Dining at 189 Burger was an absolute joy from start to finish! As soon as we walked in, the lovely hostess Mikayla greeted us with a warm smile and seated us right away. Almost instantly, we had refreshing glasses of water in front of us, followed closely by expertly crafted cocktails that set the mood just right. Our server, Maddie, was a true gem—always attentive and cheerful. She took our food orders the moment we felt ready, making the whole experience feel seamless and enjoyable. The food was delicious, my husband ordered the pot roast dip while I ordered the bourbon onion burger. It's safe to say we left with smiles on our faces!
Ann Marie Kurasz
Food was good but a bit sloppy to eat. Service was great. (Bree) Side patio is a bonus.
Jill
Visiting the area, and my fiancé recommended this place for us having been there once before and really enjoyed the salad he had then.
First impression: Rustic but charming, and popular — On a Monday evening around 7:30pm it was not crowded but the bar was full and a few tables too. Has a narrow space but there appeared to be an upstairs.
We were seated right away and all service individuals were friendly. We ordered 2 uniquely flavored cocktails, then shared an appetizer (Beef on Weck Egg Rolls) — this sauce was so delicious we kept it behind for the sandwich (Pot Roast Dip). Everything came out hot too.
If we stay in this area again, 189 Burger is definitely ⭐️ as a favorite restaurant.
Alexis Bowerman
The food was great it was a little too dark for me but overall it was great! My son broke a cup accidentally and they quickly took care of it. Im not super big on dark dining but the food makes it worth it.
karen martinke
Weird toppings and waited forever for waitress to take order, get water just basics. And too dark on a beautiful evening
Chris Aldrich
I really love this place. I went here for the first time and love the vibe, the decor and the food! The bourbon onion burger is spectacular 😋 great service (thanks Callie) too. So many good restaurants in East Aurora.... but I will be back here next time ;)
Riley Bauer
Adam and Anna are quite literally the best people on earth. this brother and sister duo make me feel like i just walked into a disney magical experience.
Sarah Pawig
Get. That. Bourbon. Onion. Burger. STAT.
Donna Bielecki
The burgers were to die for. Hubby had the Mushroom burger and found it amazing. I had the Steak Frites, and it also was fabulous. The fries are delish and not dry. My specialty cocktail Hypnotic Eye was marvelous. Serviced with 1 huge ice cube that didn't water down the drink. Can't wait to go back.
My favorite burger joint in the southtowns. Fantastic food and service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Zimmerman
I had the best burger of my LIFE at 189, thanks to Jay! The bourbon onion burger he crafted for me was truly a masterpiece. Even the fries were memorable: crisp and tasty. Their servers are extremely professional and courteous without being stiff--a rare combination indeed. I'm not a whiskey drinker, but their beer selection is very adequate. This is the place to eat in East Aurora.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Will Albers
Big fan of 189. Used to love it for their cocktails but now appreciate the burger. It's quite above the pack in EA.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Anna M.
The chipotle mayo burger was one of the best burgers I've had. So much flavor. I can't wait to show more people this place. * I went back again after 3 months and it was as amazing as the first time. Get a side of their blue cheese for the fries.. It's actual cheese, not the fake stuff. Amazing ambiance too and beyond cozy.
Dining at 189 Burger was an absolute joy from start to finish! As soon as we walked in, the lovely hostess Mikayla greeted us with a warm smile and seated us right away. Almost instantly, we had refreshing glasses of water in front of us, followed closely by expertly crafted cocktails that set the mood just right. Our server, Maddie, was a true gem—always attentive and cheerful. She took our food orders the moment we felt ready, making the whole experience feel seamless and enjoyable. The food was delicious, my husband ordered the pot roast dip while I ordered the bourbon onion burger. It's safe to say we left with smiles on our faces!
Food was good but a bit sloppy to eat. Service was great. (Bree)
Side patio is a bonus.
Visiting the area, and my fiancé recommended this place for us having been there once before and really enjoyed the salad he had then.
First impression: Rustic but charming, and popular — On a Monday evening around 7:30pm it was not crowded but the bar was full and a few tables too. Has a narrow space but there appeared to be an upstairs.
We were seated right away and all service individuals were friendly. We ordered 2 uniquely flavored cocktails, then shared an appetizer (Beef on Weck Egg Rolls) — this sauce was so delicious we kept it behind for the sandwich (Pot Roast Dip). Everything came out hot too.
If we stay in this area again, 189 Burger is definitely ⭐️ as a favorite restaurant.
The food was great it was a little too dark for me but overall it was great! My son broke a cup accidentally and they quickly took care of it. Im not super big on dark dining but the food makes it worth it.
Weird toppings and waited forever for waitress to take order, get water just basics. And too dark on a beautiful evening
I really love this place. I went here for the first time and love the vibe, the decor and the food! The bourbon onion burger is spectacular 😋 great service (thanks Callie) too. So many good restaurants in East Aurora.... but I will be back here next time ;)
Adam and Anna are quite literally the best people on earth. this brother and sister duo make me feel like i just walked into a disney magical experience.
Get. That. Bourbon. Onion. Burger. STAT.
The burgers were to die for. Hubby had the Mushroom burger and found it amazing. I had the Steak Frites, and it also was fabulous. The fries are delish and not dry. My specialty cocktail Hypnotic Eye was marvelous. Serviced with 1 huge ice cube that didn't water down the drink. Can't wait to go back.
Really great atmosphere and service
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great place to eat! Maddy provided great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: The 189 Burger
My favorite burger joint in the southtowns. Fantastic food and service
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I had the best burger of my LIFE at 189, thanks to Jay! The bourbon onion burger he crafted for me was truly a masterpiece. Even the fries were memorable: crisp and tasty. Their servers are extremely professional and courteous without being stiff--a rare combination indeed.
I'm not a whiskey drinker, but their beer selection is very adequate. This is the place to eat in East Aurora.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Big fan of 189. Used to love it for their cocktails but now appreciate the burger. It's quite above the pack in EA.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
The chipotle mayo burger was one of the best burgers I've had. So much flavor. I can't wait to show more people this place. * I went back again after 3 months and it was as amazing as the first time. Get a side of their blue cheese for the fries.. It's actual cheese, not the fake stuff. Amazing ambiance too and beyond cozy.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Onion Soup
Loading...