John & Mary's Restaurant

Name: John & Mary's Restaurant
Address: 6425 Transit Rd, Depew, New York, 14043, US
Telephone: (716) 684-4800
Price range: $
Rating: 3.5

$ • Pizza, American, Chicken Wings

Hours:
6425 Transit Rd, Depew
(716) 684-4800

Menu Order Online Reserve

About John & Mary's Restaurant

John & Mary's Restaurant is a simple eatery serving tasty meals. While the service can be hit or miss, some staff display friendly attitudes, while others may be less welcoming. The food is good, with options including sandwiches, pizza, and pasta. Customers appreciate the sausage sub, which tastes the same as it did 15 years ago, and is known to be filling and delicious. However, some recent changes have caused frustration; subs have become a bit skimpy lately, especially for the price, and the taco salad is not recommended due to dried meat and minimal portions. The restaurant features a rubber duck claw machine inside, where customers can try their luck to win rubber duckies wearing cute knit hats, although recent modifications mean only one play per dollar is allowed, with no guarantee of winning. This change has upset many, as the machine used to be “Play Till You Win,” offering unlimited tries. Despite these issues, many customers still leave feeling happy and full, enjoying the good food and casual atmosphere, but the recent price increases and changes in the claw machine may make some think twice before returning.