Moonlight Creamery

36 West Ave, Fairport
(585) 223-0880

Recent Reviews

Sort by
lord rom

Excellent flavor to their home made icreams!
Went up to Rochester to see my son at college and stopped in for desert.
The owner is a great guy and has a beautiful shop right by the Erie Canal Bridge.
Was an awesome experience.
He found out my son loved rubber ducks and gave us a large NY duck for him(which he loved).
We will be back next trip up!

James Lally

Great service and a tasty Sunday treat!

Warren

Bad service today. Rude and inappropriate. No reason they couldn’t be nice.

Kenna Kelley

We stopped from out of town just passing through for impromptu ice cream and it was amazing!! Freshest ice cream and waffle cone we’ve ever had! Workers were sweet, great vibes, reasonable prices. I wish we weren’t driving far so we could bring some home with us!

Loris

Very well done and professional.

Michael Conway

I had an excellent experience.

Allison D

Great little ice cream shop in the heart of Fairport. Love that there’s a nice outdoor seating area overlooked the canal

Femi Kevin Murphy

Awesome ice cream!

Patrick Cicchetti

Amazing ice cream, amazinger customer service! We came here a couple weeks ago with family and the ice cream was so good that we just drove back from Brockport for more. To the guy who served us brown sugar oat around 8pm on Friday 7/12/25--you're the best!

Kristin Dona

The ice cream itself was solid, nothing special but fine. However, the staff was extremely rude. They refused to give out samples (which is honestly part of the ice cream-buying experience) and when I asked for a cup instead of a cone, the employee acted like he didn’t know what I was talking about and said he “couldn’t put it in a coffee cup.”

There are plenty of other great ice cream spots around, so I’d avoid supporting this place in the future. The ice cream isn't good enough to justify such poor customer service.

Vipul Agrawal

Mikey is amazing!!! 🤩
A lot of variety in flavors which are all good and oat meal was surprisingly outstanding

John Jack

The ice cream was fine. I have never been to an ice cream shop that didn't offer samples tho. Weird take.

One of the joys of going to an ice cream shop is trying a couple flavors to figure out what you want.

Brendon Thomas

Ice cream delicious, but service is on the slower side every time I’ve been there. Great location though.

Jo Ann Shaughnessy

All those delicious flavors!! Lemon Meringue pie was awesome!!

Laura Rose Alley

They make the best ice cream! I also love the brands that they do carry. Hands down my favorite ice cream spot!

Loading...