Salvatore's Old Fashioned Pizzeria

We usually only order pizza (The Best) but decided to try the Thursday special, LARGE
cold sub for $10 plus a 20oz drink.
Here’s the truth…it was the best sub we’ve ever had and hubby is an expert.
Since we know the owner, we assumed he gave us the ultimate sub. Nope, when I called to thank him for the extra attention I was told that all the subs are made the same for everyone. Super impressed, highly recommend.

Food: 5

Service: 5

It is always FANTASTIC at Salvatore‘s:)
EVERYTHING IS DELICIOUS
Highly Recommended

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was in town for work installed an ATM next door at nbt. The staff suggested Salvatore s it was 10 dollars sub day. So I did . The food was like my grandma was alive again nothing like an Italian pizzeria. The lady who served the food was yes like my grandma was home . I give the good and the environment 1-10 I give it a 20 if in area or hey even just to come to area for Salvatore's I would highly suggest trying the food . It's hard finding an old Italian run business. But they still do exist. So yes great food warm family feeling environment.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great pizza and more.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Alessio was so helpful in planning a menu for my son’s Surprise 30th Birthday Party Saturday October 18, 2025. I ordered the sheet pizza with a few toppings, the garlic knots, chicken wings, baked ziti and their cookies. The order was delivered right on time and the food was hot and delicious. I would highly recommend Salvatore’s Pizza in Fairport for catering an event. Thank you Alessio for helping make the party a success.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The people working at this salvatores are awesome extremely nice and super helpful willing to go the extra mile to make you happy. tried the pizza twist so good worth stopping in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

As a man who does not eat pizza very often I found myself eat pizza 2 days in a row and thinking about the pizza while working the staff is amazing and make sure you feel welcome

Friendly small pizza ship. Salvatore classic menu. Single slices available to have heated up in oven, vegetarian selections as well as meatlovers. Mama C is still working at this location in fairport village, 5am till 11am prepping your delicious food for the day!! Great small serving(5 pieced) of boneless chicken wings in boss sauce,parmesean garlic and buffalo sauce.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Staff so friendly and accommodating. Pizza was amazing.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

very good service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The pizza is always yummy. My kids love Salvatore’s. I ordered a fish fry last night and boy it wasn’t as good as I remember Salvatore’s FF’s to be! It was wayyy over cooked, the sweet potato fries I got with them tasted like they were fried in dark, not clean oil! The coleslaw and Mac salad.. it was soggy, as if it was sitting in the fridge for a few days. Nothing tasted fresh at all! The fish was super dry and had ZERO flavor! Man, I’ve gotten fish fry’s at other Salvatore’s (S. Clinton, W. Ridge Rd.) they were delicious!! But idk Fairport.. as expensive as everything is around here, you think you’d get a basic, good, fresh fish fry!! I’m NOT HAPPY! Oh yea.. when it arrived , I had NO TARTAR SAUCE!! Who forgets to give a paying customer who orders a fish fry- no tartar sauce??!! I did call them and they drove back out and brought me 2.. I mean their pizza and steaks subs are pretty good.. but man, do they need to improve those fish fry’s!!!

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 4

Best pizza I had in a long time friendly staff didn't have to wait long and it was on one of the busiest nights the fairport music fest..Definitely will go back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was around 8:30 pm I was hungry strolling along the canal. I decided to call in an order to go and I was really impressed. The staff were all super nice and attentive while maintaining their closing duties. The store was very clean inside and my order was taken by a young lady I believe I over heard her name was Trish. She was very friendly and super knowledgeable about the menu. One of the owners was present i believe her name is Sarah and she and her husband have done amazing work in turning this location back into a successful place to get a decent meal. They have brought new life into the location by having a great staff and marvelous ideas. (My favorite is doughnuts delite on Saturday mornings)

We order pizza and wings from the Fairport Salvatore’s often. The food is always phenomenal and ready on time. The staff is friendly and kind. Easily the best pizza in the Fairport!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

On 7/11/25, 5th grade students from the Encompass Program ventured to Fairport , NY to learn about owning a business. Sarah Santiago met with us and spoke to our students/answered questions about the ins and outs of Salvatore’s Fairport. Salvatore’s donated delicious pizzas for our lunch. It was a wonderful day of learning and eating for our future entrepreneurs.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5