Elaine is the best bartender! She makes amazing drinks with a drink appropriate pour. She is the reason we continue to go here. She is skilled, personable and passionate about her job! If you go … sit at the bar and ask for Elaine!
Evelyn Cuevas
Absolutely delicious everything we ordered was beyond my expectations. When I come to this restaurant it’s like I take a trip to Positano Italy ❤️ the service is amazing. Our favorite restaurant.
Amanda Gunning
Really enjoyed our dinner here tonight! The steak was excellent and the eggplant parm was super fresh. The ambiance was fun and classy. I have never been here before but i would definitely go back! We were welcomed in and sat promptly. The staff was very attentive.
Susan Kelly
Elaine is the best bartender! Her drinks are out of this world! She is personable and attentive. She is the reason we keep coming back !
Michael Berkowitz
Lovely space. Disorganized service. Margherita pizza arrived a half hour after our salad. No basil. Soggy crust. Bland sauce. Most boring and unmemorable pizza of all time. Maybe it was a bad night but these same issues appear in other reviews.
Michael Gentile
Modest atmosphere made up for by quality of food and drink. Not a vast menu but adequate. Suggest couples share an appetizer and an entree.
Vivian Groman
The food was fantastic. The service was so good. Fresh cannolis to die for!
Jessica Anne
My husband and I just left. We arrived a little past 6pm. We don’t see a servers for the first 20 mins. Then we were able to order drinks which took another 40. We had three tables arrive after us and all 3 finished before our entree was finally delivered. My husband’s dinner was delivered under cooked. Medium well was served slightly medium. In over 2 hours we left hungry and annoyed. The manager or owner didn’t bother stopping by when we voiced our frustration and complaint. We had a party of 20 here a few weeks ago and we were all served and done in the same time. Not sure what’s going on but we will not be returning. Overall upsetting and disappointing.
J P
If you come with more than 4 people I’m not sure this is the place for you. 1.5 hours later and after people in my party put in the order food showed up. There was literally nobody else in the restaurant. Not recommended
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
Kathryn Choinski
We went in to AMA expecting a pizzaria but instead found a beautiful Italian restaurant. They use fresh ingredients to create the most amazing dishes. Our server Libby is a fantastic ambassador for the restaurant - enthusiastic & knowledgable about the menu and ingredients they use. We ordered everything she recommended - eggplant parmesan appetizer, Caesar salad, pesto & burrata pizza and the figura pizza. Every first bite was an "eyes roll back in your head" moment. We took the chocolate mousse cake home for dessert - absolutely delicious. Luckily we have leftovers of everthing to enjoy again! In addition to incredible food, the service was spot on. Libby was attentive and the hostess, Shay, checked in as well. It was a great experience all around. My husband and I are self proclaimed food snobs and we were very impressed. We are looking forward to returning to AMA with friends and trying out some of their other dishes. Everything about AMA is fantastic - atmosphere, service, and incredibly delicious food.
Inventive dishes done well. The service staff was very attentive but not pushy or smothering. The atmosphere was open and modern and the music was perfect. Makes me wish I lived closer so I could become a regular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
John Garrett
We had an amazing time! The food was outstanding, and the service was top-notch. Our hostess was professional and kind. Special shoutout to our waiter, Robert, who was a true gentleman and made our evening perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cacio E Pepe, Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Pizza
Ted Bailey
I love this place, it has an NYC feel without the high prices. Their pizzas and meals are amazing, the service is always good and they have a delicious lava cake for dessert. Why wait in line for mediocre food when you can come here and have delicious food and great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Diana Haight
Chey our hostess with the mostess was amazing! Highly recommend coming when she is on!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
Gerald Espinosa
This is a beautiful restaurant located of the Fishkill/Wapoingers border. You feel like you are in NYC and the service is always terrific, the bread is fantastic and they have one of the best pizzas in the area. For salmon fans they are really great too. Actually everything they make there is delicious. Weeknights are generally not so busy so that's when we prefer to go. They have some nice desserts too, but the entrees are what keeps us coming back. We are excited to try their Sunday brunch too. Definitely give this place a try, it's rare these days to find an affordable, high quality restaurant on Route 9.
Elaine is the best bartender! She makes amazing drinks with a drink appropriate pour. She is the reason we continue to go here. She is skilled, personable and passionate about her job! If you go … sit at the bar and ask for Elaine!
Absolutely delicious everything we ordered was beyond my expectations. When I come to this restaurant it’s like I take a trip to Positano Italy ❤️ the service is amazing. Our favorite restaurant.
Really enjoyed our dinner here tonight! The steak was excellent and the eggplant parm was super fresh. The ambiance was fun and classy. I have never been here before but i would definitely go back! We were welcomed in and sat promptly. The staff was very attentive.
Elaine is the best bartender! Her drinks are out of this world! She is personable and attentive. She is the reason we keep coming back !
Lovely space. Disorganized service. Margherita pizza arrived a half hour after our salad. No basil. Soggy crust. Bland sauce. Most boring and unmemorable pizza of all time. Maybe it was a bad night but these same issues appear in other reviews.
Modest atmosphere made up for by quality of food and drink. Not a vast menu but adequate. Suggest couples share an appetizer and an entree.
The food was fantastic. The service was so good. Fresh cannolis to die for!
My husband and I just left. We arrived a little past 6pm. We don’t see a servers for the first 20 mins. Then we were able to order drinks which took another 40. We had three tables arrive after us and all 3 finished before our entree was finally delivered. My husband’s dinner was delivered under cooked. Medium well was served slightly medium. In over 2 hours we left hungry and annoyed. The manager or owner didn’t bother stopping by when we voiced our frustration and complaint. We had a party of 20 here a few weeks ago and we were all served and done in the same time. Not sure what’s going on but we will not be returning. Overall upsetting and disappointing.
If you come with more than 4 people I’m not sure this is the place for you. 1.5 hours later and after people in my party put in the order food showed up. There was literally nobody else in the restaurant. Not recommended
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 1
We went in to AMA expecting a pizzaria but instead found a beautiful Italian restaurant. They use fresh ingredients to create the most amazing dishes. Our server Libby is a fantastic ambassador for the restaurant - enthusiastic & knowledgable about the menu and ingredients they use. We ordered everything she recommended - eggplant parmesan appetizer, Caesar salad, pesto & burrata pizza and the figura pizza. Every first bite was an "eyes roll back in your head" moment. We took the chocolate mousse cake home for dessert - absolutely delicious. Luckily we have leftovers of everthing to enjoy again! In addition to incredible food, the service was spot on. Libby was attentive and the hostess, Shay, checked in as well. It was a great experience all around. My husband and I are self proclaimed food snobs and we were very impressed. We are looking forward to returning to AMA with friends and trying out some of their other dishes. Everything about AMA is fantastic - atmosphere, service, and incredibly delicious food.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Inventive dishes done well. The service staff was very attentive but not pushy or smothering. The atmosphere was open and modern and the music was perfect. Makes me wish I lived closer so I could become a regular.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We had an amazing time! The food was outstanding, and the service was top-notch. Our hostess was professional and kind. Special shoutout to our waiter, Robert, who was a true gentleman and made our evening perfect.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cacio E Pepe, Sausage and Broccoli Rabe Pizza
I love this place, it has an NYC feel without the high prices. Their pizzas and meals are amazing, the service is always good and they have a delicious lava cake for dessert. Why wait in line for mediocre food when you can come here and have delicious food and great service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chey our hostess with the mostess was amazing! Highly recommend coming when she is on!!
Atmosphere: 5
Service: 5
This is a beautiful restaurant located of the Fishkill/Wapoingers border. You feel like you are in NYC and the service is always terrific, the bread is fantastic and they have one of the best pizzas in the area. For salmon fans they are really great too. Actually everything they make there is delicious. Weeknights are generally not so busy so that's when we prefer to go. They have some nice desserts too, but the entrees are what keeps us coming back. We are excited to try their Sunday brunch too. Definitely give this place a try, it's rare these days to find an affordable, high quality restaurant on Route 9.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...