Stanley's Bakery
68 E Main St, East Islip
(631) 581-1230
Customers' Favorites
Yellow Vanilla Cake with Strawberry Preserves and Whipped Frosting
Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Mousse and Buttercream Frosting
Mini Pastries Including Cream Puffs
Cannoli Birthday Cake
Cannoli Cream Puff
Pregnant Cannolis
Strawberry Pie
Hamburger Cake
Wedding Cake
Mousse Tarts
Stanley's Most Popular Items
Almond Horn
Italian Bread
Pretzel Roll
Poppy Seeded Hard Roll
Apple Pie
Crumb Bun
Apple Turnover
Black + White Cookie
Blackout Layer Cake
3 layers of chocolate cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge
Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Fudge
3 layers of yellow cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge
Mocha Layer Cake
3 layers of yellow cake with mocha buttercream filling and icing, with chocolate sprinkles around the outside
Cinnamon Jelly Donut
Unseeded Hard Roll
Chocolate Flakey Pastry
Raspberry Flakey Pastry
Raspberry Crumb
Large piece of crumb cake filled with raspberry
Apple Crumb Pie
Cheesecake
Creamy New York Style cheesecake
7 Layer Cake
7 layers of yellow cake with chocolate buttercream and hard chocolate icing
Rainbow Cookie Cake
Traditional rainbow cookie in a cake, iced in chocolate fudge
Rainbow Cookie Tray - 1 lb
Rainbow Cookie Tray - 2 lb
Chocolate Boston Cream
Apple Fritter
Donuts
Cinnamon Jelly Donut
Powdered Jelly
Crumb Bun
Cinnamon Swirl
Apple Turnover
Vanilla Donut
Chocolate Donut
French Cruller
Powdered Cruller
w/ powdered sugar
Cruller
With cinnamon sugar
Glazed Donut
Apple Crumb Turnover
Blueberry Crumb Turnover
Cherry Turnover
Cheese Danish
Cheese Crumb Turnover
Pecan Danish
Black + White Cookie
Tea Biscuit
Chocolate Boston Cream
Vanilla Boston Cream
Apple Fritter
Apple Crumb Turnover
Egg Sandwiches
Bacon, Egg & Cheese Sandwich (2 eggs)
Sausage, Egg & Cheese Sandwich (2 eggs)
Bacon & Egg Sandwich (2 eggs)
Sausage & Egg Sandwich (2 eggs)
Egg Sandwich (2 eggs)
Egg & Cheese Sandwich (2 eggs)
Turkey, Egg & Cheese Sandwich (2 eggs)
Turkey & Egg Sandwich (2 eggs)
Homefries
A side of homefries served in a platter.
Coffee/Tea
Small Coffee
Medium Coffee
Large Coffee
Small Tea
Medium Tea
Large Tea
Pastries
Mini Cannoli
Large Cannoli
Large Custard Éclair
Fudge Brownie w/ Nuts
Cannoli St. Joseph Pastry
Topped with powdered sugar and a cherry.
Custard St. Joseph Pastry
Topped with powdered sugar and chocolate shavings.
Rainbow Cookie Crumb
A large piece of our famous rainbow cookie, but with crumbs!
Almond Horn
Large Napoleon
Cake Brownie
No Nuts
Linzer Tart
Chocolate Flakey Pastry
Raspberry Flakey Pastry
Raspberry Crumb
Large piece of crumb cake filled with raspberry
Blueberry & Cheese Bearclaw
A pastry dough filled with blueberry and cheese and topped with powdered sugar.
Cherry & Cheese Bearclaw
A pastry dough filled with cherry and cheese and topped with powdered sugar.
Crumb Cake Square
Crumb cake square that serves approximately 6 people.
Apple Horn
A pastry dough filled with apples and topped with Stanley's famous crumbs and powdered sugar.
Bread
Sourdough Bread
Italian Bread
French Bread
Onion Rye Bread
Challah Bread
Great for French toast!
Pretzel Roll
Poppy Seeded Hard Roll
Unseeded Hard Roll
Large Seeded Rye Bread
Large Unseeded Rye Bread
Small Seeded Rye Bread
Small Unseeded Rye Bread
Croissants
Sesame Seeded Hard Roll
Buttered Roll
Pies
Apple Pie
Blueberry Lattice Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Blueberry Yogurt Cake
A moist coffee cake with blueberries throughout, topped with crumbs.
Apple Crumb Pie
Blueberry Crumb Pie
Cherry Lattice Pie
Key Lime Pie
Broccoli and Cheddar Cheese Quiche
Ham and Swiss Cheese Quiche
Spinach, Bacon, Mushroom Quiche
Cookies
Black + White Cookie
Large Nonpareil Sprinkle Cookie
Large Marble Half Dipped Cookie
Large Sprinkle Cookie
Large Chocolate Chip Cookie
Rainbow Cookie Tray - 1 lb
Rainbow Cookie Tray - 2 lb
Assorted Butter Cookies - 2 lb Tray
Wrapped tray
Assorted Butter Cookies - 3 lb Tray
Wrapped tray
Cakes
Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Mousse
3 layers of rich chocolate cake filled with chocolate mousse and topped with chocolate ganache and chocolate shavings.
Cannoli Layer Cake
3 layers of vanilla cake with creamy cannoli filling, with a touch of buttercream on the top and on the sides. Includes nuts.
Blackout Layer Cake
3 layers of chocolate cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge
Vanilla Cake with Chocolate Fudge
3 layers of yellow cake filled and iced with chocolate fudge
Mocha Layer Cake
3 layers of yellow cake with mocha buttercream filling and icing, with chocolate sprinkles around the outside
Oreo Cheesecake
Creamy New York Style cheesecake with pieces of Oreo inside
Strawberry Shortcake
Yellow Cake with whipped cream and strawberry preserve with fresh strawberries on top
Round Carrot Cake
One layer of carrot cake with creamy cream cheese icing
Strawberry Boston Cake
Yellow Cake with Custard Filling topped with chocolate ganache
Maple Walnut Layer Cake
3 layers of yellow cake with maple walnut filling and icing, with walnuts around the outside
Oreo Layer Cake
3 layers of chocolate cake with an Oreo buttercream filling, iced in vanilla buttercream
Chocolate Cake w/ Vanilla Buttercream
3 layers of chocolate cake filled iced in vanilla buttercream
Chocolate Cake w/ Chocolate Buttercream
3 layers of chocolate cake filled and iced in chocolate buttercream with chocolate sprinkles on the outside
Cheesecake
Creamy New York Style cheesecake
Marble Cheesecake
Creamy New York Style cheesecake with chocolate swirled throughout
Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
Creamy New York Style cheesecake with chocolate chips inside
7 Layer Cake
7 layers of yellow cake with chocolate buttercream and hard chocolate icing
Rainbow Cookie Cake
Traditional rainbow cookie in a cake, iced in chocolate fudge
Iced Layer Cake
Yellow cake with vanilla buttercream and hard chocolate icing
Marble Turk Cake
Marble cake iced with chocolate icing and half vanilla icing
Raspberry French Nut Cake
Nut loaf cake layered with raspberry and powdered sugar
1/2 Layer Cake
Chocolate cake with raspberry and hard chocolate icing
Photos
+97 photos
+96 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
We come to Stanley bakery because people suggested it. We went and the 2 young girls working behind the counter on Saturday afternoon were more interested in talk to each other and couldn't be bothered to ask us if we needed help. When one of them was waiting on us they still carried on their conversation. Very poor customer service. We got the rainbow cookies that were not that good as well as a small lobster tail with cannoli cream that was too sweet and threw it away....
January 2026
The last three years I have ordered over 1000 cannolis and pastries for my customers… And they love it each year… This year I bought a chocolate mousse cake for myself that is by far the best cake I ever tasted… If you like chocolate/chocolate mousse… This is an absolute must…
December 2025
I come here everyday Tuesday for breakfast. Honestly the best bacon egg and cheese on Long Island. I would definitely recommend getting it on their homemade rolls. We also recently got a cake for a party and everyone agreed it was one of the best they have ever had. Definitely getting all my cakes here from now on.
December 2025