on two separate days to rule out a fluke. Both times, my blood sugar spiked significantly, similar to what I’d expect from a regular bagel.
At $2.25 each, I was happy to pay if they were truly low carb, but based on my real-world readings, they are not. I’m not trying to bash a local business, I just think people who are diabetic, pre-diabetic, or eating low carb should know before spending the money or making health decisions based on the label.
Marketing these as low carb is misleading, especially for people managing blood sugar. I like supporting local businesses, but I also think accuracy matters when it comes to health claims.
Michael M
Always a pleasure to eat here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jswiss
Classic spot for a good bacon egg and cheese. Coffee is average deli!
Erica Berkowitz
I've given this place multiple tries. Usually it's very good but the last three times, there have been major food quality issues. I have been given soft, rotten tasting pickles, what I can presume are leftover pickles from someone else as they were dry and covered in seeds, and now a sliced nova sandwich that is so THICK with fat, you need razor blade teeth to chew it.
This place is expensive and they charge you to use your card. I would just suck it up if the quality was there, but here I am, throwing a $15 piece of bread with fatty unnchewable fish, into the trash can. My cats wouldn't even eat it. Revolting.
Food: 2
Service: 1
Bob Lanzer
John was awesome, service was impeccable....food was awesome and made quickly......definitely worth the trip....even from Virginia
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
George Pappas
AVOID THIS PLACE. Bagel Chalet in Commack is officially overpriced. $25 for 6 cold bagels and 2 small cream cheeses? $15 a lb for cream cheese is a joke. Never going back to get robbed again. Total rip-off!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Debra Domino
Did food to go was not as good as two years ago the bagels are different.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
69 Bird
Busy breakfast spot with delicious bagels. Highly recommend.
Good food, however the cakes and pastries are expensive, but good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Mr Mister
Our first time ordering here. The food was good, and I don't know how they're making their whipped cream but it was absolutely amazing. But I really wrote this to say a thank you to the Sunday morning staff there on 10/12. There was a mix up and we didnt get a lg part of our order. Bagel chalet had their driver drop off our missing items in less than 15mins. There's no accountability for restaurants in the age of door dash/ uber eats. Ive had entire orders swapped out and restaurants blame Uber, Uber blames the restaurant, we get a credit and no one cares where the mess up was.
Food: 4
Service: 5
joel metcalf
Great food, fast service. A locals spot and a little chaotic figuring how to order and how to get your food. First timers be patient and experience this locals gem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Jessica Murray
$4.75 for a bagel with butter??????
Grkgemini 94
15 everything bagels for $28 and they suck. Completely over baked and made the everything seasoning bitter. Bagels were not good, dry and not the right consistency. I genuinely preferred costco bagels to these. I will not go back.
Food and coffee was overpriced. The cashier didn’t give our change back and when we questioned her she claimed she did and wasn’t too nice about it. We knew that she didn’t based on cash we had left however it wasn’t that much and we didn’t want to make a scene or hold up other people.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 2
Been going here for like 25 years. Love it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wanted to share this for anyone buying the “low carb” bagels for health or blood sugar reasons. I wear a continuous glucose monitor and tried these on two separate days to rule out a fluke. Both times, my blood sugar spiked significantly, similar to what I’d expect from a regular bagel.
At $2.25 each, I was happy to pay if they were truly low carb, but based on my real-world readings, they are not. I’m not trying to bash a local business, I just think people who are diabetic, pre-diabetic, or eating low carb should know before spending the money or making health decisions based on the label.
Marketing these as low carb is misleading, especially for people managing blood sugar. I like supporting local businesses, but I also think accuracy matters when it comes to health claims.
Always a pleasure to eat here!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Classic spot for a good bacon egg and cheese. Coffee is average deli!
I've given this place multiple tries. Usually it's very good but the last three times, there have been major food quality issues. I have been given soft, rotten tasting pickles, what I can presume are leftover pickles from someone else as they were dry and covered in seeds, and now a sliced nova sandwich that is so THICK with fat, you need razor blade teeth to chew it.
This place is expensive and they charge you to use your card. I would just suck it up if the quality was there, but here I am, throwing a $15 piece of bread with fatty unnchewable fish, into the trash can. My cats wouldn't even eat it. Revolting.
Food: 2
Service: 1
John was awesome, service was impeccable....food was awesome and made quickly......definitely worth the trip....even from Virginia
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
AVOID THIS PLACE. Bagel Chalet in Commack is officially overpriced. $25 for 6 cold bagels and 2 small cream cheeses? $15 a lb for cream cheese is a joke. Never going back to get robbed again. Total rip-off!
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 1
Did food to go was not as good as two years ago the bagels are different.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Busy breakfast spot with delicious bagels. Highly recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Good food, however the cakes and pastries are expensive, but good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Our first time ordering here. The food was good, and I don't know how they're making their whipped cream but it was absolutely amazing. But I really wrote this to say a thank you to the Sunday morning staff there on 10/12. There was a mix up and we didnt get a lg part of our order. Bagel chalet had their driver drop off our missing items in less than 15mins. There's no accountability for restaurants in the age of door dash/ uber eats. Ive had entire orders swapped out and restaurants blame Uber, Uber blames the restaurant, we get a credit and no one cares where the mess up was.
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great food, fast service. A locals spot and a little chaotic figuring how to order and how to get your food. First timers be patient and experience this locals gem.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
$4.75 for a bagel with butter??????
15 everything bagels for $28 and they suck. Completely over baked and made the everything seasoning bitter. Bagels were not good, dry and not the right consistency. I genuinely preferred costco bagels to these. I will not go back.
Food: 2
Loading...