They have consistently good pizza! They took my order right before closing and accommodated me. Thank you ♥️
Lisa Rand
I ordered a meatball sub on a hard roll to go, light sauce. It was delish. I would give them a five except it came in a clamshell. Why can’t you just put a sub in butcher paper? So much less wasteful and it has to be cheaper.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carl
My daughter has soccer practice at the Game up the street and I have always told her we will get pizza from here “sometime” after practice.
Well today was that day. I ordered a large thin crust with pepperoni slightly well done online figuring we’d get drinks and eat it there when it was done so we could speed up the wait.
The ordering said 30 minutes. We got there after about 15 and it was already done. We grabbed the box and a drink and sat down.
This pizza looked good. I forgot to take a photo of it when I first opened the box so I took one after some of the pizza was chosen and eaten.
It was done perfect. Brown and crispy on the bottom but not burnt. The pepperoni are the type that curl up but not all the way. The sauce is good. It was a great pizza and hungry kids agree!
We enjoyed the pizza, our time here, and the guys who are working here are awesome.
We will be in again after practice I can guarantee it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Phil M.
Have wanted to try this for years but it's out of the way from where I am so I forgot about it. Finally had a slice today - one of the best pizzas I've tasted, and Rochester has lots of good pizza. We'll be back soon for the whole pie.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Adam Stutz
Great Pizza! And always been very pleased with anything else we have ordered from their very big menu!!! And always amazing service too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Todd Sheehan
Great NY thin crust Pizza. Great sauce.
Andrew Walker
Pizza was just ok. Was only slightly warm when picking it up. Expected more meat toppings for the price.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Ryan Wirth
One of the best NYS pizza places in the country. It was delicious and then some.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shawn Keeler
Ordered a large pizza, came out as a sheet pizza that caught me off guard. Tasted fine but not the same with all the middle pieces when you’re expecting a good pie.Wings were cooked well but sauce was way too thick. Ordered medium and was like a bbq thickness. I’d order plain next time if I go back and add a store bought sauce.
Thomas Conley
Good Pizza. Extra delivery fees, additional charge for online ordering and taxes add $10.75 to a $50 order before tip. +$75 it's just too much for two pizzas.
Pizza snob here: I love all varieties of pizza but can tell if they’re not executed well, and this is excellent pizza! This is real “corner pizza place” pizza, no boutique styles like wood-fired Neapolitan, Detroit, or Sicilian here. But the different bake options give you a lot of variety, and easily outclass many local competitors. The thin crust is a better “NYC”-style slice than Cam’s, which can be too chewy, and the thick crust is a better “WNY”-style slice than Mark’s, as it’s lighter and fluffier. Unique sauce recipe stands out as an actual “topping” with a distinct flavor, as opposed to just a standard base, but without being overpowering. Sole (minor) complaint is that the “Crispy” bake turned out a little too chewy, and, like Cam’s, became fatiguing to chew after a slice or two, but this is easily avoided by sticking with the “Lightly Done” bake, so no worries there. Friendly, helpful staff who clearly take great pride in being a long-running family-owned business. Can’t wait to order from them again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Mar Harnish
Selection was good, prices are good. Food is just ok. My calzone only had pepperoni in one half, the slice was ok, skimpy cheese. My husband's sub was good, and steak fries were good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Marlene Harnish
our food looked great bringing it home. it was just so-so. I ordered a calzone with mozzarella, pepperoni and onions, one half has no pepperoni except for a couple of pieces in the crust. I sent them a text saying how good everything was, but that was before we got too far in our meal. stinger sub my husband ordered was pretty skimpy and very well done. really disappointed
They have consistently good pizza! They took my order right before closing and accommodated me. Thank you ♥️
I ordered a meatball sub on a hard roll to go, light sauce. It was delish. I would give them a five except it came in a clamshell. Why can’t you just put a sub in butcher paper? So much less wasteful and it has to be cheaper.
Food: 5
Service: 5
My daughter has soccer practice at the Game up the street and I have always told her we will get pizza from here “sometime” after practice.
Well today was that day. I ordered a large thin crust with pepperoni slightly well done online figuring we’d get drinks and eat it there when it was done so we could speed up the wait.
The ordering said 30 minutes. We got there after about 15 and it was already done. We grabbed the box and a drink and sat down.
This pizza looked good. I forgot to take a photo of it when I first opened the box so I took one after some of the pizza was chosen and eaten.
It was done perfect. Brown and crispy on the bottom but not burnt. The pepperoni are the type that curl up but not all the way. The sauce is good. It was a great pizza and hungry kids agree!
We enjoyed the pizza, our time here, and the guys who are working here are awesome.
We will be in again after practice I can guarantee it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Have wanted to try this for years but it's out of the way from where I am so I forgot about it. Finally had a slice today - one of the best pizzas I've tasted, and Rochester has lots of good pizza. We'll be back soon for the whole pie.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Great Pizza! And always been very pleased with anything else we have ordered from their very big menu!!! And always amazing service too!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great NY thin crust Pizza. Great sauce.
Pizza was just ok. Was only slightly warm when picking it up. Expected more meat toppings for the price.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
One of the best NYS pizza places in the country. It was delicious and then some.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered a large pizza, came out as a sheet pizza that caught me off guard. Tasted fine but not the same with all the middle pieces when you’re expecting a good pie.Wings were cooked well but sauce was way too thick. Ordered medium and was like a bbq thickness. I’d order plain next time if I go back and add a store bought sauce.
Good Pizza. Extra delivery fees, additional charge for online ordering and taxes add $10.75 to a $50 order before tip. +$75 it's just too much for two pizzas.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Restaurantji Recommends
Best sauce around.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Best pizza in townSuper consistent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza snob here: I love all varieties of pizza but can tell if they’re not executed well, and this is excellent pizza! This is real “corner pizza place” pizza, no boutique styles like wood-fired Neapolitan, Detroit, or Sicilian here. But the different bake options give you a lot of variety, and easily outclass many local competitors. The thin crust is a better “NYC”-style slice than Cam’s, which can be too chewy, and the thick crust is a better “WNY”-style slice than Mark’s, as it’s lighter and fluffier. Unique sauce recipe stands out as an actual “topping” with a distinct flavor, as opposed to just a standard base, but without being overpowering. Sole (minor) complaint is that the “Crispy” bake turned out a little too chewy, and, like Cam’s, became fatiguing to chew after a slice or two, but this is easily avoided by sticking with the “Lightly Done” bake, so no worries there. Friendly, helpful staff who clearly take great pride in being a long-running family-owned business. Can’t wait to order from them again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Selection was good, prices are good. Food is just ok. My calzone only had pepperoni in one half, the slice was ok, skimpy cheese. My husband's sub was good, and steak fries were good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
our food looked great bringing it home. it was just so-so. I ordered a calzone with mozzarella, pepperoni and onions, one half has no pepperoni except for a couple of pieces in the crust. I sent them a text saying how good everything was, but that was before we got too far in our meal. stinger sub my husband ordered was pretty skimpy and very well done. really disappointed
Loading...