Looking for a Small batch, hand crafted, masterfully prepared, delicious, indulgent, ice cream? Get here, you won’t be disappointed!
J R
Unfortunately not a great place. Went 3 weeks in a row (tradition is getting ice cream on Sundays) 1st week it was alright nothing special notice ice cream was a weird consistency,nice staff. 2nd week noticed the ice cream tubs that had been melted and frost bitten over was still there and untouched from the week prior. Came a 3rd time and saw the same 2 melted ice cream tubs frost bitten over and their chocolate ice cream worst consistency. Decided we weren't going back. Couple weeks later the kids want ice cream sandwich saucer things I didn't want to drive all the way to carvel so I went there to find all of them were frost bitten and the SAME MELTED ICE CREAM TUB in the section where they scoop it for you... I walked right out and drove to carvel... Always try for yourself you may like it but I personally go to a lot of special ice cream spots and they normally have more fresh stuff.
Madison Jean
Spent $24.81 on a shake and 2 scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, and Oreo toppings. To sell ice cream for the price the Oreos should not be stale. Very disappointing..
Mary licona
The staff is very friendly, they have a variety of delicious flavors, the price is very affordable, 100% recommended
Eric Wendt
Never update the seamless/ubereats menu for the flavors, so when I order, they never have the flavor. They end up calling me to tell me constantly. I’ll get cold stone.
J Rose
Love Ice Cream Social Commack! Generous portions, fantastic cakes and overall amazing products!!! The kids love it! Would definitely recommend!
F K
$10.50 for a medium soft serve with sprinkles?
Pat Lowes
Waaaaaaay too expensive. Won’t be coming back :(((
Scott Cackett
The owner makes me horny ......
Jenny Maldonado
The flavors are so delicious. However, the price is not worth what you get. They’re very stingy with the scoops. I don’t mind paying +$12 for a waffle bowl but I’d be satisfied if it was filled with the amount of ice cream it can hold.
The flavors are super creative and the quality is super rich in this locally owned spot run by a chef! The flavors change regularly and everything is home made. My favorite is the pumpkin Oreo. They also have boozy eggnog, coconut chip, Mexican hot chocolate. The only thing I wish for is some tables to sit at.
Alex Garcia
It was my first time there. I live in Commack but someone in Hauppague recommended this place. They have a lot of standard flavors and seasonal flavors. They also have a separate section for vegan flavors. We ended up getting two shakes one was a Chocolate pumpkin shake and the other was a Rainbow Cookie malt shake. Both were probably some of the best shakes I’ve ever had. I’m a big shake guy so I’m not easily impressed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Family SV
The ice cream here is absolutely delicious! We’ve ordered two birthday cakes from them. The artistry was stunning! You can taste the quality of the ingredients and the fact that it is homemade! Service is always friendly! Whether at the main shop or at a pop up. It is owned and operated by a local family too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Anonymous
The ice cream is very good however two single scoop cups should not cost $14. And then they have the audacity to put tip cups by the register. For those prices they should be paying their employees better. Refuse to pay those prices so I won’t be returning.
Food: 3
Ian Winkler
The ice cream is great! Great tasting and too many choices ?. Friendly, helpful staff. I'll be back!
Looking for a Small batch, hand crafted, masterfully prepared, delicious, indulgent, ice cream? Get here, you won’t be disappointed!
Unfortunately not a great place. Went 3 weeks in a row (tradition is getting ice cream on Sundays) 1st week it was alright nothing special notice ice cream was a weird consistency,nice staff. 2nd week noticed the ice cream tubs that had been melted and frost bitten over was still there and untouched from the week prior. Came a 3rd time and saw the same 2 melted ice cream tubs frost bitten over and their chocolate ice cream worst consistency. Decided we weren't going back. Couple weeks later the kids want ice cream sandwich saucer things I didn't want to drive all the way to carvel so I went there to find all of them were frost bitten and the SAME MELTED ICE CREAM TUB in the section where they scoop it for you... I walked right out and drove to carvel... Always try for yourself you may like it but I personally go to a lot of special ice cream spots and they normally have more fresh stuff.
Spent $24.81 on a shake and 2 scoops of ice cream, whipped cream, and Oreo toppings. To sell ice cream for the price the Oreos should not be stale. Very disappointing..
The staff is very friendly, they have a variety of delicious flavors, the price is very affordable, 100% recommended
Never update the seamless/ubereats menu for the flavors, so when I order, they never have the flavor. They end up calling me to tell me constantly. I’ll get cold stone.
Love Ice Cream Social Commack! Generous portions, fantastic cakes and overall amazing products!!! The kids love it! Would definitely recommend!
$10.50 for a medium soft serve with sprinkles?
Waaaaaaay too expensive. Won’t be coming back :(((
The owner makes me horny ......
The flavors are so delicious. However, the price is not worth what you get. They’re very stingy with the scoops. I don’t mind paying +$12 for a waffle bowl but I’d be satisfied if it was filled with the amount of ice cream it can hold.
Restaurantji Recommends
The flavors are super creative and the quality is super rich in this locally owned spot run by a chef! The flavors change regularly and everything is home made. My favorite is the pumpkin Oreo. They also have boozy eggnog, coconut chip, Mexican hot chocolate. The only thing I wish for is some tables to sit at.
It was my first time there. I live in Commack but someone in Hauppague recommended this place. They have a lot of standard flavors and seasonal flavors. They also have a separate section for vegan flavors. We ended up getting two shakes one was a Chocolate pumpkin shake and the other was a Rainbow Cookie malt shake. Both were probably some of the best shakes I’ve ever had. I’m a big shake guy so I’m not easily impressed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
The ice cream here is absolutely delicious! We’ve ordered two birthday cakes from them. The artistry was stunning! You can taste the quality of the ingredients and the fact that it is homemade! Service is always friendly! Whether at the main shop or at a pop up. It is owned and operated by a local family too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The ice cream is very good however two single scoop cups should not cost $14. And then they have the audacity to put tip cups by the register. For those prices they should be paying their employees better. Refuse to pay those prices so I won’t be returning.
Food: 3
The ice cream is great! Great tasting and too many choices ?. Friendly, helpful staff. I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rainbow Cookie Ice Cream
Loading...