Mitch's General Store

9005 E Otto Springville Rd, East Otto
(716) 257-3344

Recent Reviews

Anita Williams

This is the only store in town. I would give it 4 stars but he doesn’t accept cards and the ATM machine is a hit or miss. It’s 2023, everyone accepts cards. I wish they would open another store in town. Someplace more updated.

victoria germanovich

Hands best little country store!!!And Mitch’s tacos are amazing, call and order to make sure he has the meat!!!!

tammy lagowski

Guy was super friendly and full-on laughs. Super sweet guy. Prices not too bad. Worth the look around. A little bit of everything.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

karen Markiewicz

Absolutely my favorite so delicious and excellent service ?

Warren Joseph

Best tacos around. Drove an hour just for them. He's is a great guy that loves to joke around while you wait for your food. Please give Mitch's a try you won't regret it been going to their store since I was a kid.

Lar Bear

Cool Small Town place country store with a little bit of everything good food

Joseph K.

Small general store in a small town. Not a lot of options but Mitch's does not disappoint. Good subs, tacos and good pizza. Friendly service and everything made to order. I don't go through often but have been stopping by when I get a chance, for years.

Honky Tonk Guy

Wanted to buy some beer, no credit card machine so had to pay an ATM fee to buy. Just a tiny little store where there isn't much else around.

Jillian Mitchell

Mitch is such a character. There's no way to not enjoy your stop. I especially suggest the pizza and subs!

Cyle Stoczynski

Wanted to buy some beer, no credit card machine so had to pay an ATM fee to buy. Just a tiny little store where there isn't much else around.

Anthony C

Best place around to get tacos. If you stop in try a Mitch’s!

Jon H.

Mitch is quite a colorful ambassador for this tiny town. Don't let the look of this tiny general store Hide the fact that matches pizza and subs are amazing. Everything's fresh to order by Mitch. His pizza is closer to a Chicago style than thin crust and its delicious

Forever Nightengale

Mitch is such a character. There's no way to not enjoy your stop. I especially suggest the pizza and subs!

Ken JP Stuczynski

My favorite pizza is made here. It's a welcomed stop for provisions and snack when travelling about Otto and Little Valley.

Debbie Smith

Best ? in the area.Travel a little to find Mitch's but it will be worth it ! After you dine,maybe Mary's Trash & Treasure store across from Mitch's will be open.

Load More