Andy's Pizza

4434 Ford Rd, Elba
(585) 757-6699

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Greg Brennan

Until Dan is fired, I want my family to never order from this place again

jennifer curtis

Ordered 4 small subs and a $8 chicken and fry combo and it was $38...the subs were really tasty too. A little messy, but tasty!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Holly Rosendale

Way to expensive & so not worth it. Pizza was under cooked, very small amount of sauce, very small amount of cheese & little amount of toppings. Pizza was super thin. Wings were small & definitely not hot like I asked. I am sorry but I won't be ordering here again. The front area is also very dirty & not pleasant to look at. Cob webs every where just gross.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 2

Gina Brege

We order from Andy's for years on a regular basis weekly to biweekly. Last night the delivery was 1/2 hr late. Tonight we were told 1 hr for 2 subs with an order of fries and waited 2 hrs. before they delivered. This is just unacceptable.Our subs were barely warm and the fries were cold. We are saddened by the change in this pizzeria.

Food: 3

Service: 1

Robert Spenton

Was very good. When you ask them to make the wings extra crispy , they actually listen

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Ewert

Great pizza and always great service

Tierance Davis

Hometown

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Delgado

Great wings close to home

Matthew Boyce

Best. Pizza. Ever.

Erika Fernandez

Best fresh made pizza here..from childhood weekend dine in to teen would I enjoy family time..stop by..you won't regret

Dan Shuler

Bought a turkey sub. It was a joke. Would not go back

Bob Wirth

Pizza was delicious and so were the wings. Staff was polite when getting the order. We will be going back again !!! Thanks Andy's pizza you rock. !!!!!

Ryan Wisniewski

Had to wait forever to get served ?

melissa shanley

Best steak sub I have ever had

Eric Hering

One of the small town jewels you don't know exists until you talk to locals, great pizza and wings!

Loading...