Il Toscano Seafood & Steak

6330 Jericho Turnpike, Commack
(631) 486-2808

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Thomas

Excellent , service, recommended specials ,staff well trained to serve , Michelin quality to customers Highly recommend, prices are very reasonable !!

Stephanie

We had a 12 pm reservation for Mother's Day. I selected outdoor dining and requested a shady spot/umbrella as we were bringing our newborn with us. We got there at 12 and none of the outdoor tables were set up at all, so it took awhile to get situated. There were also no umbrellas out at all despite pictures of the restaurant showing many. The staff was nice enough to get one out for us though. The menu was limited for brunch, which I knew, but we found all of the food to be lacking. The burgers were supposed to come with Parmesan truffle tots but came with undercooked French fries instead. The inside of the restaurant was rather empty as well, which wasn't a good sign in hindsight. The service started off okay, but despite having a lot of waitstaff there (and it not being crowded) the service was too slow as the meal went on. We ordered milk for our son and it didn't come until the end of the meal (and we didn't see anyone to ask before that). It also took a long time to get the check, which my husband had to go inside to ask for. I would not return.

Denise

Beautiful restaurant and the service was excellent. Went there for my husband's birthday. Most importantly food was wonderful. Very interesting menu. Highly recommend.

Reesa

Could not have felt more welcomed. Outstanding service. Food was delicious! The cheesecake is a must.

Opentable Diner

Good was very good, and the owner treated us very well. Very nice inside and not too loud. The pistachio tiramisu was amazing. Would def come again

pam

We were seated right away and then waited for our server. No one came and manager took drink order and then also took our food order - literally 20 mins after being seated and placing orders, this young waiter, at no fault of his own, he was slammed, came over and started from the beginning. We told him we had ordered no problem!! Then food came and we never saw anyone else again till I got up and asked for the bill! Only one side of restaurant was busy but obviously only one server. Now the food, pork chop would have been awesome if it wasn't over salted! The sea bass was excellent but pesto crusted was all bread crumbs no pesto! Lobster mashed potatoes were cold. And the salad was OVER dressed and wayyyy too many olives! Sorry, might be a one off- We shall see

Ann

Have eaten here a few time , hostess is lovely and comes around to make sure meals and service are good . Wait staff is always professional and excellent . Live music to listen to while eating is always a plus , so a great place to eat , I've never had a bad dish

Brianna

HORRIBLE. Walked in for a 12:30 reservation and no one worker was there besides the chef. Not the hostess, not a waitress, no one. Was seating by the chef. No music was on no heat. He said he had to put the heat on for us. Meanwhile the restaurant opened at 11:30. He also told us our waitress was on the way. After 1pm still not waitress. We got up and left. Was so sketchy. Not a sole was in there as well. Will never go back. Not sure how they are in business still.

KATHLEEN

Service was great, Food was excellent. There were 4 people in our party salad was enough to split

MaryAnn

We had 8 people in our party. We had a nice large round table, which was great for conversation! All the food and drinks where excellent! our server was very attentive all night.

Hyman

Had 7 pm reservation for four. Started with Calamari Garibaldi which was excellrnt I had the stuffed veal, my wife had the Fioretti Ristica, my son had the Super Tuscan and my daughter in law had the Rigatoni BR all were again exceclent! There was nothing to complain about with the food. As good as the food was the staff was even better from a great bartender to our server, his support help and the hostess! Fantastic experience and cannot wait to go back. If you have not tried this restaraunt you are missing a great dinning experience!

Kevin

The calamari appetizer was really excellent, generous portion, really nicely seasoned. My wife loved her osso bucco entre. I really enjoyed the pork chop, great browning and crust, outstanding flavor The creme brulee could have had more of a crackle crust. We were both impressed with the affogato, rich ice cream, dark espresso top it off with a sip of sambuca Exceeded our expectations, all the way around. we'll be back soon.

Glenn

I think we actually expected more Italian food on the menu. Menu was quite limited. Appetizers were good, entrees were ok, we just thought we were going to an Italian restaurant. Desserts were kind of disappointing, lacking in flavor. Servers were attentive, everyone was very nice.

Ronnie

Went on Valentines Day and there was a prefixed menu which was $85 per person. The menu options weren't great and didn't feel like $85 per person quality. Service slow. The place was LOUD due to live music taking place in the bar area. Unsure if this location wants to be a sports bar or a fine dining establishment. Willing to give them another shot on a non holiday/non live music night.

Lacie

Why does this place have good ratings? For a $265 dinner for 2 the quality was not good at all! It took 25-30 mins for to served a warm drink which tasted like rubbing alcohol. My sea bass was overcooked/stringy and the server never came back after the food was dropped off. Dessert was worse than Carvel. Manager was also quite rude. Very undesirable experience.

Loading...