Rosemarie's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Absolutely delicious menu selections, terrific service, and consistently positive dining experience. The chicken oreganata entree is fantastic!

We celebrated my niece/Goddaughters Baptism here on June 22, 2025. The food was great. Everything we had was excellent. The staff was very attentive to us. We had Sophia as our server/bartender, and she was wonderful. The restaurant itself was very clean as well. I am giving 3 stars for the following reason: On one of the hottest days of the year, their A/C wasn't working. The thermostat in the restaurant was reading 85 at one point and that was the temp inside the place. Imagine being served hot and heavy Italian food and eating it at that temperature. It's not easy and we ended up taking a lot of our food home. By the time we left, our faces were flushed, and we were so hot from sitting there in the heat. Even the carafes of ice water on the tables melted and the water was room temperature. If the restaurant reads this, you guys need better A/C. You can't expect people to sit and eat your food in that heat. If you're in the area and want to eat here, order the food to go.

I walked into rosemaries with high expectations from hearing amazing things about the food and decided to give it a try; I was greeted with two very mature gentleman named John and Cade behind the counter; they both helped me decide what slices to get as well as inform me on what pizza is what. Both of them were very mature, helpful and great. I suggest asking for them if you’re stopping by. I ended up getting 3 slices and they were delicious! I would suggest they add a pickle and pepperoni pizza. I will be a long lasting customer ?????????

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken Pizza

Great pizza with a great staff. This place has been here for as long as I live here, and the food as the pizza is always good. Today, we only had the pizza , we ordered a regular and a grandma pie, they didn't disappoint. BTW, I have lived around here for over 35 years.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Grandma’S Pizza, Alla Vodka Sausage and Bacon Chicken Ranch Slices Spinach Roll w Side of Sauce

We've been there before and we love this place, however last night the main course and the dessert were not up to their usual standards. We will be back. ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Personal pizza is a good deal at 10 dollars.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This is what had arrived after we had waited over 1 hour for our pizza to be told by the manager that one of her employees took home our food so this was my replacement. Never ordering from here again very unprofessional.

Best pizza in Farmingdale by far! Great lunch specials, great prices, great service, and staff. Don’t think about it, just go!!! Pizza maker Mani has been here forever, everything is consistent.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Chicken Parmigiana, Pepperoni Bites & Calzone, Grandma Pizza, Meatballs

Pizza was excellent however Thursday is chicken night and chicken was overcooked and very dry. Service was also very slow took over 45 minutes to get main course. Rosemarie’s used to be my favorite restaurant hope they can get back on track

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Sicilian Pizza

Been going here for years, such a classic spot in the neighborhood

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Severely overpriced and quality has taken a dive since ownership has changed hands. Rosemaries was at its prime when Nunzio and his fam ran it. Back when Superstar Video was their neighbor.

Great pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Parking: Parking lot isn't that big, so it gets difficult to park. 8/10 times, you will find a parking spot.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 4

Our retirement party for one of our employees at our Massapequa Highway Department was for 60 people.
For other employees that had retirement parties, I was not in charge of the food.
This time I was, and I knew that I wanted restaurant food. I've been to Rosemarie's many times and went there to discuss catering.
Gianna and I sat down at a quiet table in the middle room and looked over what I had picked out.
She had her paperwork with her and amazing knowledge of the catering business. After two sentences, I knew that I should sit back and just listen.
She really did know what I needed after just a few questions that I answered.
If this was just about price, then I would say they gave me the greatest deal imaginable.
It was about the food, the amount of food, the on time delivery. Everything that I asked, she said, "we supply that".
My plan was to go shopping for other things like water, soda, a six-foot hero to add to the hot food, and much more.
Gianna said, we have all that.
On the day of the party, one week later, tons of food came in all by the recommendations of Gianna and also by the generosity of her boss. Yes, I got a fantastic deal.
My only job was to buy ice.
The party was a blast, the food was more than ample, Gianna's suggestions were right on target, so, I really did nothing, it was all Rosemarie's!
Thank you, Thank you!
There is no other place that I will go to for catering and no other place I would recommend except for Rosemarie's Restaurant.
10 Stars!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I spotted in today because I was randomly in the area and I have to say you don’t get service like this anymore ! The girl that was at the front I wish I knew her name because she was beyond friendly and helpful so sweet to my son she even helped me bring everything to the car ! The Food was amazing , you most try there Spinach slice ! Amazing !! My fiancé loved the personal pie Chicken parm and my son ate up all the zeppoles the you girl gave him lol You don’t get service like this anymore !