Wings were very tasty. Pizza needs some work. The dough was great. Sauce and cheese reminded me of grade school pizza I wish there was a little more spices and flavor. Came through for us with the Bills game on Sunday night though!
Charlene Arva
Ordered A cheeseburger sub, a chicken Parm sub, and chicken wings. The cheeseburger sub had no cheese on it, the chicken Parmesan sub had about 2 tablespoons of sauce on it, ordered golden wings and got barbecue. All this after waiting an extra 35 minutes on top of the 30 minutes that they said it would be for my order. Very disappointed. I was Warned not to order from here I guess I should’ve listened
Justin Martin
call for a large pepperoni with extra cheese and an order of garlic knots was told he couldn't make the knots because he didn't have butter paid $23 for a large pizza the sauce is nasty there's not cheese on at least half the pizza paid extra for cheese barely got any cheese where's pizza place I've ever had
Owen F
If I could give it a zero I would, was there 4 of july weekend not many options for a good pie near watkins. Forgot the tall guys name what a a.. Hole we got they're at 8 rude is being nice told we close at 9 that's it. Ordered 2 pies worst ever only taste the cheese and I had misshapped slices worst time ever and can't stand conveyer belt pies.
Eric Groom
Took almost 45 min to make twp subs. Then I watched the young man go into the bathroom with his rubber gloves on amd come back out without changing his gloves. He then goes back to making food.
Robert Druker
Great pizza ! Love the staff !
Dawn Ameigh
Bacon pizza is amazing
VeronicaR645
Called and ordered medium pizza and an order of wings on a Sunday night from a local inn. 2 hours later receive a call back stating they didn’t have ingredients to make pizza. WTF. Now I have no recourse. It’s Sunday night. Can’t believe still in business F””Kers ?
RyAn Ermacor
The guy at the counter was miserable. Asked for a sub The sub unit was “down” not that it mattered because I wanted a hot sub (chicken parm) so not sure why it mattered that the unit was “down” . So I ordered 2 slices ,Told the guy thank you he looked at me then walked away . Oh yeah the slices were cold .
Jamie Oates
Will not ever order from here again called and placed order at 455pm told 45mins for delivery. food arrived at 630 after a call speaking to the manager and being hung up on!! tried to give this place another chance but they will not get my patronage ever again!!!!!! and just let me add that the food was ice cold when it did get here!
Used to love this place, but last few times it took way longer until Food was ready they said
Sam T
Very good pizza and wings. Huge wings very meaty, large pizza is very large!!
HBST65
Stayed at Plump Point over New Years. Wanted a local place to get pizza and wings. Very nice guy at the counter, may have been the owner. Very good pizza and huge wings!! Pizza was thin crust but not like the paper thin type. Still had a good amount of dough/crust and was a good tasting pie. BBQ wings were some of the largest I have had. Very meaty with no fat and excellent taste.
fun o
Ordered 3 slices with pepperoni. 2 were huge one was not. 2 had lots of cheese, 1 had hardly any and hardly any sauce. It seems OBVIOUS. How do you mess that up? It's pizza. Not impressed.
John Dhar
Very good pizza with great service. Ask for Tony, the manger. Enjoy a pie with toppings today ?
Wings were very tasty. Pizza needs some work. The dough was great. Sauce and cheese reminded me of grade school pizza I wish there was a little more spices and flavor. Came through for us with the Bills game on Sunday night though!
Ordered A cheeseburger sub, a chicken Parm sub, and chicken wings. The cheeseburger sub had no cheese on it, the chicken Parmesan sub had about 2 tablespoons of sauce on it, ordered golden wings and got barbecue. All this after waiting an extra 35 minutes on top of the 30 minutes that they said it would be for my order. Very disappointed. I was Warned not to order from here I guess I should’ve listened
call for a large pepperoni with extra cheese and an order of garlic knots was told he couldn't make the knots because he didn't have butter paid $23 for a large pizza the sauce is nasty there's not cheese on at least half the pizza paid extra for cheese barely got any cheese where's pizza place I've ever had
If I could give it a zero I would, was there 4 of july weekend not many options for a good pie near watkins. Forgot the tall guys name what a a.. Hole we got they're at 8 rude is being nice told we close at 9 that's it. Ordered 2 pies worst ever only taste the cheese and I had misshapped slices worst time ever and can't stand conveyer belt pies.
Took almost 45 min to make twp subs. Then I watched the young man go into the bathroom with his rubber gloves on amd come back out without changing his gloves. He then goes back to making food.
Great pizza ! Love the staff !
Bacon pizza is amazing
Called and ordered medium pizza and an order of wings on a Sunday night from a local inn. 2 hours later receive a call back stating they didn’t have ingredients to make pizza. WTF. Now I have no recourse. It’s Sunday night. Can’t believe still in business F””Kers ?
The guy at the counter was miserable. Asked for a sub The sub unit was “down” not that it mattered because I wanted a hot sub (chicken parm) so not sure why it mattered that the unit was “down” . So I ordered 2 slices ,Told the guy thank you he looked at me then walked away . Oh yeah the slices were cold .
Will not ever order from here again called and placed order at 455pm told 45mins for delivery. food arrived at 630 after a call speaking to the manager and being hung up on!! tried to give this place another chance but they will not get my patronage ever again!!!!!! and just let me add that the food was ice cold when it did get here!
Restaurantji Recommends
Used to love this place, but last few times it took way longer until Food was ready they said
Very good pizza and wings. Huge wings very meaty, large pizza is very large!!
Stayed at Plump Point over New Years. Wanted a local place to get pizza and wings. Very nice guy at the counter, may have been the owner. Very good pizza and huge wings!! Pizza was thin crust but not like the paper thin type. Still had a good amount of dough/crust and was a good tasting pie. BBQ wings were some of the largest I have had. Very meaty with no fat and excellent taste.
Ordered 3 slices with pepperoni. 2 were huge one was not. 2 had lots of cheese, 1 had hardly any and hardly any sauce. It seems OBVIOUS. How do you mess that up? It's pizza. Not impressed.
Very good pizza with great service. Ask for Tony, the manger. Enjoy a pie with toppings today ?
Loading...