Coffee Pot Cellars

31855 Main Rd, Cutchogue
(631) 765-8929

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Yael W

Amazing shop!! Absolutely obsessed with their jams and wine. Everything is delicious and fresh so its well worth the trip to get some!!! Better yet, is the lovely people who run it. Adam is fun to talk to for an hour or so and Laura is the sweetest most inspiring human! Please go support local business and local pollinators by visiting this cute farm.

Jerry Wichrowski

Great wine and great people!

Chelsea Gotz

This is my favorite place to go when I'm out east! I've been coming here for at least 6 or 7 years now, I'm also a member of their wine club. I recently got engaged here, Laura made everything perfect and helped my aunt and fiancé arrange everything in secret! Nothing better than good wine, puppy pets and Laura's smiling face on any weekend visit out east! ??

Atmosphere: 5

Service: 5

Elena M Colón

One of my absolute faves! The wines are great from the Meritage to the rosé. Adam is an excellent winemaker. Laura is always happy to see you and have a chat and Anna is following in Beasley’s (Try his blend!) footsteps ? beautifully as director of hospitality and cutest, sweetest pup ever. The vibe is chill and unpretentious and the porch is perfect to relax and enjoy a glass of wine. Great place!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chardonnay

Al Henneborn

It's been a number of years since we last visited Coffee Pot Cellars (we met Beasley back then). We decided to visit the tasting room based upon my daughter raving about their Merlot. All the wines were so good that we had to join the wine club and bring home 1.5 cases. Just found another Nork Fork hidden gem winery. Shhh don't tell anybody.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Margie Fetscher

Don’t miss this stop while on the North Fork wine trail! We had a lovely visit and enjoyed all of the wines and our conversations with Laura. A quaint small tasting room with delicious wine and homemade jam for sale.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Clarissa Wachenfeld

I’m so happy we stopped in! Delicious wine and awesome conversations!! Loved learning about pollinators! Do not pass this place by!

Millie Kwan

Coffee Pot Cellars is a delightful stop on the North Fork wine trail. Just note that they are open mainly on the days around and including the weekend days. We had the privilege of meeting the winemaker, Adam, who was a great host and obviously knows his wines well. He also went to my alma mater so we had to talk about our university too. The wines were nice, but they do not expect to ship their wine unless you live in New York since they only ship in state. His wife also runs a farm and makes preserves, jams, etc and preserves Monarch butterflies. Very enjoyable stop and recommend.

Danny

Their Rose is really bold with lots of fruit flavor. Cab Franc is one of the best on the North Fork and and found a gem 2015 Merlot

Matt Stamos

Great wine and conversation. A must stop!

Thomas Mele

So good. Friendly. Like having wine with family. Say hello to Anna

Jason Darmiento

Great wines and conversation.

A.J. Schumacher

One of the best wineries on the North Shore. The owner, Laura, runs the tasting room and is the highlight of any visit. She is always wonderful to chat with while she pours you some excellent wines.

Kacey Nady

Laura was an absolute pleasure and such a home-y feel to their place. Loved the experience of our tasting!

April Fucci

We love Coffee Pot Cellars!The Beasley's Blend and Merlots are lovely! We enjoy visiting when we're in the area and the owners are always so welcoming, kind, and fun!

Loading...