Bear Mountain Pizza

840 Rte 9W, Fort Montgomery
(845) 977-8015

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Mukta Begum

Cheese pizza was good, veggies found it bit unsalty

Jonathon Stevens

Absolutely amazeballs! Will suggest this to anyone who wants some astoundingly delicious food. My mouth is salivating with just the thought of having another taste of the marinara sauce!

Gopa Sheppillayar

It’s a hidden gem in the middle of nowhere.
Good food and great service, will visit again next time.

Adriana

Love the food we ate pasta and pizza slices and everything was super yummy

Angelina Erkina

Honestly, I didn’t like this place at all. There’s a musty, old smell near the entrance — like walking into a dusty attic. The automated ordering system might seem convenient, but the staff is incredibly slow and disorganized. Not all menu items are actually available, which you only find out after placing your order.

I ordered a Caesar pizza, and it was honestly a joke — just a Margherita with a handful of Caesar salad tossed on top. On top of that, they brought out the pizza before the drinks, and it turned out my drink wasn’t even available. The staff didn’t know how to process a refund, so I was told I’d either lose my money or have to pick something else instead.

This place is a mess. If you’re looking for a quick, smooth experience — or even just basic service — look elsewhere. I definitely won’t be coming back.

Marc Cusumano

Amazing pizza!

Ericka Morris

A cute little place for lunch,great food service. Had the cheese ravioli .Husband had sausage peppers it was fanominal. Everything was delicious,service was great . We will go back. Just a wonderful experience.

HEATHER Kupiec

By far the worst we have been to in awhile. An over all deli, paid 15$ for a sandwich that I could get a subway from 8$. It was called the mambo italiano, had 2 slices of salami 2 slices of ham, never had the freah mozz or red peppers that it was supposed to have. Completely pathetic. My husband ordered a meatball parm that had 3 meatballs cut in half and they called it a hero and cost 16$. You have to order from a kiosk if your paying with a card, if your paying cash you have to order from a woman who doesn't understand or even enter the order correctly. I asked for hot peppers she gave me green bell peppers, I asked for mayo , no mayo. In retrospect the entire experience sucked from start to finish. Needless to say we won't be back ever!

Elizabeth Miller

Picked up wings and pizza for the night. The wings were great. Nice sized, flavorful, great tasting. The pizza unfortunately was not as good. I ordered a godfather (pepperoni, sausage, beef, bacon, onions, green peppers, mushroom, etc.)…. And I got a totally different pizza, with gyro meat and red peppers. ?? Not what I ordered. And not a good tasting pizza. I hate red peppers. Could not eat it. Wish I had checked it before I left the restaurant. 😕

Joe Oberbroeckling

They helped host the Marquette ROTC Ranger team while competing at Sandhurst. They did a fantastic job making a lot of pizzas for many hungry cadets. Highly recommend.

Jaime Lillis

We stopped in today for a quick bite and it was the best meal we have had in awhile! Fresh pasta and delicious meat sauce. Homemade food at its finest!!! I highly recommended!

William Collins

Stopped in Today with my wife, after enjoying the fall foliage. Had some wings,some beer on Tap and took home the Drunken Grandma Pizza, and a slice of the Chicken Marsala. Everything was Excellent! Will definitely stop in again. Service was Excellent as well.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Sirimaturos

My favorite place to eat when we come back to visit our cadet at West Point. Pizzas are fantastic and my wife loves the eggplant dishes. Today we tried the Drunk Grandma with the Sicilian crust. Wife had the Eggplant Siciliana and it’s her favorite. I try to get a different pizza each time we’re back. Highly recommend

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

John Spadafino

Outstanding!!!!!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free and dairy free

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Brick Oven Pizza, Pizza Mozzarella, Garlic Knots

LM MF

If you are in the area this restaurant is a must visit. They are slowly but lovingly restoring the Old Oak Inn and it’s charming. They have a full Italian menu and have recently added beer and wine. The pizza is amazing…my favorite is the ‘Grandma’ with crispy crust, delicious thick Tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella. Both indoor and outdoor seating

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...