Custom Cakes near Elma, NY

“I was first introduced to this bakery's cookies at a fundraiser for Ten Lives Club, and both the design and the quality of the cutout cookies were fantastic! I love that they are involved in charity work for some really worthwhile organizations, so I'm happy to support that, and enjoy some delicious baked goods in the process! I recently placed my first order and sadly, I have no photos to share, but the presentation was very nicely done, with all of the cookies' ingredients and allergens very clearly marked. There was a large variety of flavors to chose from, and I'm excited to try cupcakes next! And finally, the owner's communication skills are excellent, she's very responsive and super friendly. Highly recommended!“

“Went to EA today for a walk at Knox Farm State Park, then had a very enjoyable lunch with my two neighbors from Hamburg. It was a beautiful and warm day, so we ate on the rooftop - casual and pretty with patio umbrellas and lots of flowers. Our server was so friendly and attentive. We all enjoyed our delicious sandwiches, and the bakery items are amazing. Highly recommend this very nice restaurant and bakery!“

“Very good cupcakes. Stopped in the store bought 6 my wife and I love them! Highly recommend“

“Ordered an ice cream cake for Easter. It was delicious!!!“

“Wheatberry made my daughter's wedding cakes. An individual cake for every table at the reception. They were absolutely gorgeous, perfect in every way!! The taste was phenomenal, one of the best tasting cakes ever. The guests were raving about them, numerous times I was asked what bakery made them, with pride I answered "Wheatberry" on Harlem Rd. 😁 Thank you so much for making the day even better!!“

“The old fashioned cupcakes have been my favorite since a kid. However don’t get the macarons from here they are not made right. Each experience with these cookies was disappointing. They don’t bang out the macarons like you’re supposed to so theirs is all air and crumble at first bite. Which is not how these delicate cookies are supposed to be. And $3 each is over priced for something not authentic.“