There’s a new owner and they’ve changed everything. All of the food is awful. Can’t recommend it any more. There goes my favorite pizza place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Nicole Biggins
I'm really disappointed today. We ordered a large everything pizza that was great as always, but our pepperoni pie didn't have any pepperoni on it. You know what, things happen, so I gave them a call, so we can come up with a solution later on. When I called though, I got either put on mute hold, or hung up on... so I tried to call again, put me straight to hold again.Guys, I just wanted an easy solution to fix this, maybe a free topping with my next order, a refund for the pepperoni topping that I didn't get? Something!So, make sure you check your pizza when you get them, since they don't have the time to pick up your calls... I'm so sad, we really love this place. I didn't think we had to check our stuff before leaving here, for this place too.
Service: 2
Zoe C.
I thought about leaving a "review" 5 times before finally settling on. Yes, I feel I should at this point. I have been a customer on/off at Taormina for 20+ yrs. It was always good up until the last 5 yrs. In my opinion. It's almost like they gave up caring ab9ut accuracy and quality food. The lasagna and ravioli were hard, and NO taste to the sauce. The infamous giving the wrong salad (which is not fresh looking) with soggy croutons or dressing continues even after we call to kindly remind them what we ordered to make no error. The place itself when you sit is quint enough. Most (not all) of the staff could care less when called to all the errors met only with "We're so sorry" and "You want to drive 30 minutes back to pick up the correct etc." No. We do not. I think crossing this past loved restaurant is finally off the list. Good luck if you order take-out. Choose wisely when you dine in.
joe
Went here for the first time it was the best experience every Anthony made me feel at home and had a great vibe the pasta was really good highly recommend 100% going
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Joy B.
Great food. Best pizza in Huntington by far. Quick and efficient service. They have a cute little restaurant in the back that I will have to sit in and eat at next date night with my husband.
Angelise Galarza
Hidden gem for sure. Taormina’s is a cozy authentic pizza spot with a wide variety of dishes, nestled perfectly into a shopping center, so there’s plenty of parking. Classic New York style pizza with many options for toppings. Great pizza, & the grilled chicken wrap is especially delicious with their house vinaigrette! Staff and management will make you feel at home, and Anthony continues to provide my family with great service with every visit.
Hidden gem for sure. Taormina's is a cozy authentic pizza spot with a wide variety of dishes, nestled perfectly into a shopping center, so there's plenty of parking. Classic New York style pizza with many options for toppings. Great pizza, & the grilled chicken wrap is especially delicious with their house vinaigrette! Staff and management will make you feel at home, and Anthony continues to provide my family with great service with every visit.
whos jack
Just great not stuffy. Food is fantastic.Parking: Parking lot right in front
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fettuccine Alfredo, Baked Clams, Salad Dressing, Penne Pasta with Tomato Sauce or Butter, Tiramisu, Eggplant Parmigiana, Salad, Chicken Francese, Chicken Marsala
Andrew Channin
Popped in here on a whim to grab some slices. Had a slice of Grandma and a slice of Buffalo. Whatever you're doing with the crust here, keep doing it. The sauce on the grandma slice was phenomenal . Good job! I'll definitely be back next time I'm doing business around here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
MrBlz
We have written several reviews on Taormina because it is always a great dining experience. On this occasion, I had the pork ossobuco and it was amazing. It's our go to place. And the staff is terrific.
Crooks. Price advertised is not what they charge. This weeks paper says $20.50 for a pie. Charged $22.50. When I raised the issue the manager said this is the price. Their own ad was wrong.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
joyful
Food is consistently good here. Try the stuffed artichoke. So good. I had linguini with white clam sauce. Full of chopped clams, I would like some fresh clams. Husband had spaghetti with meat sauce which he thoroughly enjoyed. Wish they'd get some new more contemporary wine glasses. So dated. We have been here many times and have never been disappointed.
Howard K.
Crooks. Price advertised is not what they charge. This weeks paper says $20.50 for a pie. Charged $22.50. When I raised the issue the manager said this is the price. Their own ad was wrong.
Paula
My girlfriend is gluten free. Checked with the waitress to make sure her dish could be prepared gluten free. Dish came and again she asked if the dish was gluten free. The server told her yes. After taking a few bites the server came back and said there was an error and the dish contains gluten. My friend will now be sick tomorrow as she is highly allergic to gluten. The dish was remade gluten free. We received apologies but still charged us for the dish. Really!!! Will never go back!!!
Edward Park
We've had lunch, dinner, takeout and catered a party from here. Each occasion was great. The staff is helpful and friendly and the food is amazing.
There’s a new owner and they’ve changed everything. All of the food is awful. Can’t recommend it any more. There goes my favorite pizza place.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
I'm really disappointed today. We ordered a large everything pizza that was great as always, but our pepperoni pie didn't have any pepperoni on it. You know what, things happen, so I gave them a call, so we can come up with a solution later on. When I called though, I got either put on mute hold, or hung up on... so I tried to call again, put me straight to hold again.Guys, I just wanted an easy solution to fix this, maybe a free topping with my next order, a refund for the pepperoni topping that I didn't get? Something!So, make sure you check your pizza when you get them, since they don't have the time to pick up your calls... I'm so sad, we really love this place. I didn't think we had to check our stuff before leaving here, for this place too.
Service: 2
I thought about leaving a "review" 5 times before finally settling on. Yes, I feel I should at this point. I have been a customer on/off at Taormina for 20+ yrs. It was always good up until the last 5 yrs. In my opinion. It's almost like they gave up caring ab9ut accuracy and quality food. The lasagna and ravioli were hard, and NO taste to the sauce. The infamous giving the wrong salad (which is not fresh looking) with soggy croutons or dressing continues even after we call to kindly remind them what we ordered to make no error. The place itself when you sit is quint enough. Most (not all) of the staff could care less when called to all the errors met only with "We're so sorry" and "You want to drive 30 minutes back to pick up the correct etc." No. We do not. I think crossing this past loved restaurant is finally off the list. Good luck if you order take-out. Choose wisely when you dine in.
Went here for the first time it was the best experience every Anthony made me feel at home and had a great vibe the pasta was really good highly recommend 100% going
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food. Best pizza in Huntington by far. Quick and efficient service. They have a cute little restaurant in the back that I will have to sit in and eat at next date night with my husband.
Hidden gem for sure. Taormina’s is a cozy authentic pizza spot with a wide variety of dishes, nestled perfectly into a shopping center, so there’s plenty of parking. Classic New York style pizza with many options for toppings. Great pizza, & the grilled chicken wrap is especially delicious with their house vinaigrette! Staff and management will make you feel at home, and Anthony continues to provide my family with great service with every visit.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken, Salad Dressing
Hidden gem for sure. Taormina's is a cozy authentic pizza spot with a wide variety of dishes, nestled perfectly into a shopping center, so there's plenty of parking. Classic New York style pizza with many options for toppings. Great pizza, & the grilled chicken wrap is especially delicious with their house vinaigrette! Staff and management will make you feel at home, and Anthony continues to provide my family with great service with every visit.
Just great not stuffy. Food is fantastic.Parking: Parking lot right in front
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fettuccine Alfredo, Baked Clams, Salad Dressing, Penne Pasta with Tomato Sauce or Butter, Tiramisu, Eggplant Parmigiana, Salad, Chicken Francese, Chicken Marsala
Popped in here on a whim to grab some slices. Had a slice of Grandma and a slice of Buffalo. Whatever you're doing with the crust here, keep doing it. The sauce on the grandma slice was phenomenal . Good job! I'll definitely be back next time I'm doing business around here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have written several reviews on Taormina because it is always a great dining experience. On this occasion, I had the pork ossobuco and it was amazing. It's our go to place. And the staff is terrific.
Restaurantji Recommends
Crooks. Price advertised is not what they charge. This weeks paper says $20.50 for a pie. Charged $22.50. When I raised the issue the manager said this is the price. Their own ad was wrong.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Food is consistently good here. Try the stuffed artichoke. So good. I had linguini with white clam sauce. Full of chopped clams, I would like some fresh clams. Husband had spaghetti with meat sauce which he thoroughly enjoyed. Wish they'd get some new more contemporary wine glasses. So dated. We have been here many times and have never been disappointed.
Crooks. Price advertised is not what they charge. This weeks paper says $20.50 for a pie. Charged $22.50. When I raised the issue the manager said this is the price. Their own ad was wrong.
My girlfriend is gluten free. Checked with the waitress to make sure her dish could be prepared gluten free. Dish came and again she asked if the dish was gluten free. The server told her yes. After taking a few bites the server came back and said there was an error and the dish contains gluten. My friend will now be sick tomorrow as she is highly allergic to gluten. The dish was remade gluten free. We received apologies but still charged us for the dish. Really!!! Will never go back!!!
We've had lunch, dinner, takeout and catered a party from here. Each occasion was great. The staff is helpful and friendly and the food is amazing.
Food: 5