Maggie’s Sweet Shoppe & Bakery

Delicious cookie cake. Super soft, frosting was amazing too. Easy to pick up and the packaging was perfect for any Buffalo Bills fan! Go Bills! Thank you!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

You have not had a cookie until you have had Maggie’s cookies! We are talking out of this world flavors, amazing consistency, huge size and just 10/10 taste. What ever her secret is, she’s killing it! She had a pop up tent sale this last weekend and I had to go and get a dozen to share with family and friends and keep some for myself. Not to mention she’s a hard working mom who finds time to balance all of this. Supporting Maggie’s business with your sweet tooth is the best kind of cookie decision you could possibly make!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maggie’s cookies are hands down the best! I am gluten free so I enjoy her flourless PB cookies - sooo decadent and yummy. But my family loves allll of the other flavors. 100 out of 10 recommend!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

It’s so great to have an amazing option for cookies in Fairport! Every flavor we have tried is great- the lemon iced cookie is a real standout though. Can’t wait to see what new flavors are available in the coming months!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maggie’s cookies are delicious! I had previously been getting Crumbl cookies, but these are way better! We also ordered cookies for my son’s birthday party and they were a hit.

Cookies are amazing! Best we have had! The basic chocolate chip to the cookies and cream!

Food: 5

Maggie’s Sweet Shop offers up fresh and delicious cookies . She rotates her selection every couple of weeks so if you have a favorite you don’t wait long for it to be offered. They are a generous size so they are shareable as well . The packaging she uses is pretty enough to give them as a gift as well. If you love gourmet cookies , I highly recommend ordering from Maggie’s - you will not be disappointed

Food: 5

Service: 5

I first had the cookies at a birthday party as a favor-they were amazing!! Since then I’ve had them several times and loved them.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am way overdue to write this review because I am an enormous fan of Maggie’s delicious cookies—and Maggie herself! She continues to come up with new flavors that never disappoint-this fall the pumpkin, pumpkin coffe cake, and molasses cookies have been amazing! I’m a loyal customer for sure!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Absolutely delicious cookies! Will definitely share far and wide and use when I need special orders!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Maggie has the best cookies we have ever tasted! You are never disappointed and continually impressed with all of her flavors!! They are so unique and so tasty!! We've had them a couple of times with a group of people and everyone is raving about them after! They are easy to cut and share too!She's also so easy to work with and order from! Very quick to reply and answer any questions you might have! Also suggest the best way to store cookies.

Maggie’s cookies are incredible! Best cookies ever!

First let me say, I am pretty picky when it comes to cookies. I have a huge sweet tooth and they are my favorite treat. Maggies cookies are so delicious! They are very generous in size, she has a really great variety of flavors and they are so soft and gooey! The chocolate chip are my favorite! Maggie is also so sweet, very responsive and you can tell puts so much care/effort into making the cookies. I highly recommend!

Best cookies! Ordered them for my husband's birthday and everyone loved them. Large, fluffy pillows of amazing flavor and even better warmed up! Can't wait to order again.

I am extremely picky about my cookies and that might be an understatement. I discovered Maggie's cookies because someone I follow and Instagram posted about it. I have to control myself from not ordering every week. Top notch, mouth watering cookies!