Great local spot. Beautiful inside with lots of wood. Small menu but done well. Pours a good pint of Guinness, what else could you ask for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steve Thalheimer
Classic neighborhood bar. Friendly, cozy, awesome deviled eggs, burgers and fries. Great cocktails. Super nice staff. Will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jay Singh
Great place for a casual drink. Food was good too, although I wish the caesar salad was easier to eat and actually blended in rather than a mountain of leaves.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Anne Marie Boyle-Clelland
Our bartender Andy was above and beyond amazing..great food, drink and craic was 90.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Burger
Ameer Blake
Kind service, lovely atmosphere and not expensive at all. Good quality outing in NYC that doesn't break the bank... practically an endangered species. You won't regret coming by.Especially for happy hour!
Amanda Onorato
As a bartender, i have a very low bar for service. I'll wait, i'll deal with delays, and i'll never complain. The circumstances tonight would've called for bad service and the bartender did AMAZING. People were causing problems and breaking glasses( which he cleaned and handled promptly)....seriously i have never seen a bartender as great as Mark. He had to deal with the worst people all night, but i never had to wait for a drink, a smile, or even a water !!! One of the greatest bars on skillman and amazing staff.
lize van looy
Would definitely recommend. Very cool atmosphere, great cocktails and burger. Very kind bartender as well.
Greg Pasternack
Great food! The fried items (onion rings, fried cauliflower, French fries) were all prepared wonderfully with the perfect crunch on the outside with the full taste and texture of whatever was inside. Too many places fry things to the point of being overly crunchy/hard or excessively oily and thankfully PJ Horgan's does not do that at all. Highly recommend.
Jillian Paige
Loved the happy hour drinks! We started dancing though, and they said “Please stop.” So just know that if you’re here to drink: party on. If you’re here to dance: move on.
Kalindra Chowdhury
My first time experience coming here on yesterday Sunday for dinner was great. I came here with my dad to have a father & son bonding over dinner. What I enjoyed about this Irish American pub is the atmosphere and menu. It feels historic, rustic, and casual without being too fancy. Definitely a must try place if you want to relax outdoors with your family and friends.
They make the best damn boulevardier I’ve ever had. Jeez.
Kathy Kertesz Marsh
Great atmosphere and made me feel at home. Really enjoyed the food.
P Vac
Loved the Ceasar salad with grilled salmon!!!
Paola Vaca
Loved the Ceasar salad with grilled salmon!!!
Bella Jamie
We happened to stumble at this place the other day and had food and drinks and it was all just great! The food was insanely good, the bartender (blond girl, can’t remember her name), was so so sweet and professional. Cannot recommend enough!
Great local spot. Beautiful inside with lots of wood. Small menu but done well. Pours a good pint of Guinness, what else could you ask for.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Classic neighborhood bar. Friendly, cozy, awesome deviled eggs, burgers and fries. Great cocktails. Super nice staff. Will go back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great place for a casual drink. Food was good too, although I wish the caesar salad was easier to eat and actually blended in rather than a mountain of leaves.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Our bartender Andy was above and beyond amazing..great food, drink and craic was 90.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Steak Burger
Kind service, lovely atmosphere and not expensive at all. Good quality outing in NYC that doesn't break the bank... practically an endangered species. You won't regret coming by.Especially for happy hour!
As a bartender, i have a very low bar for service. I'll wait, i'll deal with delays, and i'll never complain. The circumstances tonight would've called for bad service and the bartender did AMAZING. People were causing problems and breaking glasses( which he cleaned and handled promptly)....seriously i have never seen a bartender as great as Mark. He had to deal with the worst people all night, but i never had to wait for a drink, a smile, or even a water !!! One of the greatest bars on skillman and amazing staff.
Would definitely recommend. Very cool atmosphere, great cocktails and burger. Very kind bartender as well.
Great food! The fried items (onion rings, fried cauliflower, French fries) were all prepared wonderfully with the perfect crunch on the outside with the full taste and texture of whatever was inside. Too many places fry things to the point of being overly crunchy/hard or excessively oily and thankfully PJ Horgan's does not do that at all. Highly recommend.
Loved the happy hour drinks! We started dancing though, and they said “Please stop.” So just know that if you’re here to drink: party on. If you’re here to dance: move on.
My first time experience coming here on yesterday Sunday for dinner was great. I came here with my dad to have a father & son bonding over dinner. What I enjoyed about this Irish American pub is the atmosphere and menu. It feels historic, rustic, and casual without being too fancy. Definitely a must try place if you want to relax outdoors with your family and friends.
Restaurantji Recommends
They make the best damn boulevardier I’ve ever had. Jeez.
Great atmosphere and made me feel at home. Really enjoyed the food.
Loved the Ceasar salad with grilled salmon!!!
Loved the Ceasar salad with grilled salmon!!!
We happened to stumble at this place the other day and had food and drinks and it was all just great! The food was insanely good, the bartender (blond girl, can’t remember her name), was so so sweet and professional. Cannot recommend enough!
Loading...