Top of the Bay
159 Dock Walk, Cherry Grove
(631) 597-6028
Customers' Favorites
The Meat Rack
Onion Soup
Scallops
Menu
Photos
+30 photos
+29 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Prices were pretty crazy but that is to be expected in fire island. Not all tables have great views of the bay. We reserved well in advance and were placed at a cramped table that didn’t have a great view. The food was good but nothing amazing considering the prices. It was nice having a “fancy” dinner while staying at Fire Island. It was a nice dinner but be prepared to spend over 100 dollars a person if you want drinks, app and such. Service was ok but definitely started...
Environment and staff maintained a fantastic vibe mixed with upscale and yet still friendly. Got the bone in steak with the lobster Mac and cheese and a bottle of rose. Bar tender Robbie was an awesome bar tender with great recommendations and conversations as well.
We had the most delicious Eggplant Parmigiano and Short Ribs.I truly loved the chicken . The sautéed Spinach was the best I ever tasted. Staff treats you like a king .Can not wait to go back .
You May Also Like
Island Breeze - 247 Bayview Walk
![]()
American, Seafood, Vegetarian
Cherry's On The Bay - 158 Bayview Walk
![]()
Gay Bar, Cocktail Bar
Floyd's - 156 Bayview Walk
![]()
Breakfast, American, Vegetarian