I had the small and 15 wings. The pizza is very nice. Light, fresh, and the sauce is spot on. Perfect combo of savory with a hint of sweet. That's pizza sauce! Great job!
linda zayas
We've been wanting to try this place for so long time,but limited hours have made it difficult. Finally we got our schedules to coincide only to be terribly disappointed by the lack of service we received. Never got to order waited 10 minutes after sitting and no one ever came to our table. It's Mother's Day. We were never greeted, just told to take 1 of 3 tables. Only had pizza & wing menu on table. They had a table of 6, waiting for food, a table of 4 that got their food as we came in and a 3 top. 2 people waiting for pick up or to order food that said they were waiting 30 minutes for burgers to go. We left when a new party of 8 came in were seated with silverware and menus and we were still ignored. Too bad as we heard foods good, guess we'll never know
Matt Campbell
This place is always innovating and constantly active on Facebook. Daily special menus are bigger than a lot of places normal menus.
John Kalkowsky
Frank's favorite chicken sandwich 😍
Sherry Annutto
Took our two adult children recently for their birthday dinners. Was busy for a Sunday night, but our waitress ( she was just filling in) was awesome and attentive, we were so pleased with the service, the food and comfortable atmosphere. Also appreciate the health conscious menu changes, without compromising flavor. Highly recommend! Much prefer to support our local businesses over fast food chains! Visit 1886 soon😊
tom murtaugh
Great food
Jimmy Dean
THAT CRUNCH🍕!!! 🤯 Unbelievable! (House Pie) With that crunch and that sauce or should I say gravy😋, makes for an unforgettable, possibly ledendary experience. Perfect sauce to cheese to crust ratio, honestly can't wait to try everything else!
Nicole V
Food is always delicious and the service is ALWAYS top notch!
Irene Pfluke
Dined in tonight. 6 of us. 2 pizzas 50 wings 2 pasta dinners and poutine. 1 cheesecake to go. Everything was PHENOMENAL. Waitress was attentive with a fabulous personality. The food came out quick and hot and was top notch. The final bill was extremely reasonable especially for the amount of food we got and brought home! we live in Whitesboro and would definitely make the drive out to eat there again!!!
zach bellinger
Ordered online for the first time. I've never had your pizza. Very tasty! Good solid base and good top. Will order again.
Every visit to this restaurant feels like navigating a culinary minefield of disappointment. From the moment you walk in, something is guaranteed to go wrong. Service Nightmares The staff seem perpetually confused, with orders consistently mixed up or completely forgotten. What should be a simple dining experience turns into an exhausting ordeal of corrections and apologies. Specific Frustrations • Ordered a medium-rare steak? Expect well-done. • Asked for no onions? Prepare for a mountain of them. • Requested a specific side dish? They’ll inevitably substitute something entirely different.
The food is very good when correct and on time - although an exceedingly rare occurrence.
Manuel Mannino
Best pizza hands down met the owner great guy
Michael Rando
didn’t get meatballs on my raviolis th egg replaced it with chicken instead of asking. didn’t get my garlic knots at all and closed right when i left so i couldn’t get them. chicken looks like piece of flat slab.
Amir Covic
Best pizza and burgers in Upstate,NY everything is made from scratch:)
Ciara Sweezey
My grama and I ordered takeout here! Very great ravioli & meatballs!! Def recommend. ☺️
I had the small and 15 wings. The pizza is very nice. Light, fresh, and the sauce is spot on. Perfect combo of savory with a hint of sweet. That's pizza sauce! Great job!
We've been wanting to try this place for so long time,but limited hours have made it difficult. Finally we got our schedules to coincide only to be terribly disappointed by the lack of service we received. Never got to order waited 10 minutes after sitting and no one ever came to our table. It's Mother's Day. We were never greeted, just told to take 1 of 3 tables. Only had pizza & wing menu on table. They had a table of 6, waiting for food, a table of 4 that got their food as we came in and a 3 top. 2 people waiting for pick up or to order food that said they were waiting 30 minutes for burgers to go. We left when a new party of 8 came in were seated with silverware and menus and we were still ignored. Too bad as we heard foods good, guess we'll never know
This place is always innovating and constantly active on Facebook. Daily special menus are bigger than a lot of places normal menus.
Frank's favorite chicken sandwich 😍
Took our two adult children recently for their birthday dinners. Was busy for a Sunday night, but our waitress ( she was just filling in) was awesome and attentive, we were so pleased with the service, the food and comfortable atmosphere. Also appreciate the health conscious menu changes, without compromising flavor. Highly recommend! Much prefer to support our local businesses over fast food chains!
Visit 1886 soon😊
Great food
THAT CRUNCH🍕!!! 🤯 Unbelievable! (House Pie) With that crunch and that sauce or should I say gravy😋, makes for an unforgettable, possibly ledendary experience. Perfect sauce to cheese to crust ratio, honestly can't wait to try everything else!
Food is always delicious and the service is ALWAYS top notch!
Dined in tonight. 6 of us. 2 pizzas 50 wings 2 pasta dinners and poutine. 1 cheesecake to go. Everything was PHENOMENAL. Waitress was attentive with a fabulous personality. The food came out quick and hot and was top notch. The final bill was extremely reasonable especially for the amount of food we got and brought home! we live in Whitesboro and would definitely make the drive out to eat there again!!!
Ordered online for the first time. I've never had your pizza. Very tasty! Good solid base and good top. Will order again.
Restaurantji Recommends
Every visit to this restaurant feels like navigating a culinary minefield of disappointment. From the moment you walk in, something is guaranteed to go wrong.
Service Nightmares
The staff seem perpetually confused, with orders consistently mixed up or completely forgotten. What should be a simple dining experience turns into an exhausting ordeal of corrections and apologies.
Specific Frustrations
• Ordered a medium-rare steak? Expect well-done.
• Asked for no onions? Prepare for a mountain of them.
• Requested a specific side dish? They’ll inevitably substitute something entirely different.
The food is very good when correct and on time - although an exceedingly rare occurrence.
Best pizza hands down met the owner great guy
didn’t get meatballs on my raviolis th egg replaced it with chicken instead of asking. didn’t get my garlic knots at all and closed right when i left so i couldn’t get them. chicken looks like piece of flat slab.
Best pizza and burgers in Upstate,NY everything is made from scratch:)
My grama and I ordered takeout here! Very great ravioli & meatballs!! Def recommend. ☺️
Loading...