The Lilly Pad

627 Pennsylvania Ave, Elmira

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Faith Smith

Our family highly recommends The Lilly Pad Ice Cream Shop. My husband "found" this place on Facebook so we thought we'd bring our granddaughter here yesterday. We were greeted by a very friendly lady who took my granddaughter's order of a kid sized twist with sprinkles. Perfect size for an excellent price. We returned this evening and she was excited to order a kid sized Poppy's Worm Shack. Our youngest daughter ordered the same. That was a hit with both of them. My caramel cheesecake cookie monster ice cream was amazing! I have never heard of this flavor before. It was delicious! We are already talking about our next visit there. Highly recommend!! oh and to the wonderful lady who was working yesterday evening and this evening, my granddaughter loves her wrist balloon octopus. Thank you!

Chelsie Nichole Bachert

five stars from me!!! My three girls and I (9, 4, and 1) got ice cream there this evening and not only were they super welcoming and polite but they went above and beyond. If I needed more napkins (because... kids) they noticed before I even said anything and brought them out to me. If I asked for a bowl for one of the girls so she didn't drop her cone, they brought another spoon too (because my one year old kept stealing mine 💁🏼‍♀️😂) they're great! I went for the first time today because we live right down the street and I was not disappointed. They have a good selection and milkshakes and other treats other ice cream shops in the area don't have. Great selection, reasonably priced, and friendly people. The best part was Brittany made animal balloons for two of the girls! a turtle 🐢 and a butterfly 🦋. they're adorable and they LOVED them. It was a nice touch and the "cherry" on top on the evening. I probably won't do anywhere else for awhile for ice cream I really hope they stay open!

Jean Shelley

great customer service fresh fruit and ice cream and the prices are reasonable and its flavors are awesome and I would send my friends and family here!

Nella K Jackson

Love it!!! My girls love it!! So many flavors!!

Millie Wilcox

Great place to grab a sundae with loved ones!

John Notholden

Amazing customer service I ordered a single scoop birthday cake ice cream cone which is amazing try it but anyway the owner says I gave you two scoops cause I can lol I love this place and did I mention a single scoop cone is only $4

Warren Morrison

Very friendly staff, amaingly clean environment and perfect icecream at very reasonable rates

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jordan Long

Great ice cream, Service and prices

Siddhesh

The way they serve the soft ice cream is cute - the softie on a dish with the cone on top. They have a good selection of flavors. Some of them I hardly saw around viz. Kahlua, Rum, Tiramisu. I personally like more flavor, so their regular was a bit less flavourful for me (Next time, I'll ask them to add more). Had the Kahlua and Tiramisu. Around $4.5 per soft ice cream.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 4

Christopher Oconnor

Great place! The ice cream is excellent and they went out of their way to make sure that our 1 year old had the perfect treat and a great time in their Halloween trail. Couldn't be happier with our experience

Krystal Alington

My ronin won and he was so excited with his scoop!!! Me and the hubby had a delicious chocolate milk shake!!! Thank you for your amazing service!!!

Kathleen Springstead

Best ice cream ever since I was a kid I could stay away from the place ?

Joe Frega

Best lactose free Ice Cream options in the area. I get a hot fudge sundae made from lactose free chocolate chunk ice cream, with peanut butter brownies, lactose free whipped cream, peanuts n a cherrie!!!wonderful people. I come here every chance i get.My wife loves her hot fudge brownie sundae with soft serve chocolate!Our husky loves the soft serve w peanut butter sauce

Chris Brittany abi and Emi Sprouse

An amazing and affordable family oriented ice cream shop with so many yummy options for you to chose from!! I just happen to know how amazing the owners are, So I know that you're going to love it there!!

LordCreepl (Tim)

Great place with great customer service and serving time! The Family that runs it is very kind and willing to talk with customers about their experience and days! Very good quality ice cream as well and a great place to stop by with the family on a hot day or a cool evening! Hours vary and through experience, check facebook for their hours as to not confuse them with being open all the time as they have lives outside of the ice cream shop!

Loading...