Five Guys

6546 Jericho Turnpike, Commack
(631) 850-3437

Recent Reviews

Ash C.

Let me start with the good. I have celiac disease, so fast food is not something I can usually enjoy. That's part of what makes Five Guys so nice for me---everything is completely safe, and it's great food as well. But as of recently, the prices have just gotten completely out of hand. I get meals here fairly regularly, and over the past 8 months or so I've watched the prices of everything steadily rise to unreasonable levels. What was my (already expensive) $21 meal last year is now $26, for the exact same stuff. $12 for a cheeseburger is just ridiculous. It makes absolutely no sense, and I only wish I had any better options due to my allergy. Yeah, I can just not eat fast food, but sometimes that craving is just there.

Matthew

Good food!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Conlin

Ok food, terrible service, dirty

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 4

Service: 3

Pharo Ksp

Straight up trash. Not Tasty, For the price it’s not worth it.

Matthew Slater

Absolutely over priced. Nice workers but the food is absolutely overpriced, not just at this location but all of them on the island. I got 2 small burger meals and it came out to 36 bucks. That’s 2 burgers, 2 fries and 2 drinks. Outrageous pricing.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 2

Calogero Migliore

Over priced grease burgers

Edward Park

Good burgers and fries. Great place to hang out. The French fries are also great. The price is reasonable. The staff is super friendly.

Joanne Currie

Fresh food worth the wait. And the Nicest staff & management...

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacob Fingerman

Tried asking if they do fundraisers. Was told to jump off a cliff. Very unprofessional.

Service: 1

Samantha C.

I must say this is an impressive Five guys on the island. I've been to many and I often come for lunch. I've been frequenting this particular location for a few years now going on eight years. The staff is always happy and attentive, which is rare to find these days because everyone doesn't wanna work, but here it doesn't show.I usually get a double cheeseburger with jalapeños , Barbecue sauce and hot sauce. I'll pair it with a large strawberry milkshake, which taste like heaven on earth.I highly recommend coming with the family if you're looking for a cheap, healthy selling, and tasty treat. It will definitely impress you, especially within the current economy. Thank you to the staff and moms I highly recommend coming.

Candice DickFitInYoMouth

All the food was delicious! But I wish it was served better. The fries were in a cup and didn’t have a special container and the burger wasn’t wrapped just on a plate, 4.5/5 stars

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tim J.

This was my first time at a Five Guys in a while (probably over a year). I'm not sure if perhaps they changed the process in that time, but what I remember being a pretty good burger was absolutely awful. No flavor, all grease, very small, and, despite being fresh beef, somehow tasted like it had been defrosted in a microwave. Fries were burned and service was slow.

Linda D.

The establishment large and cleanThe staff were friendly and courteous. The peanuts are back!!!Our meals were on point and deliciousThe only thing is they no longer give the vast amount of fries they use too

Roy J.

The little cheeseburger is a great choice. I had that with a little Cajun fries and a pink lemonade. The wall decor is super cool, and tell you more about Five Guys as a company. I recommend coming here for lunch. Everyone smiles too!

Tim N.

Mullet glasses guy had terrible customer service today. He rolled his eyes when I asked about ice cream flavors. Then he hands me my shake and doesn't say a word after I say thank you.

Load More