Top of the Bay

Name: Top of the Bay
Address: 159 Dock Walk, Fire Island, New York, 11782, US
Telephone: (631) 597-6028
Price range: $$
Rating: 4.3

$$$ • Bistros

Hours:
159 Dock Walk, Cherry Grove
(631) 597-6028

About Top of the Bay

Top of the Bay is a restaurant that provides an elegant dining experience with a stunning view of the bay. The drinks, such as the Blue Cheese Martini and Spicy Mezcal Margarita, are praised for their delicious taste. The appetizers, including the ceviche special, margarita flatbread, and mussels marine, are highly recommended for their wonderful flavor and presentation. The entrees, such as the braised short ribs, Eggplant Parmigiano, and branzino, are cooked to perfection and described as fresh and delicious. The bone-in steak with lobster Mac and cheese has also received positive remarks. The sautéed spinach is noted as the best ever tasted. The restaurant is commended for excellent service, with staff treating customers like royalty and accommodating dietary restrictions. The ambiance is a fantastic mix of upscale and friendly, making it a wonderful spot to end a beach day. The crab cakes are a standout dish, and there are many gluten-free options available on the menu. The restaurant is considered one of the best meals reviewers have ever had, and they eagerly plan to return. For the best experience, it is recommended to book a table in advance, especially for window seating.