Small quite place ... Plenty of parking.. prices are reasonable.
Gerry Colucci
My favorite pizzeria. The best one I’ve ever had in all of NYC and Long Island in terms of service and quality. And that’s coming from a carbophile that lives in the city and grew up in Long Island, so it’s fair to say this opinion comes from quite a large sample
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Kiggins
New guy Joe is really good. Quick efficient tasty and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Roseanne Beovich
Great service and great food! Had 3 parties catered by Gino’s and Timmy was fantastic. He followed up with me before each party and made sure everything was perfect. All the guests complimented the food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Eddie Torre
Best pizza I've had in a while.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Nathan
Mini buffalo roll dipped in buffalo sauce was incredible, buffalo slice had a great portion of chicken but was a little dry/not much heat/spice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Fuzzy K.
4.5 stars...I've gone to Gino's fairly regularly since they opened and I live in the area. I've gotten take out as well as dined in. The food is very good, just a few disappointments. When having dinner in, they have a salad with their entrees that has lots of mushrooms (I'm not a big mushroom person)...so the second time I made sure to order the salad without mushrooms and it still came with so I had to pick out the multitude of mushrooms. Kind of annoying and will probably not get salads anymore but as far as the other meals, from the pizza to the wraps, to the entrees etc, everything was very good. Their balsamic chicken, in wraps as well as entree dinners, is awesome. The interior is very nice and cozy and an improvement from the previous restaurant there. The waiters and staff are always very accommodating. The prices are on the high side but sadly, where aren't the prices on the high side now? But I'd rather pay more for quality food and service rather than save a few dollars for food that is not as good.
John M.
I was very disappointed in the amount of cheese on the chicken parmigiana. It was like a few thin slices. Not acceptable for a New York restaurant. It came with a salad which was not served. They actually forgot to bring two salads to the table. Then, after we asked they brought one with onions which was ordered without onions. However, the waitress was very nice and apologetic. I will go back because their food is usually very good. Inconsistent and unauthentic Italian food is not acceptable.
janice dannebaum
Pricey.. umbertos is good also and much cheaper
Seth Michael St. Giles
My job takes me from Manhattan to the Hamptons and this is consistently one of the very best Italian Pizzeria experiences on Long Island; not just for the food which is top-notch but also for the always friendly service.
Although it's a little bit of a drive, this has become my go-to for pizza and Italian. Not a cheap pizza and restaurant, but in line with everyone else unfortunately. Great salads, solid entrees, terrific pizza. I eat gluten free and I think their prep of personal gf pies are the best around and I've tried a lot. Totally recommend. I agree that when they first opened things were a little clunky but that's long past, and those reviews are old. My experience says ignore. This is a great place. Solid service and the managers are very customer focused, friendly. At the top of their game right now.
mary austin
First time there. Was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Vulkaya A
Food was good. Service was mediocre. Waiter disappeared and never checked up on us, claiming he was busy with a catering order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Cesar Jara
Best pizza I’ve had in a while, very nice and polite service ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Keith Tamayo
Great addition to the neighborhood. Huge selection of specialty pies and everything is great. Entrees are excellent as well!
Small quite place ... Plenty of parking.. prices are reasonable.
My favorite pizzeria. The best one I’ve ever had in all of NYC and Long Island in terms of service and quality. And that’s coming from a carbophile that lives in the city and grew up in Long Island, so it’s fair to say this opinion comes from quite a large sample
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
New guy Joe is really good. Quick efficient tasty and
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great service and great food! Had 3 parties catered by Gino’s and Timmy was fantastic. He followed up with me before each party and made sure everything was perfect. All the guests complimented the food!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza I've had in a while.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mini buffalo roll dipped in buffalo sauce was incredible, buffalo slice had a great portion of chicken but was a little dry/not much heat/spice.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
4.5 stars...I've gone to Gino's fairly regularly since they opened and I live in the area. I've gotten take out as well as dined in. The food is very good, just a few disappointments. When having dinner in, they have a salad with their entrees that has lots of mushrooms (I'm not a big mushroom person)...so the second time I made sure to order the salad without mushrooms and it still came with so I had to pick out the multitude of mushrooms. Kind of annoying and will probably not get salads anymore but as far as the other meals, from the pizza to the wraps, to the entrees etc, everything was very good. Their balsamic chicken, in wraps as well as entree dinners, is awesome. The interior is very nice and cozy and an improvement from the previous restaurant there. The waiters and staff are always very accommodating. The prices are on the high side but sadly, where aren't the prices on the high side now? But I'd rather pay more for quality food and service rather than save a few dollars for food that is not as good.
I was very disappointed in the amount of cheese on the chicken parmigiana. It was like a few thin slices. Not acceptable for a New York restaurant. It came with a salad which was not served. They actually forgot to bring two salads to the table. Then, after we asked they brought one with onions which was ordered without onions. However, the waitress was very nice and apologetic. I will go back because their food is usually very good. Inconsistent and unauthentic Italian food is not acceptable.
Pricey.. umbertos is good also and much cheaper
My job takes me from Manhattan to the Hamptons and this is consistently one of the very best Italian Pizzeria experiences on Long Island; not just for the food which is top-notch but also for the always friendly service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Although it's a little bit of a drive, this has become my go-to for pizza and Italian. Not a cheap pizza and restaurant, but in line with everyone else unfortunately. Great salads, solid entrees, terrific pizza. I eat gluten free and I think their prep of personal gf pies are the best around and I've tried a lot. Totally recommend. I agree that when they first opened things were a little clunky but that's long past, and those reviews are old. My experience says ignore. This is a great place. Solid service and the managers are very customer focused, friendly. At the top of their game right now.
First time there. Was
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Food was good. Service was mediocre. Waiter disappeared and never checked up on us, claiming he was busy with a catering order.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Best pizza I’ve had in a while, very nice and polite service ??
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great addition to the neighborhood. Huge selection of specialty pies and everything is great. Entrees are excellent as well!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5