Ordered a Reuben walked out to my truck and started eating it. Hands down the worst Reuben I've ever had meat was cut way too thick and tasted spoiled. I love the Avon location of calabrasellas but this location I will never visit again.
Audrey K
Good food, but the guy that works here who says that he’s the manager needs to watch the things he says around customers. My granddaughter has witnessed him firsthand using racial slurs and derogatory terms that degrades both women and people of color. Will be making a phone call to whoever’s in charge of this store.
Mike Brant
Went to this location a few days ago to get a sub and overheard the older male employee that works here use the “N” word behind the counter. Ended up not purchasing the sub and me and my three year old daughter went to another store. Won’t be returning to this location ever again. Disgusting behavior.
Adam Stutz
Just tried this place for the first time tonight. Great sandwich, friendly and patient staff. I will definitely be back!!!
Karen S.
Pretty bare bones if you're used to their Gates location but the subs were good and the employees were friendly and helpful. Prices were a little on the high side but it's good quality on Main Street so we'll probably stop by again in the future.
Jeff B.
Was in from out of town and local Fairport friends said I should try this place. I had a steak sub with some marinara and melted mozzarella ... not on the menu but they were happy to make it for me. It was delicious! Steak was tender. Bread was soft but not too soft. Already looking forward to the next time I get a chance to eat here.
Michael Donnellan
Excellent experience!!
Jerry Griffith
Great deli
james acker
The people that work there were very friendly steak sandwich rocks ??????
Christine Harder
Subs are great, done exactly how you want it. Love em”!BUT!!!They CLOSE AT 6:00pm from now on?They aren’t even open until at least 8:00pm on weekend nights (Fridays and Saturdays) that’s absurd!!! I get that it’s Covid but hours should be extended past 6pm Fridays and Saturdays. Im very disappointed.
Best chicken parm sub I've ever had, best bread in town, and tons of good local selections for miscellaneous goods.
Dave Martin
I ordered a basic turkey sub. Everything was as expected except the roll itself. It was big, bready and dry. I've been looking forward to finally having a good deli on the Fairport area but would like to see a better quality sub roll. Will keep looking for now.
Kathy Moczarski
I was so happy to hear Calabresella ‘s opened in Fairport. They guys in Gates need to teach the employees in Fairport how to work. Waited more than 10 minutes to order a sub that then took 15 minutes for them to make and only 1 person in front of us. Come on Gates, teach them how it’s done!!
Michael P.
Best sub in Rochester. Colon Kicker ... Reminds me of the Italian Beef sandwiches you can get in Chicago. Bread is seedless and has medium softness maybe slightly on the soft side. It's thick enough where it soaks up all the juice from the Italian beef while keeping it's structure. I've only tried their warm subs so far, but they have all been amazing!
Ordered a Reuben walked out to my truck and started eating it. Hands down the worst Reuben I've ever had meat was cut way too thick and tasted spoiled. I love the Avon location of calabrasellas but this location I will never visit again.
Good food, but the guy that works here who says that he’s the manager needs to watch the things he says around customers. My granddaughter has witnessed him firsthand using racial slurs and derogatory terms that degrades both women and people of color. Will be making a phone call to whoever’s in charge of this store.
Went to this location a few days ago to get a sub and overheard the older male employee that works here use the “N” word behind the counter. Ended up not purchasing the sub and me and my three year old daughter went to another store. Won’t be returning to this location ever again. Disgusting behavior.
Just tried this place for the first time tonight. Great sandwich, friendly and patient staff. I will definitely be back!!!
Pretty bare bones if you're used to their Gates location but the subs were good and the employees were friendly and helpful. Prices were a little on the high side but it's good quality on Main Street so we'll probably stop by again in the future.
Was in from out of town and local Fairport friends said I should try this place. I had a steak sub with some marinara and melted mozzarella ... not on the menu but they were happy to make it for me. It was delicious! Steak was tender. Bread was soft but not too soft. Already looking forward to the next time I get a chance to eat here.
Excellent experience!!
Great deli
The people that work there were very friendly steak sandwich rocks ??????
Subs are great, done exactly how you want it. Love em”!BUT!!!They CLOSE AT 6:00pm from now on?They aren’t even open until at least 8:00pm on weekend nights (Fridays and Saturdays) that’s absurd!!! I get that it’s Covid but hours should be extended past 6pm Fridays and Saturdays. Im very disappointed.
Restaurantji Recommends
Best steak sub on the east side of monroe county
Best chicken parm sub I've ever had, best bread in town, and tons of good local selections for miscellaneous goods.
I ordered a basic turkey sub. Everything was as expected except the roll itself. It was big, bready and dry. I've been looking forward to finally having a good deli on the Fairport area but would like to see a better quality sub roll. Will keep looking for now.
I was so happy to hear Calabresella ‘s opened in Fairport. They guys in Gates need to teach the employees in Fairport how to work. Waited more than 10 minutes to order a sub that then took 15 minutes for them to make and only 1 person in front of us. Come on Gates, teach them how it’s done!!
Best sub in Rochester. Colon Kicker ... Reminds me of the Italian Beef sandwiches you can get in Chicago. Bread is seedless and has medium softness maybe slightly on the soft side. It's thick enough where it soaks up all the juice from the Italian beef while keeping it's structure. I've only tried their warm subs so far, but they have all been amazing!