Sunday Brunch is my favorite time to come here. It is well worth the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Fountain
Cindy Romero
The atmosphere was incredible. The service was top notch, our server was Will and he was incredibly helpful. The lobster bisque was 5/5, the skirt steak was delicious but the sides were very bland.My biggest gripe was them not having a bathroom with a baby changing table. It’s 2024, families go out to dinner and having a changing table or a family bathroom should be a no brainer. That was a disappointment and an inconvenience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Skirt Steak
M J L
As a steak enthusiast, I had high expectations, and Rothmann's exceeded them in every way. The menu boasts a mouthwatering selection of prime cuts, ranging from tender filet mignon to robust ribeye, each expertly aged and cooked to perfection!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Delgardo
First time here! After all my life living on the Island. Such a sheltered life I lead! It was fantastic, everything was fresh! And for restaurants on Long island during the Winter that's rare. Rothmanns did not disappoint me at all. Highly recommend! Old school charm on the inside! Staff polite and professional all the way above and beyond! Thank you for a wonderful first time experience! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Shell Oysters Lobster Roll and Wedge Salad, Clams, Skirt Steak
Larry Durban
Delightful dining!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service is always pleasurable and they have great personalities Bartenders are the Best..super friendly and great drinks From land to sea food is always on point and will always accommodate Rothmans is a clean -friendly-casual but neat attire Restaurant ?????
BruceH
One steak was smaller than advertised and had to be replaced. The other steak was requested not to have any marinade or spices on it it came with salt on it. Appetizer of baked clams, they were so small they should be embarrassed in serving them.
Justin M
I love Rothmann's, the food is always good. I've seen them overcook a steak (not mine) maybe 2x, but it was quickly resolved with appropriate action. Great cocktails and wine list too!
Our server William was a gem and did an amazing job. The food was delicious and was cooked to perfection. My whole family went to celebrate accomplishments and birthdays and we enjoyed everything. Everyone was very welcoming and friendly! Zero complains and highly recommend. 10000% recommend the Wagyu Porterhouse! DELICIOUS!
Service was great as always! Very accommodating, and kind. Food is always delicious! Definitely recommend the tomahawk for 2! It was amazing! Always happy and get exactly what I pay!
Tomahawk was dry and had a lot of fat. Seafood was not that fresh. Service is good except for a guy. Whatever we asked for it, he just threw it on the table.
I had a 6PM reservation and was seated immediately. The table we were seated at was very drafty and cold. My wife had to wear her coat during the entire meal! Steak was good, but not great. We've had better!
Edras Hidalgo
With co-workers we chose Monday since suppose to be quiet but still little busyIf I start from appetizers I will said octopus and Mac and cheese were so goodI am not fans and how they do the applewood bacon but is ok . They have a very diverse half bottle of wine. Porter house that we chose was very outstanding with Coked flavor and right on expectations.For some reason they didn’t have creamy spinach what’s make the week point .Alternative we request grill mushrooms and for my taste over cooked or over seasoned.(I respect their style )I end the night with a Crème Brùlèe dessert , flavor was so good , well caramelizadle but the texture little liquid in mine non professional opinionPlace has not atmosphere (owners or manager don’t show their face )Good steak house and great drinks
Ann Cappello
Husband and I dinner out for a quiet night but not. We were seated in the back room where there were families celebrating with kids, pretty loud which is fine for them but not us. Cut our dinner short and had coffee and dessert at home, too noisy!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Clams, Lobster
Stacy
Ended up here on a whim & was pleasantly surprised. Everything was amazing. The ambiance & overall look of the restaurant was lovely and the food was even better. Our waiter was great & the bus boy Juan was singing while he cleared our plates. You could tell this was a happy environment for both staff & patrons. Will 10000% be going back asap.
Sunday Brunch is my favorite time to come here. It is well worth the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Chocolate Fountain
The atmosphere was incredible. The service was top notch, our server was Will and he was incredibly helpful. The lobster bisque was 5/5, the skirt steak was delicious but the sides were very bland.My biggest gripe was them not having a bathroom with a baby changing table. It’s 2024, families go out to dinner and having a changing table or a family bathroom should be a no brainer. That was a disappointment and an inconvenience.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mashed Potatoes, Skirt Steak
As a steak enthusiast, I had high expectations, and Rothmann's exceeded them in every way. The menu boasts a mouthwatering selection of prime cuts, ranging from tender filet mignon to robust ribeye, each expertly aged and cooked to perfection!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
First time here! After all my life living on the Island. Such a sheltered life I lead! It was fantastic, everything was fresh! And for restaurants on Long island during the Winter that's rare. Rothmanns did not disappoint me at all. Highly recommend! Old school charm on the inside! Staff polite and professional all the way above and beyond! Thank you for a wonderful first time experience! I'll be back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Half Shell Oysters Lobster Roll and Wedge Salad, Clams, Skirt Steak
Delightful dining!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Service is always pleasurable and they have great personalities Bartenders are the Best..super friendly and great drinks From land to sea food is always on point and will always accommodate Rothmans is a clean -friendly-casual but neat attire Restaurant ?????
One steak was smaller than advertised and had to be replaced. The other steak was requested not to have any marinade or spices on it it came with salt on it. Appetizer of baked clams, they were so small they should be embarrassed in serving them.
I love Rothmann's, the food is always good. I've seen them overcook a steak (not mine) maybe 2x, but it was quickly resolved with appropriate action. Great cocktails and wine list too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Rib Steak 18oz, Baked Clams, Mozzarella Tower, Tomahawk Rib for Two, Applewood Smoked Slab Bacon
Our server William was a gem and did an amazing job. The food was delicious and was cooked to perfection. My whole family went to celebrate accomplishments and birthdays and we enjoyed everything. Everyone was very welcoming and friendly! Zero complains and highly recommend. 10000% recommend the Wagyu Porterhouse! DELICIOUS!
Service was great as always! Very accommodating, and kind. Food is always delicious! Definitely recommend the tomahawk for 2! It was amazing! Always happy and get exactly what I pay!
Restaurantji Recommends
Tomahawk was dry and had a lot of fat. Seafood was not that fresh. Service is good except for a guy. Whatever we asked for it, he just threw it on the table.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Tomahawk Rib for Two, Applewood Smoked Slab Bacon, Seafood Plateau
I had a 6PM reservation and was seated immediately. The table we were seated at was very drafty and cold. My wife had to wear her coat during the entire meal! Steak was good, but not great. We've had better!
With co-workers we chose Monday since suppose to be quiet but still little busyIf I start from appetizers I will said octopus and Mac and cheese were so goodI am not fans and how they do the applewood bacon but is ok . They have a very diverse half bottle of wine. Porter house that we chose was very outstanding with Coked flavor and right on expectations.For some reason they didn’t have creamy spinach what’s make the week point .Alternative we request grill mushrooms and for my taste over cooked or over seasoned.(I respect their style )I end the night with a Crème Brùlèe dessert , flavor was so good , well caramelizadle but the texture little liquid in mine non professional opinionPlace has not atmosphere (owners or manager don’t show their face )Good steak house and great drinks
Husband and I dinner out for a quiet night but not. We were seated in the back room where there were families celebrating with kids, pretty loud which is fine for them but not us. Cut our dinner short and had coffee and dessert at home, too noisy!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Clams, Lobster
Ended up here on a whim & was pleasantly surprised. Everything was amazing. The ambiance & overall look of the restaurant was lovely and the food was even better. Our waiter was great & the bus boy Juan was singing while he cleared our plates. You could tell this was a happy environment for both staff & patrons. Will 10000% be going back asap.