The pizza was disgusting. I am not a picky eater but this was just gross. Ended up throwing it away.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Bob Jim
Pros: 1. friendly 2. Heavy garlic butter flavor if you are into that
Cons: 1. $30 cash for medium pizza and 10 wings 2. Pizza crust was overcooked, giving the texture and taste of cardboard 3. Cheese on top was undercooked??? 4. Pizza sause non existent 5. Do NOT buy the wings. Very dry, no flavor. No wing sause whatsoever, just an oil???
Here is a wing sause I make when I do wings since A Round Pizza doesn't know how to make sause: 1. 1 bottle of franks hot sause 2. 1-2 sticks of butter 3. That's it, it is literally that easy to make a good wing sause.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Nicholas DeLessio
Pros: the pizza is very good, particularly for the area, and the prices seem fair.
Cons: Very limited menu compared to most pizzerias (literally just pizza, wings, salads and a couple sides) and I wasn't crazy about their garlic knots (last time I went they tasted to me like they used jarred garlic.)
If you're looking to get good pizza, I'd say to give this place a try. If you're looking for anything much more than pizza or wings, you might have to try another place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Katie Peterson
I ordered via Door Dash. It was a large pie, with pepperoni. The crust was burnt and there was barely any sauce on it. This is not the experience I've had in the past but I can't afford to buy food and then throw it away. This was very disappointing.
Food: 2
Andrea Morey
You can get two huge slices and a drink for $8! I go there for lunch every week or so. Pizza is great!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Naomi
Perfect tasting pizza with genuine crust that is edible. Real toppings and ingredients. Highly recommend.
THE FISH OASIS
Best pizza around cortland by far! and the blue moon wings, the best! Only comment I could make is make the sauce and topping and cheese go closer to either edge with less crust, but dude! I’ll def buy another party pack from here and a chicken wing pizza!
Aaron Grey (Aaron and Cindy)
Pretty good pizza
Sheila Lienemann
Buffalo chicken salad is amazing 10 out 0f 10 always
Stopped in looking to get a couple slices of cheese pizza they had 1 slice and about 8 other cheese pies out and was told that the pies weren't for sale a d they could not be cut into slices. The crew that was working didn't seem very enthusiastic of wanting to make a sale probably won't attempt this place again the staff wasn't even that friendly
Christopher Bistocchi
not the first time i had it, but it might the last. chicken wing pizza was not done an not good, i’ve made better pizzas at home
Christina Kan
We were looking for a restaurant off the highway and found this gem. Excellent pizza and the sweetest people. So sweet to our 3 kids. The kids loved their ny style pizza and the people! Highly recommend!
Cody Morton
Stopped by for lunch got 2 slices and a drink went to pick up and was told I didn't pay for a drink. $8+ for 2 slices of day old cheese pizza and a can of Pepsi seems like a ripoff to me. Definitely much better local options to choose from where the works aren't snobby.
sgim43
Tell me you're up to unethical business practices without telling me you're up to unethical business practices. Rip off customers with obscene fees if you don't pay in cash - If they can't cheat on their taxes they'll just steal from you instead! NO other reason to charge over 12% (4-6x the processing fees) to customers for not paying in cash.
Amazing food cheap prices
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza was disgusting. I am not a picky eater but this was just gross. Ended up throwing it away.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 5
Pros:
1. friendly
2. Heavy garlic butter flavor if you are into that
Cons:
1. $30 cash for medium pizza and 10 wings
2. Pizza crust was overcooked, giving the texture and taste of cardboard
3. Cheese on top was undercooked???
4. Pizza sause non existent
5. Do NOT buy the wings. Very dry, no flavor. No wing sause whatsoever, just an oil???
Here is a wing sause I make when I do wings since A Round Pizza doesn't know how to make sause:
1. 1 bottle of franks hot sause
2. 1-2 sticks of butter
3. That's it, it is literally that easy to make a good wing sause.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Pros: the pizza is very good, particularly for the area, and the prices seem fair.
Cons: Very limited menu compared to most pizzerias (literally just pizza, wings, salads and a couple sides) and I wasn't crazy about their garlic knots (last time I went they tasted to me like they used jarred garlic.)
If you're looking to get good pizza, I'd say to give this place a try. If you're looking for anything much more than pizza or wings, you might have to try another place.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
I ordered via Door Dash. It was a large pie, with pepperoni.
The crust was burnt and there was barely any sauce on it.
This is not the experience I've had in the past but I can't afford to buy food and then throw it away.
This was very disappointing.
Food: 2
You can get two huge slices and a drink for $8! I go there for lunch every week or so. Pizza is great!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Perfect tasting pizza with genuine crust that is edible. Real toppings and ingredients. Highly recommend.
Best pizza around cortland by far! and the blue moon wings, the best!
Only comment I could make is make the sauce and topping and cheese go closer to either edge with less crust, but dude! I’ll def buy another party pack from here and a chicken wing pizza!
Pretty good pizza
Buffalo chicken salad is amazing 10 out 0f 10 always
Restaurantji Recommends
Stopped in looking to get a couple slices of cheese pizza they had 1 slice and about 8 other cheese pies out and was told that the pies weren't for sale a d they could not be cut into slices. The crew that was working didn't seem very enthusiastic of wanting to make a sale probably won't attempt this place again the staff wasn't even that friendly
not the first time i had it, but it might the last. chicken wing pizza was not done an not good, i’ve made better pizzas at home
We were looking for a restaurant off the highway and found this gem. Excellent pizza and the sweetest people. So sweet to our 3 kids. The kids loved their ny style pizza and the people! Highly recommend!
Stopped by for lunch got 2 slices and a drink went to pick up and was told I didn't pay for a drink. $8+ for 2 slices of day old cheese pizza and a can of Pepsi seems like a ripoff to me. Definitely much better local options to choose from where the works aren't snobby.
Tell me you're up to unethical business practices without telling me you're up to unethical business practices. Rip off customers with obscene fees if you don't pay in cash - If they can't cheat on their taxes they'll just steal from you instead! NO other reason to charge over 12% (4-6x the processing fees) to customers for not paying in cash.
Loading...