Papa’s Pizza
199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale
(516) 586-5600
Customers' Favorites
Mozzarella Caprese Appetizer
12 Personal Primavera Pizza
Baked Ziti with Meatballs
Cauliflower Cheese Pizza
Neopolian Slice of Pizza
Sausage Parmigiana Hero
Large Meat Lovers Pizza
Neapolitan Plain Pizza
Mulberry Street Panini
12 Personal White Pizza
Featured items
Large Neapolitan Pizza (Most Popular) ❤
Neapolitan Round Crust
Mozzarella and Homemade Tomato Sauce made with Basil and Olive Oil.
Fresh and simply unforgettable!
Personal Cheese Pizza (Best Seller)
Plain pie with cheese and sauce.
Chicken parmigiana Hero (Top Seller)
Garlic Knots with Cheese & Sauce (6)
Personal White Pizza
Neapolitan pie topped with melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
Chicken Francese
Egg battered chicken in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
Chicken Bruschetta
Grilled or breaded chicken, topped with tomato, red onion, and fresh mozzarella tossed in balsamic and oil.
Chicken Sorrentino
Egg battered chicken, white wine lemon butter sauce, spinach, and mozzarella cheese.
Personal Chicken Marsala Pizza
Topped with seared chicken breast, sautéed mushrooms, onions, Marsala wine sauce, and cheese.
Personal Baked Ziti Pizza
Topped with penne pasta mixed with tomato sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese.
Eggplant Parmigiana (Most Popular)
Fried eggplant, sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese.
Penne with Sausage
Meatball parm hero
Baked Ziti
Chicken Roll
Old Fashion Sicilian Pizza (Square)
Brooklyn Favorite!!!! Whole milk Grande Mozzarella, Homemade Sicilian Sauce, oregano, grated Romano cheese, olive oil.
Enjoy it!!!
Cauliflower Vodka Pizza
Baked Ravioli
Ravioli with melted Mozzarella on top
Spaghetti Carbonara
Pancetta, peas, and shallots in a cream sauce.
Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Topped with hot Buffalo chicken and cheese.
Appetizers
6 Garlic Knots
Garlic Knots with Cheese & Sauce (6)
Wings (6 or 12)
Your choice of Hot, Medium. BBQ or Naked
Served with Celery and choice of Bleu Cheese or Ranch
Papa's Sampler
3 mozzarella sticks, 3 zucchini sticks, fried calamari, fried ravioli, and marinara sauce.
Mozzarella Sticks (6 pcs)
Mini Riceballs (3)
Zucchini Sticks
Served with tomato sauce
Drunken Eggplant Parmigiana App
Vodka cream sauce and melted mozzarella.
Chicken Fingers (4) & French Fries
Golden brown chicken tenders served with a side of French fries.
Baked Clams [8]
Fried Ravioli (6 pcs)
Buffalo Mozzarela Sticks (6)
Sautéed in our delicious buffalo sauce. Served with blue cheese carrots and celery.
French Fries with Melted Mozzarella
French fries with melted mozzarella.
Fried Calamari
Mozzarella Caprese Appetizer
Layered fresh mozzarella, tomato, roasted red peppers, and basil with balsamic glaze.
Eggplant Rollatine Appetizer (2 pcs)
Salads
House Salad
Tomato, cucumber, roasted peppers, black and green olives, over romaine lettuce, and served with house Italian dressing.
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, homemade croutons, and parmesan cheese served with creamy Caesar dressing.
Greek Salad
Tomato, cucumber, black olives, and feta cheese over romaine lettuce. Served with house Italian dressing.
Buffalo Chicken Salad
Romaine lettuce, tomato,, carrots, buffalo chicken, and blue cheese dressing.
Antipasto Salad
Garden salad with ham, pepperoni, provolone cheese, and salami.
Soups
Chicken Soup
Lentil Soup
Straciatella A La Romana
Spinach and Egg drop in Chicken broth
Sides
Side of Broccoli Rabe
Side of Sauteed Broccoli
Side Parmesan cheese (2 Oz)
Ricotta (4 OZ)
Fried Chicken Cutlet (2)
Side of Garlic Powder (2 Oz)
Side of Red Peper Flakes (2 Oz) Recommended!
Grilled Chicken (2)
Panini
Chicken BLT Panini
Fried chicken, bacon, mayo, romaine lettuce, tomatoes, and melted mozzarella.
House Panini
Grilled or breaded chicken, fresh mozzarella, lettuce, and tomato.
Paesano Panini (Top Seller)
Grilled chicken, Broccoli rabe, roasted peppers fresh mozzarella.
Mulberry Street Panini
Grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, fried eggplant, roasted pepper, and red onion.
Wraps
Buffalo Chicken Wrap
Chicken fingers, buffalo sauce, tomato and blue cheese dressing.
Chicken Caesar Wrap
Grilled chicken, romaine lettuce, parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing.
BLT Wrap
Bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
Greek Salad Wrap
Grilled chicken, Feta, roasted pepper, tomatoes, and basil with balsamic vinaigrette.
Heroes
Chicken parmigiana Hero (Top Seller)
Meatball parm hero
Italian Combo Hero
Salami, ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and Italian dressing.
Chicken Club Hero
Grilled Chicken, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise.
Eggplant Parmigiana Hero
Sausage Parmigiana Hero
Sausage & Pepper Hero
Shrimp Parm Hero
Veal Parmigiana Hero
Buffalo Chicken Hero
Buffalo Chicken, Melted Mozz
Philly Cheese Steak Hero
Papa's Favorite
Grilled Chicken, Brocolli Rabe & Fresh Mozz on a freshly baked & toasted Hero.
(Request with or without Cherry Peppers. Without by default)
Rolls & Pinwheels
Spinach Pinwheel
Cheese Calzone
Chicken Roll
Buffalo Chicken Roll
Pepperoni Pinwheel
Sausage & Pepper Roll
Eggplant Roll
Meat Calzone
Pepperoni, Sauasage, Mozzarella and Ricotta Cheese
Pizza By The Slice
Regular Slice (Most Popular)
Pepperoni Slice
Chicken Caesar Slice
Rigatoni Vodka Slice
Homemade rigatoni, crispy chicken, bacon, and pink vodka sauce.
Sicilian Slice
Margherita Slice
Regular and Fresh mozzarella, Marinara sauce and basil
Grandma ala Vodka Slice
Creamy Vodka & Fresh Mozzarella
Buffalo Slice
Chicken Bacon Ranch Slice
Chicken Parm Slice
Barbecue Chicken Slice
Old Fashion Sicilian Slice
Upside Down Sicilian
White Slice
Meat Lover Slice
Pepperoni, meatball, sausage, mozzarella, and cheese pizza sauce.
Grandma Slice
Chicken and Broccoli Slice
Vegetable Slice
Personal Pizzas 12"
Personal Cheese Pizza (Best Seller)
Plain pie with cheese and sauce.
Personal Chicken Marsala Pizza
Topped with seared chicken breast, sautéed mushrooms, onions, Marsala wine sauce, and cheese.
Personal White Pizza
Neapolitan pie topped with melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
Personal Hawaiian Pizza
Topped with ham, pineapple, and cheese.
Personal Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Personal Margherita Pizza
Marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, garlic, and basil.
Personal Ala Vodka Pizza
Vodka Sauce.
Personal Chicken Parmesan Pizza
Crispy chicken, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
Personal Baked Ziti Pizza
Topped with penne pasta mixed with tomato sauce, ricotta, and mozzarella cheese.
Personal BBQ Chicken Pizza
Topped with BBQ chicken and mozzarella cheese.
Personal Primavera Pizza
Topped with sautéed mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, peppers, and cheese.
Personal Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pizza
Rigatoni, vodka sauce, and mozzarella.
Personal Chicken Caesar Pizza
Topped with romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, creamy Caesar dressing, and grated parmesan.
Personal Meat Lovers Pizza
Topped with sausage, chicken, bacon, meatballs, pepperoni, and extra cheese.
Cauliflower Pizza 10"
Cauliflower Vodka Pizza with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese
Cauliflower Vegetable Pizza
Cauliflower Fried Chicken Bruschetta Pizza
Cauliflower Pepperoni Pizza
Cauliflower Gluten Free Margarita Pizza
Cauliflower Vodka Pizza
Cauliflower Cheese Pizza
Cauliflower Grilled Chicken with Broccoli
Cauliflower Mushroom & Cheese Pizza
Cauliflower Sausage & Cheese Pizza
Large Pizzas
Large Neapolitan Pizza (Most Popular) ❤
Neapolitan Round Crust
Mozzarella and Homemade Tomato Sauce made with Basil and Olive Oil.
Fresh and simply unforgettable!
Sicilian Pie
Thick crust Sicilian sauce and grande mozzarella.
Old Fashion Sicilian Pizza (Square)
Brooklyn Favorite!!!! Whole milk Grande Mozzarella, Homemade Sicilian Sauce, oregano, grated Romano cheese, olive oil.
Enjoy it!!!
Large Grandma Pizza
Thin crust, famous grandma sauce, grande mozzarella, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, and basil.
Large Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Topped with hot Buffalo chicken and cheese.
Margherita Pizza
Marinara sauce, fresh mozzarella, extra virgin olive oil, garlic, and basil.
Large Meat Lovers Pizza
Topped with sausage, chicken, bacon, meatballs, pepperoni, and extra cheese.
Our "Famous" Crostino Pizza
Thin bakes garlic crust topped with fresh mozzarella, fresh slice tomatoes, fresh basil. Topped off with Extra Virgin Olive Oil w/ salt & pepper sprinkled on top
Large Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pizza
Chicken pieces, smoked bacon, vodka sauce, and mozzarella.
Large BBQ Chicken Pizza
Topped with BBQ chicken and mozzarella cheese.
Large Ala Vodka Pizza
A la Vodka sauce
Large White Pizza
Neapolitan pie topped with melted mozzarella and ricotta cheese.
Large Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Mozzarella cheese, maple glazed bacon, and chopped tomatoes. Topped with cheddar and ranch dressing.
Large Hawaiian Pizza
Topped with ham, pineapple, and cheese.
Large Primavera Pizza
Topped with sautéed mushrooms, spinach, broccoli, tomatoes, peppers, and cheese.
Large Chicken Caesar Pizza
Topped with romaine lettuce, grilled chicken, creamy Caesar dressing, and grated parmesan.
Large Chicken Marsala Pizza
Topped with seared chicken breast, sauteed mushrooms, onions, Marsala wine sauce, and cheese.
Large Chicken and Broccoli Pizza
Topped with grilled chicken and broccoli on a white crust.
Large Chicken Parmesan Pizza
Crispy chicken, tomato sauce, and mozzarella cheese.
Pastas
Penne Ala Vodka (Best Seller)
Penne in our homemade A la Vodka sauce.
Spaghetti Carbonara
Pancetta, peas, and shallots in a cream sauce.
Penne with Sausage
Pasta Alfredo
Homemade Alfredo sauce and Parmesan cheese.
Baked Ziti
Spaghetti alla Mama
Fresh chopped tomatoes, basil, marinara sauce, chunks of fresh mozzarella, and pink cream sauce.
Spaghetti with Meatball
Rigatoni Florentina
Rigatoni tossed with fresh chicken pieces and spinach, sautéed in a creamy pink sauce with melted mozzarella.
Meat Lasagna
Our homemade lasagna features layers of slow-braised beef, creamy ricotta, al dente pasta sheets, our marinara sauce, our Parmesan blend, and mozzarella.
Spaghetti Bolognese
Fresh ground beef with tomato sauce and a touch of heavy cream, topped with ricotta cheese.
Penne with Broccoli
Sautéed in Garlic and Oil
Baked Ziti with Meatballs
Baked ziti with homemade meatballs and grande mozzarella.
Baked Ravioli
Ravioli with melted Mozzarella on top
Linguini with Chicken & Broccoli
Grilled chicken and broccoli, with chopped tomatoes in garlic and oil.
Spaghetti with Meat Sauce
Manicotti
Penne Cremosa
Bacon, creamy roasted garlic, and fresh basil.
Linguini with Shrimp & Broccoli
Sautéed shrimp and broccoli, with chopped tomatoes in garlic and oil.
Stuffed Shells
Linguini White Clam Sauce
Fresh little neck clams in a white wine sauce.
Penne Primavera
Broccoli, mushrooms, carrots, and peas sautéed in garlic and oil.
Entrees
Chicken Bruschetta
Grilled or breaded chicken, topped with tomato, red onion, and fresh mozzarella tossed in balsamic and oil.
Chicken Parmigiana Dinner (Best Seller)
Breaded chicken, sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Sorrentino
Egg battered chicken, white wine lemon butter sauce, spinach, and mozzarella cheese.
Eggplant Parmigiana (Most Popular)
Fried eggplant, sauce, and melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Piccata
Seared chicken, capers, and artichoke hearts in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
Chicken Marsala
Seared chicken and sautéed mushrooms in a marsala wine sauce.
Chicken Jennifer
Sautéed chicken topped with fresh spinach, mushrooms, marsala wine sauce, and melted mozzarella.
Veal Marsala
Chicken Francese
Egg battered chicken in a lemon butter white wine sauce.
Eggplant Rollatine (3 pcs)
Pieces of fried eggplant rolled with seasoned ricotta and romano cheese. Topped with sauce and melted mozzarella cheese.
Chicken Alla Vodka
Breaded chicken, melted mozzarella, and creamy vodka sauce.
Chicken Verdi
Egg battered chicken, white wine lemon butter sauce, spinach, and mozzarella cheese.
Grilled Chicken with Vegetables
Grilled chicken with sautéed spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, tomato, and roasted pepper.
Chicken Cacciatore
Sautéed chicken, tomato, mushrooms, onions, and peppers.
Veal Piccata
Tender pan-seared veal sauteed with capers and artichoke hearts in a light wine lemon sauce.
Veal Parmigiana
Veal Francese
Seafood
Lobster Ravioli
Lobster stuffed Ravioli sautéed in our homemade pink sauce. Topped with basil and sundried tomatoes
Shrimp Parmigiana
Served over pasta.
Shrimp Marinara
Served over pasta.
Choice of Regular or FraDiavlo sauce
Shrimp Scampi
Served over pasta.
Shrimp Francaise
Served over pasta.
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
Served with baby clams and FraDiavlo sauce over Linguini.
Kid's Menu
Spaghetti with Meatball kids
A small portion of spaghetti with one meatball in Tomato sauce w/ a piece of bread
Kenzie's Favorite - Chicken Fingers w/ Panpans
4 chicken fingers and crispy fries served with honey mustard
Spaghetti with Chicken kids
A small portion of spaghetti with pieces of fried chicken.
Desserts
Sugar Knots (6)
6 of our delicious homemade sugar knots.
NY Cheesecake
Oreo Cake
Slice of delicious and fluffy Oreo cake
Carrot cake
Cannoli
Drinks
20 Oz Regular Coke
2 Liter
20 Oz Orange Soda
20 Oz Diet Coke
20 Oz Ginger Ale
20 Oz Spite
20 Oz Dr Pepper
Can Soda
16.9 Poland Spring Water
Monster Energy Drink
Diet Coke Can
20 Oz Lemonade!
Daily Specials (Coupons)
Family Treat (Top Seller) Limited Time Offer.
1 large cheese pie, choice of meatball, eggplant, or chicken Parmesan hero, baked ziti, and 12 garlic knots. Cannot be combined with any other offers.
Family Combo
The We'll Feed Your Family Combo (Limited Time Offer)
The "We'll feed your family!" combo comes with (1) regular18 inches large pie, (1) chicken parm hero, (1) penne alla vodka, and (1) large Caesar salad.
*Cannot be combined with any other offers*
Photos
+43 photos
+42 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Finally a legit pizzeria on the Island!! As a born and raised Queens girl who moved out East nearly 10 years ago, it's been a battle to find anywhere comparable to Lucia's... but Papa's takes the prize. And I might even add that they are better!
October 2025
Ho-Lee WOW! I am currently doing the Keto diet and so I ordered the Meat Lovers with Alfredo Sauce on Cauliflower crust and it was seriously the greatest food I've eaten since I arrived in Long Island from Utah a week ago. The atmosphere was inviting and the service exceeded my expectations! I cannot wait to return! Do yourself a favor and go get yourself some phenomenal pizza from Papa's Pizza! 🔥🔥🔥
August 2025
One of the best slices of Sicilian I have ever had… I was doing a delivery, was greeted professionally and they actually cared about the customer, they were out of a drink and attempted to call multiple times… how’s that for service. I walked out of the place and I get a call that I received a positive review. They didn’t have to go out of their way for me at all. In conclusion, the place didn’t even charge me for the slice. Was completely mind blown. Don’t just go...
June 2025
You May Also Like
Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant - 188 Merritts Rd
![]()
Italian, Pizza
Irving's - 180 Merritts Rd
![]()
American, Sandwich Shop, Burgers, Hot Dogs
Dunkin' - 194 Merritts Rd
![]()
Coffee Shops, Coffee & Tea, Donuts, Coffee