New York Pizzeria
75 Chestnut St, Cooperstown
(607) 547-2930
Customers' Favorites
Garlic Knots with Marinara
Classic Cheese Pizza
New York-Style Pizza
Chicken Parmigiana
Mozzarella Sticks
Antipasto Salad
Buffalo Chicken
Chicken Nuggets
Pepperoni Pizza
Slice of Pizza
Menu
Photos
+54 photos
+53 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Every Columbus Day weekend about 30 members of our tractor club goes to Cooperstown for tractor fest. On Friday evening we order pizza and wings and on Saturday we order catered pans of food. From the minute you place the order to the time you pick up the food, all of the employees are very helpful and extremely pleasant to deal with. They are just genuinely nice people, even though they are always extremely busy. The food is always excellent. In a world of short staffed, frazzled...
Having grown up in the area and leaving in my early 20’s, this is always my go to spot when I’m back and the one thing I crave most when I’m home in Indiana. On our last visit, we had 4 pizzas in 5 days and brought two back to Indiana with us to share with our family here! NYP Cooperstown will always be my favorite restaurant!
Pizza was bland and boring. The crust was too fluffy (not NY style) with absolutely no taste. We had to ask for extra sauce and coat with grated parm to give it any flavor. My husband says they wouldn’t last a day in NYC. One positive: the location is great, because we were starving after hours at the Hall of Fame.
You May Also Like
Cooperstown Distillery - 11 Railroad Ave
![]()
Distilleries
Mel's at 22 - 22 Chestnut St
![]()
American, Bar, Seafood, Vegan, Vegetarian
Schneider's Bakery - 157 Main St
![]()
Bakery, Custom Cakes, Donuts, American