10 out of 10 I do recommend! This pizza is literally the best pizza I ever had in my entire existence!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata
winepusher
Honestly the best pizza in NY! Also their side dishes are different yet excellent!! I e considered buying a house close to them just to have the option of eating there when I want!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Claudia Lang
Very expensive Pizza. the ingredients are very fresh. you need to sit outside clean up after yourself. big sign saying no changes or substitutions to any item. the staff expects to be tipped for handing you a pizza and cleaning up after yourself. real city attitude.
Duvin Roman
A well built machine. The food is delicious. A nice variety of flavors on the menu. Great service, everyone was happy to be there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jerry Squillante
Incredible. Just go. Kind of the Soup Nazi vibe so don't be offended. Some if rhe best pizza you will ever eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita, 4 Cheese, Farm Stand Salad, Hot Sopressata Pizza
Gaia Moisan
Favorite place ever yum
Stephanie Russell-Ladd
Amazing pizza and salad!!!! Amazing staff!! Amazing owner!!! And we loved the atmosphere and music!!!! Thank you!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Scott Ellsworth
If you’re a fan of thin, crispy, brick oven pizza made with real-deal ingredients and a whole lot of love, this place is an absolute must. Tucked away with a charming, laid-back outdoor vibe, it feels like the kind of spot you’d stumble across in a little Italian village—but lucky for us, it’s right here in town.
The crust is something to write home about—paper-thin but still full of flavor, with just the right balance of chew and crisp. Cooked to perfection in a real brick oven, every slice has those beautifully blistered edges and that subtle smokiness you can only get from the real thing.
And the ingredients? Top-notch. From the tangy, vibrant tomato sauce to the creamy mozzarella and thoughtfully sourced toppings (hello, fresh basil, spicy soppressata, roasted mushrooms, and more), you can tell everything is fresh, high-quality, and chosen with intention. Even the simplest margherita tastes like something elevated. It’s pizza for people who really love pizza.
But what makes this place even more special is the vibe. The outdoor seating area is cozy and inviting—string lights overhead, local artwork or rustic touches scattered throughout, maybe a few herb planters nearby. It’s the kind of setting where you can sip a glass of wine or a local beer, enjoy great conversation, and let the evening stretch out. There’s often a mix of locals catching up with friends, families enjoying a relaxed dinner, and couples sharing a pie under the stars. It feels authentic, like a real neighborhood hangout rather than some trendy place trying too hard.
The staff are warm and attentive, and there’s clearly a lot of pride in what they’re doing. It’s not fast food—it’s food made with care, and it’s worth every second of the wait.
Whether you’re a local looking for a new go-to or just passing through and craving an exceptional slice, this is one of those rare pizza places that gets everything right. Delicious, cozy, and full of character. What more could you want?
Do yourself a favor and grab a table. You’ll be back before you know it.
Robin Stephens
This pizzeria makes fresh perfectly crunchy perfectly doughy crust in an artisanal way with pride. Delicious!! The manager said he has a special menu every day! The music was fun, the staff were fun, and the pizza was really special. In addition they were so, so lovely to us when we turned up hungry after they turned off the oven, what a lovely place for a picnic!! Thanks guys!!
First, the pizza. 10/10 - wood fired, local ingredients, thin crust. It’s Croatian style pizza, not NYC style, don’t get those 2 confused. Our favorite was the funghi pizza which has a white sauce and a little pesto, everything was amazing. Don’t forget to order the bread sticks with trout dip (insanely good), the homemade pink lemonade (yup), and the chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches for dessert. Sit outside on one of the many picnic tables and enjoy the music playing over the speakers. Then rejoice when they call your name through the pizza window and hand you a stack of pies from right out the oven. We LOVED it here! Will definitely be coming back.
Todd Floyd
Epic pizza and great outdoor seating. Owner and his staff are all awesome. We tried three different types and they were all awesome. Also try the smoked trout dip for pizza crust appetizer and finish with amazing ice cream cookies! By far the best pizza!
Jonas Murphy
10/10 pizza and people
Victoria
Yes, weird experience. But you came for the pizza, and it's insanely good. And they are right - Eat it on the spot.
Patrick Forman
Wow. These folks are doing something magical in this tiny place. The Bianca pizza was like something I’ve never had before, exceptional.
10 out of 10 I do recommend! This pizza is literally the best pizza I ever had in my entire existence!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Burrata
Honestly the best pizza in NY! Also their side dishes are different yet excellent!! I e considered buying a house close to them just to have the option of eating there when I want!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very expensive Pizza. the ingredients are very fresh. you need to sit outside clean up after yourself. big sign saying no changes or substitutions to any item. the staff expects to be tipped for handing you a pizza and cleaning up after yourself. real city attitude.
A well built machine. The food is delicious. A nice variety of flavors on the menu. Great service, everyone was happy to be there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible. Just go. Kind of the Soup Nazi vibe so don't be offended. Some if rhe best pizza you will ever eat.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Margherita, 4 Cheese, Farm Stand Salad, Hot Sopressata Pizza
Favorite place ever yum
Amazing pizza and salad!!!! Amazing staff!! Amazing owner!!! And we loved the atmosphere and music!!!! Thank you!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
If you’re a fan of thin, crispy, brick oven pizza made with real-deal ingredients and a whole lot of love, this place is an absolute must. Tucked away with a charming, laid-back outdoor vibe, it feels like the kind of spot you’d stumble across in a little Italian village—but lucky for us, it’s right here in town.
The crust is something to write home about—paper-thin but still full of flavor, with just the right balance of chew and crisp. Cooked to perfection in a real brick oven, every slice has those beautifully blistered edges and that subtle smokiness you can only get from the real thing.
And the ingredients? Top-notch. From the tangy, vibrant tomato sauce to the creamy mozzarella and thoughtfully sourced toppings (hello, fresh basil, spicy soppressata, roasted mushrooms, and more), you can tell everything is fresh, high-quality, and chosen with intention. Even the simplest margherita tastes like something elevated. It’s pizza for people who really love pizza.
But what makes this place even more special is the vibe. The outdoor seating area is cozy and inviting—string lights overhead, local artwork or rustic touches scattered throughout, maybe a few herb planters nearby. It’s the kind of setting where you can sip a glass of wine or a local beer, enjoy great conversation, and let the evening stretch out. There’s often a mix of locals catching up with friends, families enjoying a relaxed dinner, and couples sharing a pie under the stars. It feels authentic, like a real neighborhood hangout rather than some trendy place trying too hard.
The staff are warm and attentive, and there’s clearly a lot of pride in what they’re doing. It’s not fast food—it’s food made with care, and it’s worth every second of the wait.
Whether you’re a local looking for a new go-to or just passing through and craving an exceptional slice, this is one of those rare pizza places that gets everything right. Delicious, cozy, and full of character. What more could you want?
Do yourself a favor and grab a table. You’ll be back before you know it.
This pizzeria makes fresh perfectly crunchy perfectly doughy crust in an artisanal way with pride. Delicious!! The manager said he has a special menu every day! The music was fun, the staff were fun, and the pizza was really special. In addition they were so, so lovely to us when we turned up hungry after they turned off the oven, what a lovely place for a picnic!! Thanks guys!!
10/10 za and hospitality
Restaurantji Recommends
First, the pizza. 10/10 - wood fired, local ingredients, thin crust. It’s Croatian style pizza, not NYC style, don’t get those 2 confused. Our favorite was the funghi pizza which has a white sauce and a little pesto, everything was amazing. Don’t forget to order the bread sticks with trout dip (insanely good), the homemade pink lemonade (yup), and the chocolate chip cookie ice cream sandwiches for dessert. Sit outside on one of the many picnic tables and enjoy the music playing over the speakers. Then rejoice when they call your name through the pizza window and hand you a stack of pies from right out the oven. We LOVED it here! Will definitely be coming back.
Epic pizza and great outdoor seating. Owner and his staff are all awesome. We tried three different types and they were all awesome. Also try the smoked trout dip for pizza crust appetizer and finish with amazing ice cream cookies! By far the best pizza!
10/10 pizza and people
Yes, weird experience. But you came for the pizza, and it's insanely good. And they are right - Eat it on the spot.
Wow. These folks are doing something magical in this tiny place. The Bianca pizza was like something I’ve never had before, exceptional.
Loading...