Papa Joe's Pizzeria
59 Main St, Fort Plain
(518) 993-3200
Customers' Favorites
Hawaiian Pizza Extra Dark
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
Personal Pizza Cheese
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Large Pepperoni Pizza
Chicken Wing Pizza
Boneless Wings
Chicken Riggies
Slice of Pizza
Garlic Knots
Menu
Photos
+24 photos
+23 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
This place is the absolute BEST !!!! Beth and Charissa are the best !!! Beth ALWAYS is smiling and makes it very welcoming !!!! The pizza , calzones, and wings are to die for!!!! Their prices are unbeatable!!! THANK YOU PAPA JOE'S FOR BEING THE ABSOLUTE BEST !!!
rode the Erie Trail last week. After a hard morning on Saturday trying to stay ahead of the rain, we decided to stop in at Papa Joe's in Fort Plain. Are we glad we did! The largest pizza slice we've ever seen. Good New York style. But the best was the staff. They appreciated us coming in and let us hang out for 2.5 hours while the heavy rain came down. They did a very busy carryout for that little small village. Great place to stop if you are in the neighborhood or on...
As an out of state visitor I kept being told I needed to try true NY pizza. This place was super quaint and the workers seemed to enjoy working with each other. The food was quite good, we had pizza and wings. The mid size pizza was a great sharing size for four people, the original buffalo wings were also very good as well. The chicken was cooked perfectly and there was a perfect amount of sauce on each wing.
You May Also Like
New York Pizzeria - 68 Main St
![]()
Pizza, Italian
Erie Station - 7 Canal St
![]()
Pubs, American, Pet Friendly, New American
Mediterranean Kitchen - 18 Canal St
![]()
Mediterranean, Kebab