Had the special tonight- crab cake sandwich & salad. It was delicious! I would definitely order it again. The house salad dressing never disappoints- yum!
Anthony Palermo
Excellent local casual restaurant. We’ve only been here twice in the past five years, mostly recently March 2024. This past visit we had the steak cafe salad, which was delicious. We also split the garlic bread, which was a very smart inventive take on it, cubing the pieces which made it much more enjoyable of a bite rather than ripping apart or gnawing away at a big loaf. Service was friendly and timely. Cute place and nice atmosphere. Nicely located by the restaurants and shops.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Paul Cannon
Great experience for our first visit to the Tomato Cafe! We enjoyed our dinner and the customer service was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kristina M.
Super cute restaurant, nice staff, decent food. Not the best food around but a nice quaint place to eat. The drunken pasta was great, burger was decent, definitely good pesto (can taste the pine nuts), cheese steak was decent and the last pasta was a little dry. However, I WOULD try this place again!
Keith Barbee
Quite a variety in the menu, and I was impressed with the gluten free pasta options. I ordered the Chicken Sandoval and it was great. I would definitely recommend.Dietary restrictions: Good gluten free pasta options!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
BeauTiFFul
They deliver cold nasty food they should be ashamed of themselves . They should be called rotten tomato.
Kyle (KCL93)
Had a margarita pizza the other day. Easily the best pizza in fishkill!. Thin, crispy, tangy sauce, fresh cheese. It was like an 8.2 pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Rolando Jaimez
Ate here with some friends. The food is good and so are the portions. The service was friendly. It wasn't busy the evening we were here. It's nice and casual. Easy place to catch up with
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jacquelyn S.
THE TOMATO CAFE - Fishkill, NY I've been waiting to eat at this establishment. In the past I ended up going to the Greek restaurant and the German restaurant that are literally a few walking feet away on the same side of the block, mostly because the Tomatoe Cafe closes at 3pm on sundays. But, arrive in time as it is worth going for lunch!!!! The menu was WONDERFUL! Many delicious choices with options that are vegetarian friendly! Most importantly, the food is delicious and FRESH! First off, beverages were ordered. As usual my sweetheart ordered green tea with lemon and honey. I ordered coffee with half and half and Splenda. The coffee was watery. ( I guess I prefer strong coffee and will select a different option next time. The wait staff/ waiters and staff whip around the place with energy and enthusiasm! The young man that welcomed us at the front door was so friendly and welcoming! It was very very nice to receive such a warm welcome. The front counter display is wonderfully full of desserts, pecan crusted honey buns, cream cheese iced carrot cake, cheesecake and more. What an amazing sight. I knew I wanted dessert just from seeing that case! At the counter is a also container of m&m's for visitors to take a scoop when at the counter. How awesome is that! I could see all of this from where our table was. (See pic) The tables and atmosphere overall is country kitchen meets picnic table church pews. It is country cozy. I kinda was transported to my "Big mom" (grandmother) kitchen nook. Sunday the place closes at 3pm and people came in up until that time, with one group coming in after 3pm but were turned away. The food is freshly prepared so I do understand. People, arrive before 3pm!!! So the food... I ordered grilled cheese on wheat sourdough with salad, and my sweetheart ordered cheesesteak sandwich and fries. I had wanted the quesadillas on the special but it was sold out. The crispy fries that came with my sweethearts meal were so good I almost ordered my own because they were super delicious! The side salad of fresh greens was very fresh!! And the croutons were homemade with rye bread. I so LOVED the grill cheese sandwich. I selected wheat sourdough and it was scrumptious! This bread is extraordinary. So overall, food=9.5, atmosphere 7.5, beverages 6.5, service greeted enthusiastically so greet gets a 10, and waiter was attentive but with one part snarky so he gets an 8. Food arrived on a timely manner which was awesome. Although my first choice of Barria quesadillas was sold out , my second choice was very good. I recommend and will go back for more grilled cheese sandwiches and to try other options also. Oh yes, the food is moderately priced and affordable. This place is great! Thank you to the tomato cafe for a great affordable and fresh meal!
Jim “Jimbo” Carroll
My food wasn't a gee wiz wow. The gals(3), seemed pretty happy. Except eggplant in salad (under cooked). I had baked ziti, cheese w little red sauce. No mocktails. Disappointed. Staff was great.First all male staff restaurant. Interesting. I would not do back. For the price of meals I did not feel it was a value. There are many others.
The place is small and they have too many chairs. Other than space, the place is good and so was the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Mastromarino
Great food and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Soup, Bruschetta of the Day, Chicken Marsala
Chris Wright
Very nice place. Excellent food. Even a lesson on the "trap door"
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fishkill Cheesesteak
Owhite 2012
This is our go-to casual restaurant for a quick tasty
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Willie V
From out of town looking for a place to eat and this place popped up for good ratings. Ordered a Calzone thinking to would be good. It looked stunning, but very cold in the middle. I have not had one in a long while, so I google it to make sure it was supposed to be at least warm in the middle. Flagged down a wait or to let them know, they took it and I think nuked it. After they brought it back I paid my bill and left over half of it on the plate. Like it said, it looked like a million bucks, to bad it was cold.
Had the special tonight- crab cake sandwich & salad. It was delicious! I would definitely order it again. The house salad dressing never disappoints- yum!
Excellent local casual restaurant. We’ve only been here twice in the past five years, mostly recently March 2024. This past visit we had the steak cafe salad, which was delicious. We also split the garlic bread, which was a very smart inventive take on it, cubing the pieces which made it much more enjoyable of a bite rather than ripping apart or gnawing away at a big loaf. Service was friendly and timely. Cute place and nice atmosphere. Nicely located by the restaurants and shops.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great experience for our first visit to the Tomato Cafe! We enjoyed our dinner and the customer service was good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Super cute restaurant, nice staff, decent food. Not the best food around but a nice quaint place to eat. The drunken pasta was great, burger was decent, definitely good pesto (can taste the pine nuts), cheese steak was decent and the last pasta was a little dry. However, I WOULD try this place again!
Quite a variety in the menu, and I was impressed with the gluten free pasta options. I ordered the Chicken Sandoval and it was great. I would definitely recommend.Dietary restrictions: Good gluten free pasta options!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
They deliver cold nasty food they should be ashamed of themselves . They should be called rotten tomato.
Had a margarita pizza the other day. Easily the best pizza in fishkill!. Thin, crispy, tangy sauce, fresh cheese. It was like an 8.2 pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ate here with some friends. The food is good and so are the portions. The service was friendly. It wasn't busy the evening we were here. It's nice and casual. Easy place to catch up with
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
THE TOMATO CAFE - Fishkill, NY I've been waiting to eat at this establishment. In the past I ended up going to the Greek restaurant and the German restaurant that are literally a few walking feet away on the same side of the block, mostly because the Tomatoe Cafe closes at 3pm on sundays. But, arrive in time as it is worth going for lunch!!!! The menu was WONDERFUL! Many delicious choices with options that are vegetarian friendly! Most importantly, the food is delicious and FRESH! First off, beverages were ordered. As usual my sweetheart ordered green tea with lemon and honey. I ordered coffee with half and half and Splenda. The coffee was watery. ( I guess I prefer strong coffee and will select a different option next time. The wait staff/ waiters and staff whip around the place with energy and enthusiasm! The young man that welcomed us at the front door was so friendly and welcoming! It was very very nice to receive such a warm welcome. The front counter display is wonderfully full of desserts, pecan crusted honey buns, cream cheese iced carrot cake, cheesecake and more. What an amazing sight. I knew I wanted dessert just from seeing that case! At the counter is a also container of m&m's for visitors to take a scoop when at the counter. How awesome is that! I could see all of this from where our table was. (See pic) The tables and atmosphere overall is country kitchen meets picnic table church pews. It is country cozy. I kinda was transported to my "Big mom" (grandmother) kitchen nook. Sunday the place closes at 3pm and people came in up until that time, with one group coming in after 3pm but were turned away. The food is freshly prepared so I do understand. People, arrive before 3pm!!! So the food... I ordered grilled cheese on wheat sourdough with salad, and my sweetheart ordered cheesesteak sandwich and fries. I had wanted the quesadillas on the special but it was sold out. The crispy fries that came with my sweethearts meal were so good I almost ordered my own because they were super delicious! The side salad of fresh greens was very fresh!! And the croutons were homemade with rye bread. I so LOVED the grill cheese sandwich. I selected wheat sourdough and it was scrumptious! This bread is extraordinary. So overall, food=9.5, atmosphere 7.5, beverages 6.5, service greeted enthusiastically so greet gets a 10, and waiter was attentive but with one part snarky so he gets an 8. Food arrived on a timely manner which was awesome. Although my first choice of Barria quesadillas was sold out , my second choice was very good. I recommend and will go back for more grilled cheese sandwiches and to try other options also. Oh yes, the food is moderately priced and affordable. This place is great! Thank you to the tomato cafe for a great affordable and fresh meal!
My food wasn't a gee wiz wow. The gals(3), seemed pretty happy. Except eggplant in salad (under cooked). I had baked ziti, cheese w little red sauce. No mocktails. Disappointed. Staff was great.First all male staff restaurant. Interesting. I would not do back. For the price of meals I did not feel it was a value. There are many others.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
The place is small and they have too many chairs. Other than space, the place is good and so was the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great food and great
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Soup, Bruschetta of the Day, Chicken Marsala
Very nice place. Excellent food. Even a lesson on the "trap door"
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fishkill Cheesesteak
This is our go-to casual restaurant for a quick tasty
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
From out of town looking for a place to eat and this place popped up for good ratings. Ordered a Calzone thinking to would be good. It looked stunning, but very cold in the middle. I have not had one in a long while, so I google it to make sure it was supposed to be at least warm in the middle. Flagged down a wait or to let them know, they took it and I think nuked it. After they brought it back I paid my bill and left over half of it on the plate. Like it said, it looked like a million bucks, to bad it was cold.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 3