Read the reviews before eating here last Friday. Sounded good. People raved about the Arincini. Ordered them, no thank you; what happened to the crispy outer layer? Bland inner portion. Bread bought to the table, was underwhelming. We ordered 2 main pasta dishes. Both pastas needed at least 3 minutes to reach el denté. Waitress was sweet, but what happened to my salad with the dressing on the side? What was happening in the kitchen that evening? I try to not complain at restaurants; it puts a damper on the evening. Though after reading my own review, I see how disappointing our meal was. Not going back.
Matthew Englert
One of the worst veal parms ive ever had. Too thick and chewy. “Homemade pasta” was extremely average. Do not recommend
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Sabrina McClow
Celebrated my sister's birthday last night (party of 10) and our waiter Noah was fantastic. Knew the menu and could answer questions in detail. Great service. Food was prepared as ordered, was hot and tasted fresh. Nice atmosphere. The only concern is with the level of noise. The restaurant was about half full and it was noisy. I didn't see any sound absorption tiles or banners and I would recommend they invest in some.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: High Street Pizza, Meatballs
Susan Brassie
Wear good walking shoes as parking was non-existent at the time we scheduled.When making reservations we were charged $10 per person on our credit card, to be refunded when we arrived. We had reservations at 7:00 for 9 people but we weren't seated for 25 minutes. We had to stand near the bar, sadly with our backsides right next to a table of patrons trying to enjoy their meal. No room to wait or sit.It was so incredibly LOUD it made conversation impossible.Drinks took quite a while to be delivered, one drink was incorrect when delivered and finally adjusted. *There was no mention of the $2.00 charge for ice in your drink.* Additionly the wine requested and listed was 'not available'.Ten very small slices of bread was delivered for our party of nine, with dipping oil and ice cold butter. We would have requested more, but could not flag down a server.Menu items are a la carte with a salad at $10 (enough for two to share). Some dinner portions were adequate in size, others were small with no side dish.Although food was good, atmosphere was not. Sorry to say we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
Jeff S.
One of my wife's favorites. When we have out of town company compane is always our first choice. If it's the two of us we have a drink and eat at the bar. I highly recommend their food and the wine selection is way above standard wine lists.
N. Sidhu
We had a fantastic night out with friends. The food and wine were both excellent. I had the calamari, the arancini and the gnocchi. We finished up with the tiramisu cheesecake. Every dish was tasty and well-prepared. The service was efficient and nonintrusive and the ambiance was enchanting. I highly recommend this Fairport gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gnocchi
Steven M.
Bit on expensive side but everything was very good for our party of 3. I would wish for more complete meal, the salad was extra, large, and would have rather a small salad that was included with the meal.
Jim Vallino
We have always had go meals at Compane. This dinner was no exception. I really enjoyed the gnocchi.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gnocchi
J.D. L
We had a large party and the service was amazing. Food was outstanding! Restaurant is very clean. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michael Specht
Excellent food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Parmigiana
Pretty good food! Delicious arancini, and perfect table oil and vinegar. Mezzaluna had wonderfully strong lemon flavor, although water-logged. Wouldn't recommend for a date or more relaxing atmosphere. Ambiance wasn't great, brightly lit, and loud dated (but not retro-fun) music, and outdated decor. Service was certainly kind but not very attentive and not always professional. There's a fee for use of credit card, which is clearly stated on the menu to avoid any surprise.
Sabrina J.
Great service, nice location. - nice bar area - great ambiance for hanging out or date night. - outdoor seating is ideal for when all the festivals are in town I really enjoyed all the dishes. It's a little pricey but they give generous portions. I felt the primi and secondi plates could be split between two people. - blue crab on toast was really good. Not fishy and very flavorful - the fried calamari was spot on perfection. I'd come back just for that again and again. - the gnocchi and pasta dishes were fantastic. You can tell it's all freshly made.
Christiana F.
This place has some really delicious pastas. All the different sauces are so good and the noodles are fun! The bar area is really pretty too.
Neil Anderson
The food was poor. My GF pizza was burned and it looked like the cook just threw it together - very few toppings. My wife’s pizza was well prepared, although it was missing key ingredients listed on the menu. This also reflects poorly on the manager who was informed yet did not come over to see us. We also asked one server (behind the bar) for an extra napkin and he informed us he could not provide it as we were not in his section. Seriously! We won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Tiffany Clay
I've been there several times and it is always fantastic. The food is amazing and the atmosphere is cozy but spacious. Service is fantastic. Highly recommend!
Read the reviews before eating here last Friday. Sounded good. People raved about the Arincini. Ordered them, no thank you; what happened to the crispy outer layer? Bland inner portion. Bread bought to the table, was underwhelming. We ordered 2 main pasta dishes. Both pastas needed at least 3 minutes to reach el denté. Waitress was sweet, but what happened to my salad with the dressing on the side? What was happening in the kitchen that evening? I try to not complain at restaurants; it puts a damper on the evening. Though after reading my own review, I see how disappointing our meal was. Not going back.
One of the worst veal parms ive ever had. Too thick and chewy. “Homemade pasta” was extremely average. Do not recommend
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 3
Celebrated my sister's birthday last night (party of 10) and our waiter Noah was fantastic. Knew the menu and could answer questions in detail. Great service. Food was prepared as ordered, was hot and tasted fresh. Nice atmosphere. The only concern is with the level of noise. The restaurant was about half full and it was noisy. I didn't see any sound absorption tiles or banners and I would recommend they invest in some.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: High Street Pizza, Meatballs
Wear good walking shoes as parking was non-existent at the time we scheduled.When making reservations we were charged $10 per person on our credit card, to be refunded when we arrived. We had reservations at 7:00 for 9 people but we weren't seated for 25 minutes. We had to stand near the bar, sadly with our backsides right next to a table of patrons trying to enjoy their meal. No room to wait or sit.It was so incredibly LOUD it made conversation impossible.Drinks took quite a while to be delivered, one drink was incorrect when delivered and finally adjusted. *There was no mention of the $2.00 charge for ice in your drink.* Additionly the wine requested and listed was 'not available'.Ten very small slices of bread was delivered for our party of nine, with dipping oil and ice cold butter. We would have requested more, but could not flag down a server.Menu items are a la carte with a salad at $10 (enough for two to share). Some dinner portions were adequate in size, others were small with no side dish.Although food was good, atmosphere was not. Sorry to say we will not be back.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 5
Service: 3
One of my wife's favorites. When we have out of town company compane is always our first choice. If it's the two of us we have a drink and eat at the bar. I highly recommend their food and the wine selection is way above standard wine lists.
We had a fantastic night out with friends. The food and wine were both excellent. I had the calamari, the arancini and the gnocchi. We finished up with the tiramisu cheesecake. Every dish was tasty and well-prepared. The service was efficient and nonintrusive and the ambiance was enchanting. I highly recommend this Fairport gem!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gnocchi
Bit on expensive side but everything was very good for our party of 3. I would wish for more complete meal, the salad was extra, large, and would have rather a small salad that was included with the meal.
We have always had go meals at Compane. This dinner was no exception. I really enjoyed the gnocchi.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Gnocchi
We had a large party and the service was amazing. Food was outstanding! Restaurant is very clean. Thank you!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent food and
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Caesar Salad, Pepperoni Pizza, Chicken Parmigiana
Restaurantji Recommends
Pretty good food! Delicious arancini, and perfect table oil and vinegar. Mezzaluna had wonderfully strong lemon flavor, although water-logged. Wouldn't recommend for a date or more relaxing atmosphere. Ambiance wasn't great, brightly lit, and loud dated (but not retro-fun) music, and outdated decor. Service was certainly kind but not very attentive and not always professional. There's a fee for use of credit card, which is clearly stated on the menu to avoid any surprise.
Great service, nice location. - nice bar area - great ambiance for hanging out or date night. - outdoor seating is ideal for when all the festivals are in town I really enjoyed all the dishes. It's a little pricey but they give generous portions. I felt the primi and secondi plates could be split between two people. - blue crab on toast was really good. Not fishy and very flavorful - the fried calamari was spot on perfection. I'd come back just for that again and again. - the gnocchi and pasta dishes were fantastic. You can tell it's all freshly made.
This place has some really delicious pastas. All the different sauces are so good and the noodles are fun! The bar area is really pretty too.
The food was poor. My GF pizza was burned and it looked like the cook just threw it together - very few toppings. My wife’s pizza was well prepared, although it was missing key ingredients listed on the menu. This also reflects poorly on the manager who was informed yet did not come over to see us. We also asked one server (behind the bar) for an extra napkin and he informed us he could not provide it as we were not in his section. Seriously! We won’t be back.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
I've been there several times and it is always fantastic. The food is amazing and the atmosphere is cozy but spacious. Service is fantastic. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5