Buttermilk's Chicken

93 E Main St, East Islip
(631) 581-3000

Recent Reviews Order Online

Customers' Favorites

French Fries and Fried Chicken
Buff-A-Leu Chicken Sandwich
Kickin Chicken Sandwich
Sriracha Honey Sauce
Fried Chicken Salad
Just Tenders 12pc
Kids Drumsticks
Kickin' Chicken
Half Chicken
Kids Tenders

Menu

Sandwiches

Crispy Classic Sandwich
crispy chicken, dill pickle chips, sassy sauce
Crispy Classic Deluxe Sandwich
crispy chicken, dill pickle chips, sassy sauce, american cheese, lettuce
Buff-A-Leu Sandwich
crispy chicken, spicy sweet buffalo sauce, topped with bleu cheese
Hey Honey Sandwich
crispy chicken, honey dijon sauce, lettuce, tomato
Peppercorn Sandwich
grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, tomato, lettuce, parmesan peppercorn sauce
Country Club Sandwich
grilled chicken, cherrywood smoked bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayonnaise
Kickin Chicken Sandwich
crispy chicken, sriracha honey, lettuce, tomato, drizzled with buttermilk ranch
Roadhouse Sandwich
crispy chicken, cheddar, smokey bacon, crispy onion ring, bbq sauce
Farmhouse Sandwich
crispy chicken, cherrywood smoked bacon, cheddar, topped with buttermilk ranch

Crispy Tenders
Crispy Tenders Combo
Just Tenders

Just Chicken

Just Chicken

Combos

Dark Combo, 2pc
Thigh and Drumstick
Half Chicken Combo
4pcs - Breast, Wing, Leg, Thigh
White Combo, 2pc
Breast and Wing

Salads

Garden Salad
toasted croutons, tomatoes, cukes, carrots, red onion, black olives
Caesar Salad
asiago & parmesan cheese, toasted croutons and creamy caesar
Country Cobb Salad
grilled chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg, tomato, danish bleu, dried cranberries
Mediterranean Salad
feta, tomato, cukes, red onions, pepperoncini, kalamata olives, house vinaigrette
Baja Salad
Grilled chicken, red onion, black olives, cheddar, sour cream, tomatoes and black beans.

Chicken Salad

Classic Chicken Salad
mayonnaise, celery, seasonings & dijon
Creamy Cobb Chicken Salad
hard boiled eggs, bacon, tomatoes & crumbled bleu
Rancher Chicken Salad
bacon, buttermilk ranch & cheddar
Waldorf Chicken Salad
apples, cranberries & glazed walnuts
BLT Chicken Salad
bacon, lettuce & tomato

Jumbo Fried Shrimp
Golden Shrimp 5pc
served with fries, lemon wedge, tarter or cocktail and cornbread
Sweet Heat Shrimp 5pc
drizzled with our sweet chili sauce, served with fries, lemon wedge and cornbread
Half Dozen Shrimp
served with lemon wedge, tarter, cocktail or sweet chili sauce

Dinner

Peck Dinner
8 pcs, 2 regular sides, 4 cornbread
Gobble Family Style
12 pcs, 2 large sides, cornbread
Feast Dinner
16pc, 3 large sides, 8 cornbread

Lil'Peeps

Kids Drumsticks
Kids Crispy Tenders
Kids Shrimp

On the Side

French Fries
Whipped Potatoes
Battered Onion Rings
Mac & Cheese
Buttery Corn
Creamy Coleslaw
Country Gravy
Corn Bread

Photos

Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
Photo credit: google
+54 photos
Photo credit: nextdoor
+53 photos
Add a photo

Recent Reviews

Really happy to discover this little gem! Fresh made sandwiches with homemade sauces that absolutely hit the spot. The service was friendly and the food came out quickly despite being made to order. The atmosphere was cuter and more comfortable than your average chicken shop too. We both only got the Crispy classic sandwich but were very pleasantly surprised and will be back to try more menu items, especially the tendies.
July 2025
I rate the chicken tenders a 6/10

Now the portion is BIG which is the good part, I like that bread comes with the entire meal and a hefty amount of everything, the service is great and so is the area it’s very quiet but it’s very nice aesthetically.

But here’s the issue:

The chicken comes dry and it’s easy to bite in which is good but it also doesn’t have seasoning and the tenders come in sometimes like chicken...
June 2025
It was good hot chicken , fresh out of the fryer chicken. The service here was awesome. The girl at the counter was friendly and kind. The atmosphere was nice and quiet. A very super clean place. I love it anyone should come and definitely try their jalapeño poppers they are great. They are filled with cheese inside. I give this place a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ if they had cheese fries but atleast the poppers made up for it.. service 5 ⭐️ for sure..
May 2025

More Reviews

You May Also Like

Subway - 67 E Main St
Sandwich Shop, Fast Food
Friendly's - 50 Montauk Hwy
American, Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt, Burgers
Stuff-A-Bagel - 24 E Main St
Bagels, Bakery

Buttermilk's Chicken

93 E Main St, East Islip, NY 11730
(631) 581-3000