Ill EagleTaphouse

200 E Church St, Elmira
(607) 442-1421

Recent Reviews

Mike Kulver

Great selection of beers on tap, really fantastic food. Can't go wrong at this place, definitely give it a try!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Susan Birkhead

There food is very good, service was fast. We will be back! You must try the pork belly...it was awesome, the chicken bacon ranch pizza was so good. The only thing I didn't care about was the crab cakes, they were more breading than crab and a little on the soggy side.Parking: It's a small lot that shares with a mattress store.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Luke Smith

Really cool spot in an excellent local history building. Its beautiful interior and its use today make for a very pleasant place to eat, talk, and explore. You can go all over its 3 stories and many of the various rooms. Damn good food, and many excellent beer wine and cocktail selection! 2 pool tables in a separate room just off the huge amount of tables room lol. Darts, a free old school arcade game, and 2 pretty comfy sofas. 2 cozy lounge rooms. The best part is summertime, when the huge deck patio just of the 3rd story bar & lounge is open! Really cool setup with a really nice unique view of downtown. There is live music once a week also. Side note: Check out the furniture story on your way in.Parking: There's plenty of available parking space, the parking right next to the building is kinda wonky, but there's lots of easy additional parking room.Wheelchair accessibility: Not all of the parking is wheelchair accessible, unless your brave with possible help lol. But there is enough handicap parking.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: OH Another IPA Craft Bier, Jumbo Chicken Wings Hot, Wings and Fries, Mediterranean Pizza

Jeremy Voelker

Great relaxed atmosphere. The food was good just not a lot of options. And not really any service. Which was ok. Had to go to bar to order anything and had to use a card to keep an open tab. Whether or not you pay cash or you use your card. Again not complaining just putting it out

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 3

Kristin Griffin

Great for a quick lunch! Loved the variations of high tops, regular tables, even comfy chairs to sit in! Pizza was delicious too!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Mediterranean Pizza

Makaio Iokepa

Such a gem in the middle of Helmira. Enjoy craft beers, wine, or ask for a delicacy from the kitchen. Highly recommend. Especially when Mike is

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ceasar Salad

hue jazz

Food was pretty poor quality for the price. Maybe it was an off day there or a new cook.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Jereme Wensel

We waited over an hr for our one burger and Fries. Not used to that kind of wait. Nice place but slow.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 2

Shawn Auld

Awesome atmosphere and great

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Penny H.

The food is great!! The ambiance is great!! However. The service is atrocious!! As three adult females doing girls' night out, we were treated by the tiny, dark-haired female bartender as though we were wasting her time. When we went to the restroom together and left personal items at the table, the table was completely bussed when we returned. All food, beverages, and cutlery were completely gone! There is no table service. Everything has to be ordered at the bar, so be sure to have someone guard your table while someone else treks back and forth to place orders and fetch drinks.

Dottie L.

My husband enjoyed a flight of beer, including a pumpkin ale, and I had a yummy glass of red wine. He loves his beer and trying new ones, and they have an extensive selection. We shared two different flat breads that were delicious. My only complaint was that the pieces of flat bread were the size of a piece of pizza, and I prefer smaller pieces. We will definitely be visiting this place again!

Wade F.

The bartenders are top notch with a very interesting atmosphere. They also have a wonderful craft beer selection.

Manda Jane

Very very cool place. It's located in what used to be the old federal building in Elmira. Inside, there are multiple different event rooms, bars, dining areas, fun rooms with darts, or billiards, and recently, they added a patio. I've been to a wedding rehearsal here, and I personally had my baby shower here as well, and both were great! They have brunch every Sunday, and they hold event nights like trivia and dart leagues. The food is awesome! They have a great variety for lunch and dinner. IMO, the pickle pizza is the best ? They also have a huge variety of alcoholic beverages, including local beers and wines. Upstairs, they also have local businesses that have areas to check out, and downstairs, they have a furniture store! Honestly, it's just a really cool place with a huge variety to offer!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Ill Eagle Burger, Charcuterie Board, Boneless Wings Medium, Wings and Fries

Chris VanDruff

I'll eagle is the best. The pizza looked amazing although I was only there for beers. Fantastic selection of drinks. That upper patio is amazing!

Linzy D.

this place was seriously fantastic. from the great space to the superb service to the delicious food, we were thrilled with our experience here. the bartender offered great recommendations, including the grandma's sauce for the boneless wings and solid beer & cider selections. the chicken wing pizza had great flavor and was especially good dipped in extra buffalo sauce, and my boyfriend (biggest wing fan ever) said the bone-in buffalo wings were "A+, 10/10" and loved the crispness. if you're in the area, it's a must-try.

Load More