Owners are absolutely the nicest people ever! The quality of food is AMAZING! We bought a broccoli chicken pot pie to cook at home and it’s hands down the best pot pie I’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Duane Shute
I enjoyed the pot brownies, I was so stoned, I didn't have to smoke no weed the rest of the day, thanks Mr. Pot.
Nic D
Good but expensive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Ginny Pendleton
The staff is always friendly and the pies are mouthwatering, delicious and filling ? Our favorite is chicken cheddar broccoli ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carl Sperrazza
The food is Superior !! LOVED the cucidatti ring I tried out around Christmas. Their pot pies are tremendous!
Parking: Busy place and you have to arrive at the right time or no parking spot for you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Baumgartner
When looking for Shephards pie ,or a chicken pot pie you will find the best here to take home to cook.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
A Laskowski
There was not a huge variety of pot pies when I went. I also went later in the day. Pies are a little pricy but extremely tasty. I'll definitely be trying other varieties.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Oldskool Pautz
Bought frozen chicken pot pie!! LUK when cooked!!
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 4
Sarah Spencer
This place is a hidden gem. 1st time there today, but it won't be my last. Had the Chicken Marsala soup, it was amazing!!!
Heard this place was good from my co workers so I went for the first time and bought 2 of these pies, and all I can say is.. WOW!!! So creamy, lots of turkey and so much flavor!! My husband and I were very impressed.. we will definitely be a reg customer for sure!!
cgw67-68
I reveled in the sidewalk sale on reunion weekend Saturday in the very hip East Aurora NY. Had already checked out a sample of Fowler's chocolate walnut fudge moments before and walked in not realizing Mr. Pot Pie also served fudge. Truth be told, their version was a tad more scrumptious than the confectioner right down the street that hangs its hat on the supremacy of their sweet nothings. My only regret is that this place was not open on Sundays, as my plan was to return the next morning before heading home to purchase the frozen pot pie (I was aiming to take home the seafood pot pie): everyone I spoke with during reunion weekend said their pot pies are THE BEST. Nuts; was really set on bringing home one of these dense, 2.25 pound behemoths. I DID appreciate the extra half pound of the fudge, which was generously added to my 1 pound order simply because I happened to mention I thought theirs was better than Fowler's. How very, very sweet of them (no pun intended).
Amanda D
We normally go in for their short bread, it's to die for. They recently started offering fudge which is very good too. I love their macaroni and cheese to have in my freezer for a quick dinner. Their pot pies from what I hear from family are delicious (I am biased as I don't like pot pie). I highly recommend giving them a try!
Owners are absolutely the nicest people ever! The quality of food is AMAZING! We bought a broccoli chicken pot pie to cook at home and it’s hands down the best pot pie I’ve ever had!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I enjoyed the pot brownies, I was so stoned, I didn't have to smoke no weed the rest of the day, thanks Mr. Pot.
Good but expensive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
The staff is always friendly and the pies are mouthwatering, delicious and filling ? Our favorite is chicken cheddar broccoli ❤️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food is Superior !! LOVED the cucidatti ring I tried out around Christmas. Their pot pies are tremendous!
Parking: Busy place and you have to arrive at the right time or no parking spot for you
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
When looking for Shephards pie ,or a chicken pot pie you will find the best here to take home to cook.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
There was not a huge variety of pot pies when I went. I also went later in the day. Pies are a little pricy but extremely tasty. I'll definitely be trying other varieties.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Bought frozen chicken pot pie!! LUK when cooked!!
Atmosphere: 3
Service: 4
This place is a hidden gem. 1st time there today, but it won't be my last. Had the Chicken Marsala soup, it was amazing!!!
Always wonderful...products and staff!
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pot pies, soups and baked goods
Heard this place was good from my co workers so I went for the first time and bought 2 of these pies, and all I can say is.. WOW!!! So creamy, lots of turkey and so much flavor!! My husband and I were very impressed.. we will definitely be a reg customer for sure!!
I reveled in the sidewalk sale on reunion weekend Saturday in the very hip East Aurora NY. Had already checked out a sample of Fowler's chocolate walnut fudge moments before and walked in not realizing Mr. Pot Pie also served fudge. Truth be told, their version was a tad more scrumptious than the confectioner right down the street that hangs its hat on the supremacy of their sweet nothings. My only regret is that this place was not open on Sundays, as my plan was to return the next morning before heading home to purchase the frozen pot pie (I was aiming to take home the seafood pot pie): everyone I spoke with during reunion weekend said their pot pies are THE BEST. Nuts; was really set on bringing home one of these dense, 2.25 pound behemoths. I DID appreciate the extra half pound of the fudge, which was generously added to my 1 pound order simply because I happened to mention I thought theirs was better than Fowler's. How very, very sweet of them (no pun intended).
We normally go in for their short bread, it's to die for. They recently started offering fudge which is very good too. I love their macaroni and cheese to have in my freezer for a quick dinner. Their pot pies from what I hear from family are delicious (I am biased as I don't like pot pie). I highly recommend giving them a try!
Always a pleasure
Loading...