Milky Ways Ice Cream & Cereal Bar

2229 Rte 112, Coram
(631) 846-8868

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

Chunky Monkey Special Swirl
Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Adult Cup Ice Cream
Toasted Coconut
Ice Cream Swirl
Fruity Pebbles
Cookie Monster
Cocoa Pebbles
Rice Krispies
Silly Rabbit

Menu

Ice Cream and Milkshake
Adult Cup Ice Cream
Milkshake
XL Cup Ice Cream

Specials Swirl

Camo Fire Special Swirl
Vanilla, cinnamon toast crunch, oreos blended, space bites and oreos on top marshmallow drizzle
Cactus Jack Special Swirl
Vanilla, resses puff, nutter butter blended, reeses peanut butter cups on top chocolate, peanut butter drizzle.
Meet the Flinstones Special Swirl
Vanilla fruity pebbles blended, cookies dough with fp dust on top chocolar and marshmallow drizzle.
The Crumbs Special Swirl
Vanilla, captain crunch berris blended, strawberry short cake crumble and cheesecake on top marshmallow drizzle.
Cookies Monster Special Swirl
Vanilla, cookie crisp blended, cookie crunches and cookie dough on top chocolate drizzle.
Silly Rabbit Special Swirl
Vanilla, trix, fruity pebbles blended, brownie bites and fruity pebbles dust on top honey drizzle.
Strawberry Crunch Special Swirl
Strawberry, cinnamon toast crunch blended, brownie bites and cheesecake on top raspberry drizzle.
Chunky Monkey Special Swirl
Vanilla. chocolate sprinkles, bananas and nutter butter, peanut butter drizzle.

Specials Milkshake

Camp Fire Specials Milkshake
Vanilla, cinnamon toast crunch, oreos blended, space bites and oreos on top marshmallow drizzle
Cactus Jack Specials Milkshake
Vanilla, resses puff, nutter butter blended, reeses peanut butter cups on top chocolate, peanut butter drizzle.
Meet the Flinstones Specials Milkshake
Vanilla fruity pebbles blended, cookies dough with fp dust on top chocolar and marshmallow drizzle.
The Crumbs Specials Milkshake
Vanilla, captain crunch berris blended, strawberry short cake crumble and cheesecake on top marshmallow drizzle.
Cookies Monster Specials Milkshake
Vanilla, cookie crisp blended, cookie crunches and cookie dough on top chocolate drizzle.
Silly Rabbit Specials Milkshake
Vanilla, trix, fruity pebbles blended, brownie bites and fruity pebbles dust on top honey drizzle.
Strawberry Crunch Special Milkshake
Strawberry, cinnamon toast crunch blended, brownie bites and cheesecake on top raspberry drizzle.
Chunky Monkey Specials Milkshake
Vanilla. chocolate sprinkles, bananas and nutter butter, peanut butter drizzle.
THE GOAT Special Milkshake
Vanilla ice cream Honey bunches oats with almonds. Topped with cookie dough and bananas with honey drizzle

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: facebook
+15 photos
Photo credit: facebook
+14 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Such a fun spot! I got vanilla soft serve ice cream with cinnamon toast crunch mixed in and topped with brownie bites and cheesecake bites — it was so good. Love how they can mix any cereal into the ice cream. Super creamy and delicious!
July 2025
The guys working tonight nailed my shake, I told them a little bit about my taste for desserts and they straight hit it out of the park. Oscar, Andrew, and Angel each gave input on recipes that would work for my taste and actually Surprised Me. Very good service, very clean environment, and the guys had a good sense of humor.
June 2025
Staff are very welcoming and helpful. They offered great recommendations while also adjusting to anything I was craving. They pay very close attention to detail and made sure that my ice cream came out perfect. Highly recommend this place!
April 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Bueno deli 2 - 2229 NY-112
Dominican, Beverage Store, Coffee & Tea, Deli, Seafood
Tommy's Old Town Tavern - 2229 NY-112
Bar, Pubs, Sports Bar
Bloomberg Bagel - 2229 Rte 112

Milky Ways Ice Cream & Cereal Bar

2229 Rte 112, Coram, NY 11727
(631) 846-8868